• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

colossal squids


The linked article said:
Alien-like Squid With "Elbows" Filmed at Drilling Site
I'll start being concerned when they evolve opposable thumbs.
They already have opposable arms, which enables them to do all the things that we can do with hands, like opening a bottle.
 

The linked article said:
Alien-like Squid With "Elbows" Filmed at Drilling Site
I'll start being concerned when they evolve opposable thumbs.
They have brains in their arms, to the point where a severed octopus arm will still hunt for food on its own and are pretty smart for something that we eat. In captivity, they'll sneak out of their tanks and steal fish to eat from other tanks and sneak back in.

They don't need thumbs.
 

The linked article said:
Alien-like Squid With "Elbows" Filmed at Drilling Site
I'll start being concerned when they evolve opposable thumbs.
They have brains in their arms, to the point where a severed octopus arm will still hunt for food on its own and are pretty smart for something that we eat. In captivity, they'll sneak out of their tanks and steal fish to eat from other tanks and sneak back in.

They don't need thumbs.

Wow! Thank goodness Vulcan is more of a desert planet!
 

The linked article said:
Alien-like Squid With "Elbows" Filmed at Drilling Site
I'll start being concerned when they evolve opposable thumbs.
They have brains in their arms, to the point where a severed octopus arm will still hunt for food on its own and are pretty smart for something that we eat. In captivity, they'll sneak out of their tanks and steal fish to eat from other tanks and sneak back in.

They don't need thumbs.

But they can't make fire and can't use electricity in their natural habitat, so I'm not that worried.
 
They have brains in their arms, to the point where a severed octopus arm will still hunt for food on its own and are pretty smart for something that we eat. In captivity, they'll sneak out of their tanks and steal fish to eat from other tanks and sneak back in.

They don't need thumbs.

But they can't make fire and can't use electricity in their natural habitat, so I'm not that worried.
When they develop lungs and crawl out onto dry land, I, for one, will welcome our new mollusk overlords.
 
the lack of fire and electricity is not necessarily an indicator for a lacl of intelligence. Just think of the whales.

Varek, (welcome to the board, btw :) )if I interpret you correctly, you assume that male squids are larger than females? I'm no expert on cephalopods but in most non-mammal species the female is taller. I'd have assumed that to be the case with squids, too.

I agree, though, that it's likely that there are bigger specimens than the ones we've found so far. After all, the few ones whos bodies stranded or got entangled in nets are just a tiny sample of the total population. It'd be very unscientific to build a theory based on the dissection results of just a handfull of partially decayed individuals.
 
the lack of fire and electricity is not necessarily an indicator for a lacl of intelligence. Just think of the whales.
JarodRussell wasn't referring to intelligence per se, but rather a species' ability to make tools and develop technology -- which, of necessity, would be extremely limited in an aquatic environment.
 
Exactly. They might develop a complex language, become great thinkers and philosophers, and develop an Ancient Greek like understanding of nature, they might build basic tools, but technologically they would be extremely limited.
I don't think they would be able to manufacture "land suits" like we can make diving suits. I think water is an extremely limiting medium. So basically all technologically advanced species need to be home on dry land.
 
Exactly. They might develop a complex language, become great thinkers and philosophers, and develop an Ancient Greek like understanding of nature, they might build basic tools, but technologically they would be extremely limited.
I don't think they would be able to manufacture "land suits" like we can make diving suits. I think water is an extremely limiting medium. So basically all technologically advanced species need to be home on dry land.

Pssssh. You're such a landist.
 
Most human technologies (diving suits, computers, electricity, motor vehicles, plumbing, central heating) are fairly recent developments. Neither is older than 200 years, many not even 100.
Maybe in a couple centuries an octopus will invent the warp drive :) After all, they already have their in-built jet propulsion
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top