Posted by Captain96:
B
Interesting but no explanation of how Archer was captured and the easy rescue keep it from an A.
I agree. I gave it a B- for these same reasons.
Decent episode, nice to see all the sets from TUC again

Posted by Captain96:
B
Interesting but no explanation of how Archer was captured and the easy rescue keep it from an A.
Posted by EarlFlynn:
I really hope we see follow-ups to the issues presented in this episode. If we don't, it'll lose almost all of its impact.
Posted by James Dixon:
I'll give it a "C" and for obvious reasons already stated here... Though it's Amazing how much Praise this episode was given (probably because the supposed Writer hangs around here? I Wouldn't be surprised!)...
I still stand behind it being a cheap ripoff of ST VI... Untlike ST VI, this one was putting me to sleep! I was waiting for the plot to actually Move On to Rura Penthe... And by the time it did...well...the ending was another Bad-written Joke!
What's all this about "Klingon development" and all I've been reading here? Did we See the same episode? Did I fall asleep at a crucial time? Kolos gives a couple lines about "we're not all warrior" and this is "Klingon development" eh?!
On the Treknical side (You KNEW this was coming!)... That doesn't look like a D-5 to me! And to add fuel to the fire: a D-5 battlecruiser of this era with Warp 6 capacity??!!!
Huh? What? Huh? What? No, I'll let YOU GUYS do the math, factor in the years between E and TOS, and gripe about warp drive development (bad enough we had an episode the other season stating that Vulcan ships can do warp 6 or 7!!)...
Maybe Earth should just tuck their head and hide in the sand... Maybe they DID tuck their head and hide in the sand, since Pike's Enterprise could only reach warp 7 a century later!
Posted by Dennis Bailey:
snip
Originally posted by Ptrope :
it was really the story of Kolos' redemption, not Archer's adventure.
We use essential cookies to make this site work, and optional cookies to enhance your experience.