• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Agents of SHIELD. Season 1 Discussion Thread

Well, this was a game-changer, all right. And it did a pretty good job keeping us guessing, though I'm not particularly surprised about who the traitors turned out to be. (I am surprised they killed off Hand, though.) I guess the speculations I've heard about Triplett being set up as Ward's replacement may have been right.

Beware Winter Soldier spoilers ahead:

It sounds like the Hub may become the team's home base now, so it's not just the Bus anymore. Which would make sense; they went to the trouble to build all those sets, so it'd be good to have a reason to keep using them. I guess the story now will be about weeding out the remaining HYDRA factions that were said to retain control of various SHIELD facilities. So the shutdown of SHIELD isn't as simple as it looked in the movie. And presumably Garrett and Ward will be the main antagonists.

I'm puzzled by the timing in this episode. It looked like it all took place on the same day as the film's climax, as the launch of Operation Insight and the three Helicarriers. After all, in the film, HYDRA didn't reveal itself openly within SHIELD until Cap outed them on the PA. Fury's apparent death came at least a couple of days earlier in the story. But wasn't May talking to Fury at the end of last week's episode, just minutes in story time before this one started? I'd really like to see a detailed chronological breakdown of how the past couple of episodes and the movie fit together, like a smaller-scale version of the one I've seen for the Phase One films.

It would also be interesting to go back and watch all the episodes again, knowing what we know now. Although it may still be a few weeks before we learn the whole story behind everything.


We'll see...Garrett didn't seem sure that Ward would turn...in the preview he's saying "welcome to Hydra", indicating that Ward wasn't already in.

No, we heard a voice saying "Welcome to Hydra" over a shot of Garrett firing some kind of device with Ward standing behind him, but it's pretty clear the sound and the picture didn't go together. So we don't know who was being welcomed.

Ward is definitely deep in HYDRA and has been all along. Consider the evidence. He's Garrett's protege (although, granted, so is Triplett). He killed the fake Clairvoyant, an action that a lot of people found out of character or hard to explain, but that makes perfect sense if he was acting under orders from Garrett to make it look like the Clairvoyant had been found and killed. He's been established as someone with a dark, troubled past and heightened aggression -- which seemed at the time like it was just a "bad boy" characterization but in retrospect feels like a clue to his true nature.

And really, from a dramatic standpoint, it's hard to see how a series protagonist could come back from cold-bloodedly murdering an innocent man. It wasn't an accident, it was a calculated choice to kill. No matter how it's rationalized, that's a pretty extreme line to cross and one you can't come back from. So it would pretty much ruin him as a series-lead protagonist. But if it he was really a villain all along, then the act merely establishes his evil credentials.

Also, look at it metatextually. People have been saying all along that they found Ward a boring or unlikeable character, a weak link in the ensemble (though not the only one, granted). That makes more sense if the plan all along was to have him be a temporary member of the ensemble. Heck, I'd much rather have Triplett take his place. That actor is a lot more interesting.


Garrett's the Clairvoyant...he certainly wasn't denying it.

And for those of you who've seen TWS, notice how the episode conveniently avoided addressing...

...the massive public data dump of SHIELD info...or did I miss that?

I've been wondering about that.
Would that info include the truth behind Coulson's resurrection and Skye's origins?



Everybody else has already covered most of my thoughts, but another nice touch was the fact that
the tool Fury and Black Widow use in TWS was invented by Fitz.

Oh, I didn't notice the connection there.
 
Last edited:
I still think Coulson and Fury are Hydra. Fury was Garrett's and Coulson's SO. For some reason (deep cover or amnesia) Coulson didn't take part in the SHIELD takeover.
 
It sounds like the Hub may become the team's home base now, so it's not just the Bus anymore. Which would make sense; they went to the trouble to build all those sets, so it'd be good to have a reason to keep using them. I guess the story now will be about weeding out the remaining HYDRA factions that were said to retain control of various SHIELD facilities. So the shutdown of SHIELD isn't as simple as it looked in the movie. And presumably Garrett and Ward will be the main antagonists.

Skye said there was no SHIELD and Coulson in the preview stated their goal was to survive. The preview also mentioned that there was a global hunt for SHIELD.There is also some new secret base they go to.
 
Great episode. I had a feeling Ward was a traitor (and Triplet) but I thought there would be a logical reason why.

There is no logical reason why some people join HYDRA outside of the fact that they maybe closeted psychopaths. Ward was the last person I suspected to be HYDRA because honestly he's not that complex of a character.
 

Your use of spoiler tags is wildly erratic.

Sorry -- fixed.


There is no logical reason why some people join HYDRA outside of the fact that they maybe closeted psychopaths.

I'm sure many people would be drawn to such an organization because of its promises of bringing order to chaos, or giving them a sense of control and purpose, of having the power to do something about the world's problems. A lot of well-meaning people have been won over by the propaganda of groups like the Nazis and other authoritarian regimes for such reasons.
One thing the movie made clear was that SHIELD's goals and methods were closer to HYDRA's than Fury was comfortable admitting. That's why HYDRA was able to subvert SHIELD so effectively for so long.
 
I minor minor thing but it did strike me how in TWS they shot out Fury's car windows for like 5 minutes straight before they could break through, but when the Bus landed at the Hub, a couple rifle shots and bam! all the windows are blown out! Whatever the plot needs I guess...
 
Ward is definitely deep in HYDRA and has been all along. Consider the evidence. He's Garrett's protege (although, granted, so is Triplett). He killed the fake Clairvoyant, an action that a lot of people found out of character or hard to explain, but that makes perfect sense if he was acting under orders from Garrett to make it look like the Clairvoyant had been found and killed. He's been established as someone with a dark, troubled past and heightened aggression -- which seemed at the time like it was just a "bad boy" characterization but in retrospect feels like a clue to his true nature.

And really, from a dramatic standpoint, it's hard to see how a series protagonist could come back from cold-bloodedly murdering an innocent man. It wasn't an accident, it was a calculated choice to kill. No matter how it's rationalized, that's a pretty extreme line to cross and one you can't come back from. So it would pretty much ruin him as a series-lead protagonist. But if it he was really a villain all along, then the act merely establishes his evil credentials.

Also, look at it metatextually. People have been saying all along that they found Ward a boring or unlikeable character, a weak link in the ensemble (though not the only one, granted). That makes more sense if the plan all along was to have him be a temporary member of the ensemble. Heck, I'd much rather have Triplett take his place. That actor is a lot more interesting.
And yet...I don't think this show has magically transformed from the one that was being so damn obvious about Ward and Skye hooking up all along. Ward outing himself to Skye in the closet (See what I did there?) wasn't an accident. He's doing it all for Snowflake. And she'll be the only one who still believes in him and all that crap.
 
Was Shaw on the airplane with Ward and Hand at the end? He was cool. I don't think Ward killed those guards to infiltrate Hydra. Shield barley has enough agents as it is. Also, Ward has the busses hard drive, right? That's going to come in play later.
 
I do have to wonder about Marvel's logic in spoiling The Winter Soldier a mere four days after it was released. Not that ratings are great on Shield but still...tying into The Winter Soldier is supposed to be a way to increase ratings for the show.
 
Okay, I know it's from the comics, but Hand in the comics is not completely Hand form the TV show, but usually when a fully grown woman does that to her hair it's a desperate yelp that he is not old, and is too fun.

Considering who she is in the TV series, I'm more thinking that it's something Victoria did for charity, or she fell asleep at her sisters bachelorette party after one drink, and this was her punishemnt.
 
I'm sure many people would be drawn to such an organization because of its promises of bringing order to chaos, or giving them a sense of control and purpose, of having the power to do something about the world's problems.

It's hard for me to believe that rational people would accept such blatant nonsense (of course Americans are the most stupid in the world). If I told you that you should join my organization and our goal is to kill all the Jews and killing all the Jews would bring world peace. You honestly would think I'm crazy.

A lot of well-meaning people have been won over by the propaganda of groups like the Nazis and other authoritarian regimes for such reasons.

If I asked you to join the Nazis party, knowing what you know NOW, would you do it. Exactly

It's hard for me to believe a liberal diplomat once considered for the Nobel Prize would start yelling Hail HYDRA. It's doubly strange that anyone with a rifle in SHIELD was a HYDRA agent. As for SHIELD's methods, I don't think even SHIELD would even consider murdering 20 million people for the simple crime of thinking for themselves
 
And yet...I don't think this show has magically transformed from the one that was being so damn obvious about Ward and Skye hooking up all along. Ward outing himself to Skye in the closet (See what I did there?) wasn't an accident. He's doing it all for Snowflake. And she'll be the only one who still believes in him and all that crap.

It's only magic in the sense that it's misdirection. They used the pretense of Ward's interest in Skye as a red herring -- set it up so we'd believe it when he said it was his reason for killing the Not-Clairvoyant, so that we wouldn't suspect his real reason.

There's no getting around the fact that Ward killed Hand and the other two. That wasn't an icer. They showed us the blood on her hand. (Victoria's hand. Pretty straightforward symbolism.) And the look in his eyes in the tag -- that wasn't remorse or deception, it was pure malevolent satisfaction.

Now, maybe his feelings for Skye are genuine; Lorelei seemed to think so, anyway. But that doesn't make them his true motivation for his recent actions. It may give him some qualms about going against her and the team; maybe he'll try to win her over to his side. But I don't believe this season will end up with Ward absolved and the old status quo restored. The show is done playing it safe. I think its appearance of playing it safe before was just to lull us into complacency, and to mark time until TWS came out.
 
I do have to wonder about Marvel's logic in spoiling The Winter Soldier a mere four days after it was released. Not that ratings are great on Shield but still...tying into The Winter Soldier is supposed to be a way to increase ratings for the show.

Studies have shown that spoilers don't effect people's enjoyment of movies.
 
I do have to wonder about Marvel's logic in spoiling The Winter Soldier a mere four days after it was released. Not that ratings are great on Shield but still...tying into The Winter Soldier is supposed to be a way to increase ratings for the show.

Every person I've talked to who watches the show, but hasn't had a chance to see TWS yet, had the same reaction after the episode was over - "Man I gotta go see that movie now!"

So yeah, that's probably their logic...
 
His being so Machiavellian that he'd kill friendly agents in cold blood to get deep into the enemy ranks would be an interesting development for his character too.

Hell, anything would be an interesting development in his character at this point....
 
He could have plans to recruit her, and that's what "have a drink" really means.

We hail Hydra, then Hail each other.

They can't be together, which is something he wants, until she relents and joins Hydra.

If Ward was worth his salt, he would have copied that hard drive and handed it over to Hydra months ago, and then updated Hydra after every mission since then.

Now for the interesting question... When was Brett Dalton told that he was playing both sides?

Siddig wasn't told that he was a Changeling for 1/4 of a season, and Martha Hacket wasn't told that she was a Cardassian Sleeper Agent till she got the script...

But then you can't really trust actors not to ham it up if they know too much about the future.

The Final 5 from Battlestar :)
 
His being so Machiavellian that he'd kill friendly agents in cold blood to get deep into the enemy ranks would be an interesting development for his character too.

Hell, anything would be an interesting development in his character at this point....

Joss Whedon has a habit of randomly killing people for no good reason. I'm wonder if he's going to go all Game of Throne and murder the entire cast.
 
I do have to wonder about Marvel's logic in spoiling The Winter Soldier a mere four days after it was released. Not that ratings are great on Shield but still...tying into The Winter Soldier is supposed to be a way to increase ratings for the show.

Studies have shown that spoilers don't effect people's enjoyment of movies.

Dammit, I was looking forward to reading those studies, thanks a lot.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top