• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Spoilers Star Trek: Discovery 1x10 - "Despite Yourself"

Rate the episode...


  • Total voters
    344
Saru said it was currently patrolling somewhere and Lorca said that obviously at some point in the future it would get to the mirror universe

Though the Defiant went from the regular universe to the MU, it also traveled backwards in time. I wonder if the Discovery followed their footsteps, if it would then end up going forward in time...
 
If an interspatial rift becomes involved then I suppose it's possible, though given the timeframe of the series I imagine any trip into the past or the future would be temporary and the Discovery would end up back home in 2257 where she left.
 
While there were some interesting moments in this it still feels very cartoony to me.
It also felt rather rushed but that’s Frakes style.
cartoony for STD perhaps, the TOS and TNG, ENT MU were much more cartoon like.
 
Piss off. I have given 7 and 8 to most episodes. This was a much better episode than anything they’ve done so far. Writing, acting, and directing were all much better than anything so far. As a regular posted I don’t blindly give every episode a 10.

Oooo look at you. 7s and 8s. Yup, that makes all the difference. Definitely not preaching to the choir then.

Enjoy the insular echo chamber.
 
So I'm a teeny bit concerned about the Mirror Discovery having almost certainly been transposed with Discovery-Prime. Given how successful Mirror-Kirk and company were at being incognito when the same thing happened (dammit, will happen) to them, there's probably some trouble brewing back in the ol' normal universe.

Production-design wise, the new Terran Empire logos are clever but, you know, too clever. The sword replaced with an upside-down delta. The mirrored Earth is a step too far. Is mirror-Earth actually backwards from our Earth in terms of the continents? That's wacky.

Also, I'm pretty sure this the first time a character on-screen has actually said the word "mirror" in reference to anything from the mirror universe.

I know some folks aren't gung-ho on that particular storyline, but I'm curious to see whether or not Ash is going to fight who he truly is, or accept it and revert back to his old self. Right now, he's horrified, but that could change. Then there's his murder of Culber, which was crazy. I honestly have no idea where it's going to go.

The way he keeps spacing out, combined with the Manchurian Candidate shout-out, makes me think that Tyler qua Tyler probably doesn't even remember killing Culber. Fat lot of difference that makes.

Anyway, now we know how things are going to end for him; Burnham makes a set of Klingon Icons, all of which are Kahless, and tries to override his Klingon programming with new instructions that way.

I’d rather they not, it would stick out.

We saw Shenzhou and Discovery side-by-side in this episode, and they were nearly as different from each other as a faithful TOS ship would be from either of them in terms of coloration and hull styling, and it didn't seem that odd. Never mind all the mismatched Starfleet ships we saw in the TNG-era. Excelsiors, Mirandas, Galaxies, and Akiras hardly seem to go together until you see them next to each other every week.

One of the pilots in the Klingon Raider was an andorian, is there a good shot of it?

Nope, but in the preview, we saw an Andorian from behind in the group shot of people walking towards a building outdoors (white hair and an antenna peaking up), so it seems pretty certain we'll probably see one's face before too long.
 
The way he keeps spacing out, combined with the Manchurian Candidate shout-out, makes me think that Tyler qua Tyler probably doesn't even remember killing Culber. Fat lot of difference that makes.

Anyway, now we know how things are going to end for him; Burnham makes a set of Klingon Icons, all of which are Kahless, and tries to override his Klingon programming with new instructions that way.
Possibly. Ash has actually grown on me. I'd like to see him either win out over his old Voq personality, or that, as Voq, he rejects what he once believed and embraces his new life.
 
That's not the Connie, merely a placeholder. And a tarted up one at that. All it was missing were the tassels.
 
Defiant timeline:
2155 or so - Prime Universe Defiant 'found' by MU Jonathan Archer - ship was towed to the gravity well of a dead star as I recall
slightly later in 2155 - Hoshi Sato knifes Archer and takes the Defiant as her own, declares herself empress
later (not sure when) - bookverse - Sato is successful in what I suspect is a coup of sorts - haven't read the books yet, sorry Mr. Bennett!
2250 or so? Discovery switcheroo between universes
2267 or so? Enterprise switcheroo between universes
also 2267 or so - Tholian web as Defiant fades in and out, eventually disappearing

So! Defiant is still active on Prime Universe side during DISCO.

QED
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top