Grade "Judgment"

[Astrozac]

I gave it B or B+ short memory. It was good and a strong episode overall. For all the bitching about TUC, yes it does resemble it but the focus wasn't exactly on the trial. It was talking more about Klingon society.

 

[Xenoclone]

Posted by Scotty:
It was good but I hoped they'd push the envelope a bit more with this story. We all knew Archer wasn't going to stay in Rura Penthe and I wonder why the writers didn't opt to keep Archer there for two or three episodes. There was enough story for a two parter in my opinion and I would've liked to see the crew try and fail to reason with the Klingons and try to get Archer back, perhaps even until the very end of the season in which the story concluded in a dramatic finale. Still, this episode was a step in the right direction. I really like the Kolos character and the trail was well done. I'd rate this episode a 7/10.

I feel the same way, but really this is more of a compliment to the epsiode. It's making us say, "Why did you give us more?"

 

[dtm2476]

B+ I would of liked to see how Archer got captured. Other than that, Judgement was an entertaining episode. It showed continuity and I can't understand why people look at it as a ripoff. It pays homage to TUC. J.G. Hertzler is just wonderful. I loved him as Martok on DS9, and I hope that we'll see him again on Enterprise. Next to Worf, he is at the top of my list for portraying a Klingon.

 

[Guest]

I gave it an A- it was over all good but that ending
I think though that the antitransporter sheild was not there because they were probably less common or existant.

 

[where'sSaavik?]

**Unpinning thread for new episode**

 

[cooleddie74]

A.

One of the best of the recent episodes,in spite of Rura Penthe not looking as savage and inhospitable as it did in STAR TREK VI(chalk that up to smaller TV budgets,I suppose)...

 

[JiNX-01]

Re: Grade "Judgment"

again: 4th bro, klaus, auntiehill

 

[captcalhoun]

Re: Grade "Judgment"

okay, this is weird. Mutant avatar thread from GSF&F becomes ENT forum 'Judgement' thread immediately upon voting...

biz-arre!