• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Spoilers Star Trek: Picard 3x05 - "Imposters"

Engage!


  • Total voters
    256
I considered this, but when we see them talking to other Dominion people, they are still in gloss-face. Obviously there’s production reasons for this, but the result in universe is that sense of ‘here is default founder’ setting. I also considered it in relation to them wanting to mirror him in order to make him feel like he belongs to them — which would make a lot of sense too — but again, it is represented again and again as just how they look as humanoids, and why the Jem’Hadar etc recognise him as a founder and therefore a god. Same for the Vorta. It’s like that *is* their appearance, on a base genetic level, when they aren’t being goop.

Not any more than this is the "default painting of humans on a genetic level". It's just easy to draw and someone without any drawing experience may stil ldo it easily.

download.png
 
I considered this, but when we see them talking to other Dominion people, they are still in gloss-face. Obviously there’s production reasons for this, but the result in universe is that sense of ‘here is default founder’ setting. I also considered it in relation to them wanting to mirror him in order to make him feel like he belongs to them — which would make a lot of sense too — but again, it is represented again and again as just how they look as humanoids, and why the Jem’Hadar etc recognise him as a founder and therefore a god. Same for the Vorta. It’s like that *is* their appearance, on a base genetic level, when they aren’t being goop.

Laas?

What an asshole.
 
It's not. He never tried to pass as Bajoran, this doesn't mean he could do it if he wanted to.

So…If changelings can do communicators (even if we're shown that Odo uses a real one and the showrunners of the showy show showed us that they can't) why didn't the one on "The Ship" made one to tell the Vorta where he was?

It would get in the way of further shapeshifting for example in combat.

He can flap tendrils about, and does so, and could run down his own trouser leg if he chose. The real reason is production, and writing, but the end result in the fiction just matches everything else.

Why didn’t the one on The Ship? Because they hadn’t considered it when they wrote it. No different to Odo’s communicator not being a part of him, except when it obviously is. In universe? Maybe they were too tired, maybe Vorta/Dominion communicators work in a different way to how we know Bajoran/Fed ones do. Maybe they use telepathy, and someone had a headache from being solid too long. Maybe they chose not to for some other sneaky reason that served their purpose.

Why didn’t he try to pass as Bajoran? He was raised Bajoran. On the other hand, that was during the occupation. Some mirror universe type Odo somewhere may identify as more cardassian.

Our Odo though is almost protective of his ‘outsider’ status, because that’s something his trauma when young impresses on him, with his complicated relationship with his adopted father and culture. It’s a character trait for him, that we also see reflected in the Founders Xenophobia. I would not normally fuss about the idea of genetic memory, but it the case of the founders, that is pretty front and centre.
Odo is a rare thing for his species. He is an individual. That’s sort of the point.
 
As far as I recall, Odo and the female changeling both refer to themselves and their people as changelings. It was the term "shapeshifter" that was considered to be offensive as it suggests they are 'shifty' and untrustworthy.
Nope, it was definitely the name ‘Changeling’ that was used offensively. Though on occasion Founders have been called shapeshifters on Deep Space Nine.

Perhaps the true story is that someone is hunting down the Founders/Changelings in revenge for the Dominion War? We have been told that this group of Changelings is attempting to get revenge after *losing* the war. The Founders also look strange like they are infected with something - Section 31 has been known to infect Founders with things before. Perhaps Section 31 are behind this and the conspiracy is actually home grown from within Starfleet itself. This would make it all a bit like Star Trek VI: The Undiscovered Country. The Maquis, and thus Ro, along with many other victims of the Dominion may want revenge on the Dominion/Founders after all the Maquis and millions of others were wiped out. This Founder prejudice and purge could run in parallel to Captain Shaw’s own personal story with his thoughts about the Borg having survived Wolf 359, and also to the story of the ex-b’s in season one of Picard. Hopefully Captain Shaw is not involved in this conspiracy though.

The Founders themselves could be being framed for the attack on the Starfleet recruitment center and soon an attempted attack on Frontier Day?

I am not quite sure how Captain Picard’s son Jack fits in to all of this yet though?
 
Eagle eye. Are they just different styles, or unique design to each person? That one she gave Picard was a spy device though, not the one she wore as an ensign.

Surprisingly, some quick Googling didn't turn up a comprehensive catalog of all Bajoran earrings. There's a project for someone. I assumed they'd go by family, since they used to be indicative of caste, but Kira's parents' earrings seem to match each others', and but don't look much like Nerys's (Meru and Taban had more dangly bits, and neither had the distinctive seashell-shape).
 
Not any more than this is the "default painting of humans on a genetic level". It's just easy to draw and someone without any drawing experience may stil ldo it easily.

download.png

Which was in many ways the original point when developing Odo’s look by Westmore. The unfinished sculpture, like the protohumanoids in TNG. But as the story on DS9 progresses, it’s quite apparent something different is going on with why he looks like that, in universe rather than out of it.

And a stick figure is basic iconography, rather than an attempt at ‘default human’ made in complete ignorance. It’s a developed symbol only. Otherwise the head would be a different shape for a start — not every child starts drawing with stick figures unless taught to do so, and the choice of additional details and the order or style in which they add them is always interesting. (Hair, fingers, face, style of facial representation, secondary sex characteristics, clothes, how the clothes are added, ears… sometimes used as developmental markers.) The same is true when looking at what might be labelled ‘primitive art’ or art history in general. But in all those cases, we are talking about external representation of self, and of a group, rather than what in Odo’s case would be an internal representation — he is his own self portrait, with more control than other people. Why does he choose *that* eye colour, in universe? Why mimic the structures of the eye so closely, when he clearly does not need to? If he can do such small and complex detail, how could Bajoran nose ridges, or Cardassian forehead indentation be beyond him?
Perhaps he chooses his default face precisely because to be Bajoran would be to invite more difficulty from the Cardassians, but he does not wish to be Cardassian either for much the same reason.
Better to be something different from both, and better to hang onto whatever identity he can muster.
 
Nope, it was definitely the name ‘Changeling’ that was used offensively. Though on occasion Founders have been called shapeshifters on Deep Space Nine.

Perhaps the true story is that someone is hunting down the Founders/Changelings in revenge for the Dominion War? We have been told that this group of Changelings is attempting to get revenge after *losing* the war. The Founders also look strange like they are infected with something - Section 31 has been known to infect Founders with things before. Perhaps Section 31 are behind this and the conspiracy is actually home grown from within Starfleet itself. This would make it all a bit like Star Trek VI: The Undiscovered Country. The Maquis, and thus Ro, along with many other victims of the Dominion may want revenge on the Dominion/Founders after all the Maquis and millions of others were wiped out. This Founder prejudice and purge could run in parallel to Captain Shaw’s own personal story with his thoughts about the Borg having survived Wolf 359, and also to the story of the ex-b’s in season one of Picard. Hopefully Captain Shaw is not involved in this conspiracy though.

The Founders themselves could be being framed for the attack on the Starfleet recruitment center and soon an attempted attack on Frontier Day?

I am not quite sure how Captain Picard’s son Jack fits in to all of this yet though?

My semi-joking theory that at least one of his parents was a changeling infiltrator, possibly a sleeper that didn’t know it, is looking more likely. As is my joke that Picards Nads still had Borg bits in.
 
Surprisingly, some quick Googling didn't turn up a comprehensive catalog of all Bajoran earrings. There's a project for someone. I assumed they'd go by family, since they used to be indicative of caste, but Kira's parents' earrings seem to match each others', and but don't look much like Nerys's (Meru and Taban had more dangly bits, and neither had the distinctive seashell-shape).

The default is the Kira earring, and easiest to source as merchandise as likely helped here.
 
Ahhh, nope. We call it the East Coast. And NYC is NOT the entire East Coast (nor "the Atlantic Coast").
Whether you call it that or even whether lots of people call it that isn’t really the point. The point is that language works that way. If I said that I lived a couple of miles from the Russian border that narrows it down to about 10,000 km of different locations.

Also from Wikipedia which was the top result for Atlantic border:

“The East Coast of the United States, also known as the Eastern Seaboard, the Atlantic Coast, and the Atlantic Seaboard, is the coastline where the Eastern United States meets the North Atlantic Ocean.”
 
I just noticed we had a roundabout mention of The Doctor with the mobile emitter being recreated with "current" tech and seemingly being a well known thing.
 
Why didn’t the one on The Ship? Because they hadn’t considered it when they wrote it.
except that they had, as stated in multiple interviews. And after all odo is a knockoff in many way of the T-1000 (again, as stated in interviews and they even used the movie to prove it was doable) and in that movie they definitely stated shapeshifters can’t do complex machinery.

when it obviously is
such as when? We never see odo’s communicator becoming goo.

Maybe they were too tired, maybe Vorta/Dominion communicators work in a different way to how we know Bajoran/Fed ones do. Maybe they use telepathy, and someone had a headache from being solid too long.
Maybe you’re again making up stuff to justify your pet theory that has no basis and has been contradicted by the show runners decades ago.
Why didn’t he try to pass as Bajoran? He was raised Bajoran. On the other hand, that was during the occupation. Some mirror universe type Odo somewhere may identify as more cardassian
But Odo always wanted to discover more about his people, not to pass as a solid. Initially, at least, he feels superior to solids anyway.

Surprisingly, some quick Googling didn't turn up a comprehensive catalog of all Bajoran earrings.
surprisingly?
 
I just noticed we had a roundabout mention of The Doctor with the mobile emitter being recreated with "current" tech and seemingly being a well known thing.

Not necessarily.

A generic description.

Processing power and storage.

The EMH is Huge.

The Raffi program is probably tiny.

She does less stuff, for less time.
 
Ahhh, nope. We call it the East Coast. And NYC is NOT the entire East Coast (nor "the Atlantic Coast").

And saying that NYC is not the entire East Coast is exactly my point. The original post said Earth was on the edge of the Alpha Quadrant and therefore the edge of the Alpha quadrant can’t be that far away.
 
As far as I recall, Odo and the female changeling both refer to themselves and their people as changelings. It was the term "shapeshifter" that was considered to be offensive as it suggests they are 'shifty' and untrustworthy.
From MA:
As an adverse reaction to being hunted and rejected by the solids, the Founders accepted the pejorative "Changeling" as their own out of defiance and retreated to a rogue planet in the Omarion Nebula
 
Changing the special effects was dumb.

They look like a different species, and they don't seem to be quantifiable cooler? They look a little like the antimatter monsters from the three doctors.

Serious question...

Would it have been less expensive to fake 90s cgi effects, with whatever animation program that they are using today, or did it cost more to make them look worse?

Showrunner said on twitter there's a reason they look different
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top