• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Spoilers Star Trek: Discovery 4x10 - "The Galactic Barrier"

Rate the episode...


  • Total voters
    124
destroying the Earth in the far future would piss off a huge section of Trek fandom, who would (for some asinine reason) decide that a "bad ending" invalidates everything that came before.

I wouldn't call it asinine.

Much as there were many who complained the "no Federation" at the start of Season 3 implied that the whole thing was futile.

Also understandable.

That said, at least there still was a Federation - just weakened. It wasn't destroyed entirely.

And the difference is, a weakened Federation can be rebuilt. You can't rebuild a PLANET.
 
Last edited:
To view this content we will need your consent to set third party cookies.
For more detailed information, see our cookies page.

What's really shocking about Gilligan's Island is that if you look closely at The Minnow departing Hawaii at the 18 second mark you can clearly see that there are eight people on the ship. Meaning, of course, that someone got blown over during the storm and they never mentioned or thought about him again.

that’s Kovich obviously. Gillian’s Island is actually set in the trekverse.
 
S04E10, "Galactic Barrier"

Pros:
"Cautiously optimistic...ish."
Stamets wanting to be a good dad to Adira and Gray.
Tarka has a heart, and a conscience.
My Owo/Detmer shipping meter.
My Saru/T'Rina shipping meter.


Cons:
Not really any cons so far as I can see this week.

Ruminations:
I was excited to see this episode because it meant we were finally going to move outside the galactic barrier (outer rather than the one at the center of the galaxy). I was not disappointed. I have to say again that the visuals team has delivered top notch work. This series, especially as of late, is looking very pretty, even cinematic. They got rid of the flamethrower walls (thank you), and have toned down the more sillier components (like the fun house turbolift). Design seems to be pretty well set at this point.

Speaking of, I liked the reduced saturation effect. It's nice to see what we take for granted as a universal constant actually having limitations. Again, well done.

We get some background on Tarka, having been captured and placed in an Emerald Chain mining camp, his friendship with Oros, and the outcome of that friendship. Some solid unpacking done for this. The power dynamics between President Rillak and Michael ended up being beneficial for both, and they opened up to one another a little more.

You know, on that note, I like that our crew has more compassion, more empathy for people. That's something American audiences desperately need in their entertainment media, IMO. For too long it's been the given that showing that kind of empathy and compassion is either played for laughs, or is to be seen as weakness. Sometimes Discovery takes a very obvious, well walked path, gloms onto tropes I wish they wouldn't, but in this case they've diverted course and taken what I'd like to think is the higher path. So three cheers for that positive change. I'd like to see more of it.

This episode gets an 8/10. I can't wait to see what we get next week.
 
A Lava Lamp with bits of lightning and other things in the mix.

The GB was pretty cool looking.

But did you think that Gilligan's Island "3 Hour Tour" proverb would last over 1000 years into the future?
I could see it lasting. I recently used that 3 hour tour quote in real life. It's synonymous with me as a complaint for anything I don't want to do, or think will end badly.
 
Aren't there ancient proverbs we still use today?
  • The die is cast (Roman)
  • Carpe diem (literally Latin)
  • To err is human
  • Rest in peace
  • Take it with a grain of salt
  • Give up the ghost (bible)
  • Rise and shine (bible)
  • By the skin of your teeth (bible)
Etc...

I wouldn't call it asinine.

Nothing lasts forever, and in the long run we're all dead. It's ridiculous to presume that the Federation/Earth will last for eternity in the Trekverse, if for no other reason than because we don't meet million/billion year old alien races.

Regardless, in storytelling what matters is the now, not the future. It's why we can enjoy say a historical drama that takes place during the Roman Empire, or Arthurian legend. Within the context of the story, there can be a satisfying closure, which is good enough.
 
It’s possible as Earth has played such a small part these past two seasons, but I sincerely doubt it. Pushing that story would definitely bring the show into a more grimdark (God I hate that term) view. Despite what some think of the current iterations, Star Trek is not grimdark. It is an optimistic vision of the future. Destroying our world would certainly be REALLY dark.

Well, it would make sense cos Starfleet Academy takes place on New Earth. From leaked emails from early last year... I wondered what it meant, but now it seems clear to me: the DMA is going to destroy Earth and we're going to built a new, better Earth that joins the Federation again.
 
One issue I had with the Tarka/Oros story is from what Oros said about the alternate universe, it basically just sounded like his race's version of heaven. He offered no proof whatsoever that it actually existed. I was surprised that Tarka as a scientist could be so credulous, but imprisonment does weird things to a mind.

I really hope Oros doesn't end up to be behind the DMA with glowy silver eyes. It would basically result in Season 4 being a retread of Season 3, where a huge galactic threat was actually caused by a manchild with godlike powers who felt a feeling.

Oh my god. I think you just nailed it!
 
Well, it would make sense cos Starfleet Academy takes place on New Earth. From leaked emails from early last year... I wondered what it meant, but now it seems clear to me: the DMA is going to destroy Earth and we're going to built a new, better Earth that joins the Federation again.

We will just have to wait and see, won’t we?
 
T'rina is Vulcan. Vulcans are not known for bearing their souls or emotional connections. Vulcan relationships are ritualistic and logical.

Current Vulcans are probably not pure anymore as they share a planet for a long time with bio-compatible Romulans. Relationships are probably not as ritualistic and logical as they once were.

To view this content we will need your consent to set third party cookies.
For more detailed information, see our cookies page.

What's really shocking about Gilligan's Island is that if you look closely at The Minnow departing Hawaii at the 18 second mark you can clearly see that there are eight people on the ship. Meaning, of course, that someone got blown over during the storm and they never mentioned or thought about him again.

Only 7. Your "8th" person is the (top side) steering column for the ship.
 
Boring, boring, boring. This one just didn’t work at all for me, felt like the fourth filler episode in a row. The season Enders better be exceptional!

The president is still great and admiral Vance is good as always.

The galactic barrier effects are incredibly generic and underwhelming. The original effect was simple but iconic this is…really forgettable.

So nobody left the galaxy in all the centuries since Kirk and Picard? And how come it’s suddenly so difficult? The original enterprise crossed at least twice (with some difficulties, but still), the D went trough with no issue at all…

Also, the micelial network is limited to our galaxy? I’m glad they nerfed it a bit, but didn’t they say in season 1 that it permeated the universe?

A big background dump on tarka’s history that doesn’t really add much: we were told at least what had happened in past episodes, even if in less detail. And Booker is now totally onboard with him again just because.

Another cast member leaves but I don’t even remember his name anyway.

Burnham delivered her over the top speech of the season, hopefully there won’t be another.

Not much else to say, as there isn’t really much else in this episode. Nice they are bringing forward the saru/t’rina thing, and obviously doing it with great care in showing a different, alien approach to relationships. Also nice to have Adira back, even if she was pretty much just there with little to do (and what was that about with Staley’s?).

6. Well, next week Picard is back and I hope to have plenty of fun with that. Also, as said, I hope all these fillers are justified by a splendid season finale.

Ah, the camera work wasn’t as distracting as I feared reading who the director was. Mostly, anyway.
 
So nobody left the galaxy in all the centuries since Kirk and Picard? And how come it’s suddenly so difficult? The original enterprise crossed at least twice (with some difficulties, but still), the D went trough with no issue at all…
It seems like there are two possible answers. The barrier was much stronger at that point than expected. Or Discovery just has really terrible shields that disappear to nothing in seconds regardless of what's hitting them or how much they upgrade them.

Also, the micelial network is limited to our galaxy? I’m glad they nerfed it a bit, but didn’t they say in season 1 that it permeated the universe?
They've shown that the network can have gaps, so maybe the barrier is just a very big gap.

A big background dump on tarka’s history that doesn’t really add much: we were told at least what had happened in past episodes, even if in less detail. And Booker is now totally onboard with him again just because.
Yeah, I was a bit confused by the flashback because it seemed to be spending a lot of precious time telling me what I already knew.

Another cast member leaves but I don’t even remember his name anyway.
Bryce! Also I didn't even realise he was leaving.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top