• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Spoilers Star Trek: Prodigy 1x14 - "Crossroads"

Rate the episode...


  • Total voters
    66
Yes, the Federation learned in 2381 that the star in the Romulus system was going to go nova. Picard was then promoted to spearhead the evacuation efforts.

The Romulan government felt having their own ships partake in the evacuation efforts would be viewed as a confirmation of an event they were trying to publicly deny.
Where is 2381 specified in canon? Because I can only find references to the Federation/Romulan’s finding out about the impending supernova in the 2380’s… no exact year? Do you have a link please? :)

Also, it could be coincidence but the new Prodigy game is all about a Supernova… I know that there is probably no link to the Romulan’s in this game but at least the crew would have experience in dealing with this kind of thing. :shrug:
4396ED2F-E583-4544-BFC9-3BE7A8FD86D0.jpeg
 
Last edited:
If the Protostar was that small (compared to the Vice Admiral Janeways) what must the crew compliment have been? And really makes me wonder about its mission.

loved the episode. 8/10
 
Where is 2381 specified in canon? Because I can only find references to the Federation/Romulan’s finding out about the impending supernova in the 2380’s… no exact year? Do you have a link please?

It wasn’t mentioned on screen but it was part of the original backstory for Season 1 of PIC, and was used in tie in novels, comics and for the information plaques in that exhibition thing they did before S1 dropped.

So, canon? I suppose not. But since it was devised by the creators of PIC I’d guess other shows would adhere to it unless a significant story reason required it to be changed.
 
If the Protostar was that small (compared to the Vice Admiral Janeways) what must the crew compliment have been? And really makes me wonder about its mission.

loved the episode. 8/10
It's likely merely so that the scaling of the ships isn't consistent. The Defiant also grew and shrunk depending on the shot.
 
I'm frustrated by the writers forcing plot advancements via orchestrated miscommunications.

All the kids need do is come to a stop and transmit a simple message via morse code on their running lights.

Something like: WE MEAN YOU NO HARM. TORPEDO WAS ACCIDENT. OUR SHIP INFECTED WITH COMPUTER VIRUS. DO NOT INTERFACE WITH OUR COMPUTER. WE DID NOT ATTACK YOUR STATION. REQUEST YOU BEAM ABOARD TO DISCUSS.
 
Do the kids know Morse code?

What I was wondering was, are the ship's shuttles able to act independently enough of Protostar for someone to fly out of the ship and use standard communications to contact Dauntless. I'm guessing the weapon maintains its control over the shuttle's computer, or the kids wouldn't have left Protostar on foot.
 
The Protostar isn’t a warship, Janeway points out that’s a science vessel, the implication being that’s not heavily armed.
Starfleet never calls their ships warships though, not even the Defiant ("escort") or ships that are heavily armed like the Sovereign ("explorer"). The Protostar may be classified as a science ship, but it actually seems to be an ultra long range scout (and explorer, ironically!) and it does seem to have the usual armament (for its size, if not more so) of phasers and torpedoes. Enough to lay waste to multiple large cities, in all likelihood.
 
Do the kids know Morse code?

What I was wondering was, are the ship's shuttles able to act independently enough of Protostar for someone to fly out of the ship and use standard communications to contact Dauntless. I'm guessing the weapon maintains its control over the shuttle's computer, or the kids wouldn't have left Protostar on foot.
Shuttles may or may not be safe, but they can't trust it because the Protostar computers (which are presumably infected) are definitely involved in creating them.

Holo-Janeway certainly would know morsecode (and so would Okona), but what good is it if they don't dare talk to Janeway? Morse code would mean letting the Dauntless in visual range, which they would be terrified of right now. Maybe as a last resort they would do it, if Janeway really has them pinned down.

With Okona on board, they have a likely candidate to be dropped off the ship later to act as their "spokesman" (if Okona is willing to help, of course).
 
Where is 2381 specified in canon? Because I can only find references to the Federation/Romulan’s finding out about the impending supernova in the 2380’s… no exact year? Do you have a link please? :)
As mentioned, the specific year of 2381 does come from the behind the scenes material which was utilized in the tie-in novels and comics. Though, canonically, we know Thad Riker was born in 2381, Deanna notes in Nepenthe (which is canonically set in 2399) that Thad would have been 18 years old were he still alive. And Picard is wearing an Admiral's uniform in the picture of him holding baby Thad. Since it is canonically established that Picard was promoted to Admiral to take control of the evacuation efforts, and he was clearly already an Admiral in 2381, I feel there is sufficient evidence to declare the 2381 date as when the Federation learned of the impending Romulan nova canon.
 
In addition, the plot of the Prodigy tie-in game "Supernova" has nothing to do with the Romulan one. This may also be true of the upcoming episodes of the same name.
 
In addition, the plot of the Prodigy tie-in game "Supernova" has nothing to do with the Romulan one. This may also be true of the upcoming episodes of the same name.
That’s a coincidence. Regardless of what caused the Romulan supernova, it’s too much of a good opportunity not to explore the Federation/Romulan dynamics in this era. We may never get to visit the 24th century again in a dedicated series. I wonder which sun is going supernova in the 2 part season finalé? I guess it could just be a figure of speech ‘supernova’ and we probably shouldn’t take it too literally as meaning that a sun is potentially going to go boom. :shrug:
 
Last edited:
Starfleet never calls their ships warships though, not even the Defiant ("escort") or ships that are heavily armed like the Sovereign ("explorer").
True but irrelevant here: janeway acted surprised at the idea that the protostar was able to destroy the relay station.
Holo-Janeway certainly would know morsecode
She should, but that part of her memory might have been deleted by the diviner. We already know he tampered with her so it’s not unlikely he eliminated from her memory every safe way of communication.

and so would Okona
Okona is an alien, he wouldn’t know human morse code. Even many 24th century humans are not familiar with it in previous series (while others are).
 
The metamorphosis buildup led to a blah reveal, unfortunately. Still give it an 8 for the ability to appeal to adults as well as kids with the show.
I forgot to mention this in my review but I felt the same way about Murph. Underwhelming reveal. Now he can walk, instead of ooze his way around, and make cute squeaky noises. ;) They're going for the baby Yoda character vibe, which is fine, might as well copy a proven and popular character from a successful competitor. We as adult viewers who enjoy the show do have to give it a bit of leeway as we are not the intended audience.
 
True but irrelevant here: janeway acted surprised at the idea that the protostar was able to destroy the relay station).

I don’t think she was surprised that it could, but rather that it did so at all — and the means by which it was destroyed (I.e. a mysterious weapon that caused the station to tear itself apart.)
 
True but irrelevant here: janeway acted surprised at the idea that the protostar was able to destroy the relay station.

She should, but that part of her memory might have been deleted by the diviner. We already know he tampered with her so it’s not unlikely he eliminated from her memory every safe way of communication.
The relay station itself seemed quite well armed and may have decent shielding. Help is a long way off, so it's not illogical to give it reasonable means to defend itself against moderately powerful starships.

I don't think the Diviner would delete something so basic, when holo-Janeway was easily programmable to work for him instead of Starfleet. Gwyn managed to prevent this in "a moral star", but it was clearly his intention. So why cripple her basis functions?
 
I don’t think she was surprised that it could, but rather that it did so at all — and the means by which it was destroyed (I.e. a mysterious weapon that caused the station to tear itself apart.)
then why mention the Protostar being a science vessel?

I don't think the Diviner would delete something so basic, when holo-Janeway was easily programmable to work for him instead of Starfleet. Gwyn managed to prevent this in "a moral star", but it was clearly his intention. So why cripple her basis functions
To prevent her to safely communicate with Starfleet? It’s been already established that parts of her memory have been erased.

They could send a probe with a recorded message.
If the probe is built by the Protostar it could be infected.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top