Re: A Choice Of Catastrophes review thread
Not a bad idea, but I prefer the hardcopy. I can wait a few more days.
Not a bad idea, but I prefer the hardcopy. I can wait a few more days.
TOS: A Choice of Catastrophes Review Thread (Spoilers!)
- Thread starter Thrawn
- Start date
Re: A Choice Of Catastrophes review thread
I'm about 70% of the way through and I'm confident in an "above average" mark for the book. It may even go up depending on the ending.
I'm about 70% of the way through and I'm confident in an "above average" mark for the book. It may even go up depending on the ending.
Re: A Choice Of Catastrophes review thread
Page 58 read. Message understood.
I've had trouble really getting into the book due to time constraints this week... work, car problems, family in town, babysitting for across the street neighbor who had to go to the hospital, etc. Thus, I am embarassed to say I just finished page 63 at lunch today.
That being said, I am noticing some oddities, none bad, mind you... though I have to admit to wondering who was in my brain last night when I read the use of the term 'action stations' instead of the more Trekishly flamiliar 'battle stations'. In my little alternate dream-universe, the UESPA has Sublieutenants and mans Action Stations when the lights go red.
Any chance of a Sublieutenant or two later on in the book?
Rob+
Page 58 read. Message understood.
I've had trouble really getting into the book due to time constraints this week... work, car problems, family in town, babysitting for across the street neighbor who had to go to the hospital, etc. Thus, I am embarassed to say I just finished page 63 at lunch today.
That being said, I am noticing some oddities, none bad, mind you... though I have to admit to wondering who was in my brain last night when I read the use of the term 'action stations' instead of the more Trekishly flamiliar 'battle stations'. In my little alternate dream-universe, the UESPA has Sublieutenants and mans Action Stations when the lights go red.
Any chance of a Sublieutenant or two later on in the book?
Rob+
Re: A Choice Of Catastrophes review thread
Please elaborate when you have time. I'm curious to find out what oddities you mean. Style, plot, character, something else?
I'm sorry, but no. However, there's a Senior Chief Petty Officer later in the book.
Re: A Choice Of Catastrophes review thread
I don't want to spoil too much for the review, but at the moment, the biggest thing that takes some getting used to is what I guess I can best describe as the 'snippets at a time' engagement of the various stories. It's kinda the literary equivalent of a quick-take... it feels a bit odd in pacing when compared to other recent Trek books, which is probably why it feels so odd and is taking me some getting-used to.
That's the best description I can come up with, anyway.
How about Mr. Kyle on the intership saying, "Action Stations! Action Stations!"?
Rob+
I don't want to spoil too much for the review, but at the moment, the biggest thing that takes some getting used to is what I guess I can best describe as the 'snippets at a time' engagement of the various stories. It's kinda the literary equivalent of a quick-take... it feels a bit odd in pacing when compared to other recent Trek books, which is probably why it feels so odd and is taking me some getting-used to.
That's the best description I can come up with, anyway.
I'm sorry, but no. However, there's a Senior Chief Petty Officer later in the book.
How about Mr. Kyle on the intership saying, "Action Stations! Action Stations!"?
Rob+
Re: A Choice Of Catastrophes review thread
No, but he does start drumming and shout "BEAT TO QUARTERS!"
That's the best description I can come up with, anyway.
I'm sorry, but no. However, there's a Senior Chief Petty Officer later in the book.
How about Mr. Kyle on the intership saying, "Action Stations! Action Stations!"?
No, but he does start drumming and shout "BEAT TO QUARTERS!"
Re: A Choice Of Catastrophes review thread
Okay... nuff said. Book gets perfect review at TrekMovie
LOL!
Rob+
Okay... nuff said. Book gets perfect review at TrekMovie
LOL!Rob+
Re: A Choice Of Catastrophes review thread
Just (well, about two hours ago) finished the book and I'm officially giving it an outstanding
I like the way everything came together in the end and I put this book second in line as the ultimate McCoy book after Provenance of Shadows.
I'll be posting a fuller review, with spoilers, on my blog in the next day or so (now that I'm posting to it more regularly).
Just (well, about two hours ago) finished the book and I'm officially giving it an outstanding
I like the way everything came together in the end and I put this book second in line as the ultimate McCoy book after Provenance of Shadows.
I'll be posting a fuller review, with spoilers, on my blog in the next day or so (now that I'm posting to it more regularly).
Re: A Choice Of Catastrophes review thread
Found the book (FINALLY) and bought it last night. Won't have a chance to read it for a while, but I'm wondering if there's been any mention of the fact that Mr. Mollmann's last name is misspelled on the cover? Will it be fixed on the next print run?
Found the book (FINALLY) and bought it last night. Won't have a chance to read it for a while, but I'm wondering if there's been any mention of the fact that Mr. Mollmann's last name is misspelled on the cover? Will it be fixed on the next print run?
Re: A Choice Of Catastrophes review thread
There may have been some mentions, yes.
There may have been some mentions, yes.
Re: A Choice Of Catastrophes review thread
It's something I was told was in fact actually fixed.
Thanks. I'll look into it.
It's something I was told was in fact actually fixed.
Thanks. I'll look into it.
Re: A Choice Of Catastrophes review thread
I have to confess this story isn't working for me. About a 1/4 through and it DRAGS. Putting it aside, but I'll try it again later.
I have to confess this story isn't working for me. About a 1/4 through and it DRAGS. Putting it aside, but I'll try it again later.
Re: A Choice Of Catastrophes review thread
I bought the eBook on release day (August 30th), so there's a chance that it has been fixed after that.
ETA: Just downloaded the excerpt from amazon and it has the correct name on the cover, so I guess it was fixed after release day.
I bought the eBook on release day (August 30th), so there's a chance that it has been fixed after that.
ETA: Just downloaded the excerpt from amazon and it has the correct name on the cover, so I guess it was fixed after release day.
Re: A Choice Of Catastrophes review thread
I felt so bad for you when I saw it.
Re: A Choice Of Catastrophes review thread
Sometimes I'm philosophical, sometimes I'm intensely aggravated. Isaac Asimov's name was spelled Issac Asimov on an early novel, and he turned out all right, though.
Sometimes I'm philosophical, sometimes I'm intensely aggravated. Isaac Asimov's name was spelled Issac Asimov on an early novel, and he turned out all right, though.
Re: A Choice Of Catastrophes review thread
Somehow I've never had that problem. As another person with two occurrences of double letters in my surname, I'm used to seeing my name misspelled in various circumstances (and I'm so used to saying "two Ns, two Ts" after giving my name), but they always seem to get it right on my books and stories.
Somehow I've never had that problem. As another person with two occurrences of double letters in my surname, I'm used to seeing my name misspelled in various circumstances (and I'm so used to saying "two Ns, two Ts" after giving my name), but they always seem to get it right on my books and stories.
Re: A Choice Of Catastrophes review thread
^I think the problem with Steve's name is that Mollmann looks wrong to the english speaking eyes, and it seems that the name was "corrected" very late in the process, as it was spelled right on all the prerelease cover pics available online, but at the last minute someone someone must have thought "Mollmann can't be right, I will fix that"
I doubt there will be a problem if his books ever get translated to German.
^I think the problem with Steve's name is that Mollmann looks wrong to the english speaking eyes, and it seems that the name was "corrected" very late in the process, as it was spelled right on all the prerelease cover pics available online, but at the last minute someone someone must have thought "Mollmann can't be right, I will fix that"
I doubt there will be a problem if his books ever get translated to German.
Similar threads
- Poll
