• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

The truth is in here: watchin' The X-Files (NO SPOILERS)

Canadave

Vice Admiral
Admiral
Up until about 15 minutes ago, I had never seen an episode of The X-Files all the way through. Yeah, that particular genre freight train managed to pass me by entirely. This was no doubt due to a few things, such as being six years old when the show premiered, and thanks to becoming obsessed with a certain other science fiction franchise in my youth (hint: I've been registered on a message board for said franchise for nearly a decade now).

Anyway, I recently decided I should try to fix this rather significant gap in my personal SF knowledge, and I thought I'd slap together a watch\rate thread while I was at it. I've never done one of these before (mostly, I've just read and lurked in the ones done by The God Ben), but I figure it'll provide me with some motivation to keep going if I ever find my interest flagging, as well as give me a place to collect my thoughts on the show as I go.

Just a couple of other notes before I go on: I'm generally unspoiled on what happened in the show, so please no one ruin it for me. I know there's an over-arcing conspiracy story, that David Duchovny leaves for the last couple seasons and... well, that's pretty much it. I'll just repeat that, for emphasis: NO SPOILERS. ;) Also, I'm planning on using a pretty standard letter-grading system, A through F, if you're curious.

That all out of the way, let's get on with it, shall we?

1x01 "Pilot"
B+


It's an intriguing start, I have to say. Though the actual story that comprises the episode is pretty ordinary, it does it's job well—introducing us to the characters, and the general feel of the universe that the show is going to inhabit.

Admittedly, for the first half of the episode, I thought that said universe was going to be "vaguely cheap 90s television," but to the episode's credit, it got quite atmospheric by the end. Kudos, considering the colour palette can best be described as "gray."

I was also impressed with the fact that exposition was kept reasonably bearable. The first scene with Scully in the office being told of her new assignment was pretty terrible, but thankfully they worked that out reasonably quickly. It helped that Duchovny and Anderson have some pretty instant chemistry, that made the "LOOK WE ARE EXPLAINING THINGS OKAY" bits in the dialogue less painful.

In the end, the main thing this episode left me with was a desire to learn more about the Cigarette Smoking Man (I know enough to know he's important). They hinted nicely that he's going to play an interesting role, and I half-expected to hear John Williams swelling when he put the metal-thinger in the Pentagon storage room. Very mysterious, and a little creepy.

All in all, a solid pilot. It wasn't spectacular in the same way Lost's was, say, but it did it's work well and left me wanting more. Hopefully this review will do the same for you...

Until next time.
 
Enjoy! I mostly loved the series, though you may find it dragging in the last seasons. One thing you may get sick of is seeing the woods around Vancouver :lol:. I think only Stargate was there more often.
 
This is making me nostalgic. I remember watching all the episodes on DVD like six years ago. It's such a great show.

As for the pilot, well, it's pretty good. Some things change within the first few episodes but overall it sets a good tone. The final scene is iconic and I adore it.
 
Ah, a newborn baby X-Phile...welcome! The scales fall from the eyes and the reality of the world stands revealed. For the Truth Is Out There, and you are about to get the grand tour.
 
I did a thread like this a few years ago. It was a fun ride. Season one and two can be a little rough at times, but there are enough good episodes and fun moments between the leads to keep you going.

Cancer Man doesn't really begin to gain prominence until the end of the season, but you'll see him in the shadows from time to time, lurking.

There's a short-lived spin-off called The Lone Gunmen that aired during season eight. It's a comedic spy show of sorts and quite different in tone to The X-Files. It's not at all important that you see it, though it is referenced a few times in season nine.

There's also Millennium, which aired during seasons 4-6. It wasn't supposed to be a spin-off, but there ends up being a crossover with a minor character and some other references to The X-Files during its three year run. After it was cancelled, the main character, Frank Black, crossed over on The X-Files early in season seven.

Then there are the two movies. The first takes place between seasons five and six. The second takes place after the series.

I look forward to your reviews.
 
I think the 90s feel -- the cellphones, the suits, etc -- actually contribute a lot to the atmosphere in retrospect. Has a grittiness that Fringe lacks.
 
I rather liked the episodes where they flashed back to the 1980s--ridiculous hair and even bigger cell phones. :D Of course, now the "present day" of the 1990s has ridiculous hair and bigger cell phones, too.
 
One thing you may get sick of is seeing the woods around Vancouver :lol:

At least in the X-Files they could just pretend they were always in Virginia. On Stargate they were supposed to be on many different alien worlds! :lol:
 
I think the 90s feel -- the cellphones, the suits, etc -- actually contribute a lot to the atmosphere in retrospect. Has a grittiness that Fringe lacks.

Seeing Scully always using WordPerfect on DOS is certainly enough to leave me scared. :eek:

I do know what you mean, though. Fringe does feel very polished in comparison, and I feel like The X-Files has done a better job of establishing atmosphere early on. I still love Fringe, mind, but that's thanks in large part to the characters and the whole alternate-universe plot.

Thanks to everyone for the replies, as well. Harvey, I appreciate you laying out where all the spin-offs and movies fit in. I was unsure how all that worked.

1x02 "Deep Throat"
B-


I watched this early this afternoon, and have been trying to figure out how I felt about it since then. At the end of the day, I'm basically forced to conclude that it was decent, but didn't really have enough standout moments to really register much of an impact with me.

I think part of the problem is that the basic plot seemed vaguely like a rehash of the pilot: strange things are happening to a certain group of people in a small Northwestern town, and the local authorities are covering it up. Obviously the devil is in the details, but it did feel similar enough that my attention wandered on occasion.

Still, there was some good stuff. The whole idea of "Trust no one" (here I was assuming that line would come in the pilot :() is certainly establishing itself, and Mulder's capture by the military was very creepy. I also appreciated that they went so far as to actually erase his memories—lesser shows would probably have him make a miraculous escape or something.

Other good bits included a Before He Was Famous version of Seth Green, and the mysterious dude at the beginning and the end. I wonder what's up with him? Who does he work for? What the hell is his name? :lol:

Overall, an enjoyable outing. Just nothing that really left me jumping for joy.
 
^ Heh, yeah, I kind of figured that would apply to a large chunk of the standalones. It doesn't bother me much, fortunately, being a fan of shows like Fringe, Buffy/Angel, TNG, etc., all of which often rely on the Monster\Anomaly\Whatever of the Week format.
 
There's a lot of bile for the last two seasons, but I don't necessarily share it. I liked some of the new characters, and they managed to squeeze a few good monster stories in between the meandering mytharc episodes. It's not a stretch to say the series could have continued if they'd made a clean break with the Mulder-Scully era. Just MHO.
 
^I agree. The last two seasons are very much like the last two seasons of Stargate SG-1 (which I also really like). They probably would have worked better if they had been treated like a spin-off instead of a continuation of the original show.
 
I love Deep Throat despite the fact that the episode isn't all that outstanding. It may be nostalgia, mind you.
 
It does have one of my favorite exchanges.

DEEP THROAT: Why are those like yourself, who believe in the existence of extraterrestrial life on this earth, not dissuaded by all the evidence to the contrary?

MULDER: Because all the evidence to the contrary is not entirely dissuasive.


That's Mulder in a nutshell. Scully, the scientist, adopts the theory most likely to explain most of the evidence while dismissing the rest as aberrant, at most indicative of the need to slightly revise conventional theory. Mulder, the pseudoscientist, grasps the smallest aberration as an indictment of an entire paradigm. And his new paradigms are usually pretty out there. That's why we like him, his ideas are weirder than ours.
 
There's a lot of bile for the last two seasons, but I don't necessarily share it. I liked some of the new characters, and they managed to squeeze a few good monster stories in between the meandering mytharc episodes. It's not a stretch to say the series could have continued if they'd made a clean break with the Mulder-Scully era. Just MHO.
I liked the new characters also. I also think that the 8th season was someways bit better and darker than the seventh:cool:
But its true that the best years are definetly seasons 1-5:bolian:
The X-Files was, and is one, of my favorite TV-shows of all time. When it started it was dark, well done and interesting show..and its that still today.
And Mulder and Scully...the best damn team on TV!
The actors have such great chemistry, something that you cant buy with money.
I hope you enjoy the ride, Canadave:techman: It will me truly memorable...
 
Other good bits included a Before He Was Famous version of Seth Green, and the mysterious dude at the beginning and the end. I wonder what's up with him? Who does he work for? What the hell is his name? :lol:

Those things will be answered in time. As for his name, just call him Deep Throat. We eventually find out the names of a few of these shadowy characters, but the nicknames (like Cancer Man) are the ones that really stick.

I'm actually kind of amused that Hal Holbrook, who played Deep Throat in All The President's Men (a key inspiration for this series, and this character) is famous for playing Mark Twain. And Jerry Hardin, who plays Deep Throat on The X-Files also played Mark Twain.
 
I like these total series reviews, such as the GodBen one you mentioned, plus the one where the guy does TNG, DS9, and B5 all in one....

But can I make one suggestion? Please put a synopsis or episode refresher or something like that before your review? So many times I can't get into these reviews because I can't recognize the episode from the title?

I love the X-files, but I only saw about half of the episodes. It would be great to see how you grade and review certain episodes that I have seen, but without a synopsis I would have no idea what episode you are referring too.

I like the way some of the other posters write, but most of the time I can't get into their review, because I don't know what episode they are talking about until I read about halfway through. Then it kicks in and know what episode they are talking about, but then I am done reading their review.

I like to have my own opinions about a show and then compare them to how other people like/dislike the show. If I don't know what episode is being talked about, then I can't compare.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top