Point remains. She's not a cadet and hasn't been one for a while.
She wasn't there to be "tactical".
Spoilers Star Trek: Discovery 4x03 - "Choose to Live"
- Thread starter Commander Richard
- Start date
She wasn't there to be "tactical".
I want Gray and Adira to break up. Gray needs to find himself in his new existence. Once the novelty of the new body starts to fade, I can imagine him undergoing an identity crisis. He's (presumably) the memories from Tal that it absorbed from the original (real?) Gray during their brief joining, and has no memories from Tal or the other hosts, including Adira. I imagine he doesn't remember how to play the cello, for instance. Who is he? And should he really be attached to someone he entirely depended on for existence for months? Maybe they can get back together some day, but I think they really need time apart.
At best, she's the Negotiator on the team due to her lack of threatening presence/aura
&
She's the science/engineering person on the away team.
5 or 6 worst one in awhile..
Few nice bits but mostly meh.
No Nvar pres and Saru flirting? Darn..
As for the moon .. Could have had just low warp.. Even at lightspeed.. The universe is huge. Think Aliens or ECS taking months between systems.
Few nice bits but mostly meh.
No Nvar pres and Saru flirting? Darn..
As for the moon .. Could have had just low warp.. Even at lightspeed.. The universe is huge. Think Aliens or ECS taking months between systems.
Space is big.
It's highly likely the writers and directors forgot that in their rush to push Tilly into screen-time.
Perhaps someone can write them a note for next time.?
If they've ignored everything on that end for the past 3 seasons I don't think they care about the show enough to pay attention to that sort of thing.
Prediction for the Season: The Qiwot Milot are going to be a problem as Ni'Var rejoins the Federation. Or, at some point, T'Rina wants to do things in a way that Rillak isn't going to approve of and that's going to create some wedge. I expect Ni'Var to actually rejoin the Federation, but there's going to be a monkey wrench or a speed bump along the way.
A note about Culber: This is where it's the most obvious this is a series that Michelle Paradise inherited. I think if it was her series from the beginning, but with the same characters, she would've just had Pollard as the Doctor, and would've made Culber the Counselor; full-time as opposed to pulling double-duty. That just seems to be the difference between what the writers thought of versus how it's starting to play out in progress.
A note about Culber: This is where it's the most obvious this is a series that Michelle Paradise inherited. I think if it was her series from the beginning, but with the same characters, she would've just had Pollard as the Doctor, and would've made Culber the Counselor; full-time as opposed to pulling double-duty. That just seems to be the difference between what the writers thought of versus how it's starting to play out in progress.
Last edited:
You don't know until you write them. A little kindness goes a long way.
Because she wasn't there as a tactical officer. Did you even pay attention to the episode?
Wasn't she there for her intuitive diplomatic skills?
Yes. Saru pointed out that Burham and the two nuns would probably be enough.
Of course he didn't.
Next weeks episode also seems to have plots not directly related to the anomaly.
The preview scene at the end of this week's Ready Room showed David Cronenberg's character with Adira and Tilly, they're apparently going to go on a mission with some cadets to help teach leadership and interpersonal skills.
Last edited:
But that's been the SOP since TOS as well (IE - There were a few episodes where they beamed to planet/ship with shields up); but it's something that continued with TNG (another example is TNG S4 - "The Wounded - Yes O'Brien DOES been thorough the shield the the U.S. S. Phoenix, but only because of an engineering 'glitch' he knows about on that particular ship..)
Sorry, but this just isn't the case. TNG Tech Manual page 139 "The annular confinement beam that serves as the transmission medium for the transporter beam requires such a wide EM and subspace bandwidth that it is normally impossible to transport through shields."
Even when O'Brien does it in The Wounded, it's only because he found a "window" when the shield was refreshing. He could exploit it due to his specific familiarity with Federation tech.
--Of course the real world answer is that transporting through shields is plot dependent, but generally, it is established that when shields are up, transporters cannot be used.
Shouldn’t the interiors of this StarFleet ship have looked much more different than the 23rd century design inside? Or did that look just happen to come back into favor with the same red alert klaxon lol
He wants to be a guardian so I don't see how that gels with Adira wanting to be a Starfleet officer. There may be trouble ahead
Similar threads
- Poll
- Poll
- Poll
