Poll Rank the Picard Seasons

[BillJ]

Discovery makes Picard look really, really bad and that says something about it. Based on my thoughts about Discovery.

 

[Lord Garth]

Disco 1: The show that Brian Fuller sorta maybe wanted. Kind of
Disco 2: The Unintended Prequel Season to Strange New Worlds
Disco 3-5: the actual show.

I agree with this assessment.

 

[Ray Hardgrit]

Oh oh, I want to rank all the shows combined now.

1. Disco S2 - Dumb as hell but rarely boring.
2. Picard S3 - Despite its issues it builds to proper payoffs.
3. Disco S1 - I'm not keen on the Klingons or Terrans, but it kept things interesting.
4. Picard S1 - Nepenthe's doing a lot of heavy lifting here.
5. Disco S5 - Love the adventurous tone, but the Moll and L'ak stuff drags it down.
6. Disco S4 - Proper sci-fi ideas, really unnatural dialogue.
7. Disco S3 - Started great, then drove right off a space cliff.
8. Picard S2 - I enjoyed this more than most perhaps, but c'mon.
9. SNW S2 - I really liked three stories, the rest not so much.
10. SNW S1 - So traditional that it has the traditionally weak season 1.

Though I haven't rewatched much of it since it came out. Only really Picard and maybe Disco's first season.