• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Best Star Trek Ever

I’m loving Discovery for multiple reasons. I need to see another season (soon!) before I could accurately rank it against the other Star Trek series. However, in the previous series, I never started out hating every character, then coming to love every character, and now to being on edge that they are going to kill another one that I now love. I’ve got a level of engagement with this show I don’t think I’ve ever had in the past.

PS every ep gets better after multiple viewings...
 
Noname Given said:
Struggling? Hardly it would seem:
https://www.forbes.com/sites/ianmor...overy-is-an-unstoppable-monster/#714a0d53152e


So, it's fully compliant with all recent post 1987 and classic Star Trek then. ;) Got it.
Click to expand...
Agreed.
Greg Cox said:
My take: If we're going to compare to DISCO to the previous shows, we should compare it to the shows as they actually were, not to some idealized, rose-tinted memory of them.
Click to expand...
"Nostalgic" or "comfortable" would also be terms I would use in terms of idealization. DISCO is uncomfortable, unfamiliar, and difficult to put in to a category.
 
Did you actually read the story behind the headline? 'Unstoppable Monster' :wtf: Fair enough people need to pay for it (and other shows) in their subscription. I do, that is one of the reasons I have watched because I'm bloody well paying for it. Next season - probably not. At the end of this month cycle it (Netflix) goes. However back to the article. Credibility for the hyperbolic unstoppable monster shout is all talk, literally. People talking about it - wahoo. Further in the piece we have this uncomfortable fact "All of this should be good news for CBS All Access, but the company isn’t releasing numbers of subscribers for its streaming service."

It will always come down to the bottom line - money. As long as Discovery translates to money it will be worth trotting out in any form. It has its first two seasons (really, barely one of other Trek).
 
fireproof78 said:
It was question, not a comment. However, the context seemed to imply negativity, CBS not releasing numbers, cancelling subscription, etc.
Click to expand...
No, the context is just the mechanics of the business of paid entertainment (TV). The article alluded to a flimsy premise of talk. 'Show me the money' ;)
 
Although DIS is only a season in, I consider it the worst Star Trek series, even worse than ENT. At least season 4 Of ENT was good which is one more season than DIS. I personally believe there has been no good Star Trek made since VOY ended....
 
I’m enjoying Discovery, but it really needs to find its feet and rethink its colour palette. It’s not as crisp or vibrant other series on right now. It’s most recent direction has taken a turn for the worse IMO.

TNG was my Trek and I’d happily pay to watch a new series set on a different galaxy class starship that overlapped with Picards mission. Just send them in the other direction and don’t do epic galactic wars. It’s been done, better, else where.
 
Wow, this thread is a blast from the past that was brought back from the dead.

My opinion hasn't changed. I'd love to call DSC my favorite Trek series, but I'm not going to do that yet. I need to see Season 2. And maybe even a little of Season 3, once Pike is gone, and we have a better overall sense of how the series is going to be on a Series Level instead of just a Season Level.

S2 seems like a different animal and I'm of the mindset of if Burnham is a constant, then the Captain makes the season because it looks like it'll always be a different one.
 
Lord Garth said:
Wow, this thread is a blast from the past that was brought back from the dead.

My opinion hasn't changed. I'd love to call DSC my favorite Trek series, but I'm not going to do that yet. I need to see Season 2. And maybe even a little of Season 3, once Pike is gone, and we have a better overall sense of how the series is going to be on a Series Level instead of just a Season Level.

S2 seems like a different animal and I'm of the mindset of if Burnham is a constant, then the Captain makes the season because it looks like it'll always be a different one.
Click to expand...

Nothing could ever dethrone TOS for me. That series is practically written into my DNA. So the race now is for second place. That's a tough one. TNG has more nostalgia, and for some reason more rewatchability for me, but DS9 is a better, more engaging series. DSC is still young, but it's hit some great notes with me and I find it more "Star Trekish" than most of what we got post 1987. I think S2 is going to tell me a lot!
 
Attentiveluke said:
Although DIS is only a season in, I consider it the worst Star Trek series, even worse than ENT. At least season 4 Of ENT was good which is one more season than DIS. I personally believe there has been no good Star Trek made since VOY ended....
Click to expand...
Thus far, events support your assertion.
 
Definitely best Star Trek ever. Production values, filmed in HD, full use of cgi models. Uniforms most high quality of any series. Set design and construction look like kelvin sets that we’re built for a movie. Budget largest of any Trek show ever made iirc. It looks amazing. The marketing has been good and it’s situated within the most modern form of televised entertainment vis. streaming and Netflix.
 
TNG is easily the best Star Trek show (or any show really) closely followed by TOS; others are far (faaar!) behind. Whilst I really haven't liked Disco thus far, I am engaged, it doesn't bore me like Voyager (I probably still haven't seen all of it, probably, can't remember, don't care) so in that sense it is more like DS9.
 
If I had to rank it right now...

TOS







DS9
DSC

TNG








ENT




VOY

(and to be clear...I LIKE all of them...this just illustrates the "relative" position of each)
 
I Am Kirok said:
If I had to rank it right now...

TOS







DS9
DSC

TNG








ENT




VOY

(and to be clear...I LIKE all of them...this just illustrates the "relative" position of each)
Click to expand...
If one must compare (as seems inevitable) then I would agree with this position, though I would tie VOY and ENT. It just depends on the episode for me if I'm going to watch it.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

E
  • Locked
Why Star Trek Discovery Failed to Impress Hardcore Fans
Replies
6
Views
2K
T'Bonz
T'Bonz
WarpTenLizard
Titling a "Star Trek" parody series.
Replies
18
Views
593
Callum MacLeod
Callum MacLeod
B
Ideas: Star Trek/Galactic Civilizations crossover.
Replies
0
Views
217
BohandiAnsoid
B
E
Is Pocket Books embarrassed about allowing Ishmael's crossover to slip through?
2 3
Replies
44
Views
3K
Saul
Saul
Charles Phipps
Spoilers Star Trek: Resurgence story thread
Replies
13
Views
2K
Charles Phipps
Charles Phipps
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top