Belive me, Jir, he's very familiar with these ships, as I'm the guy who got them to model them .. and pound him a little on their look. The dishes on the more organic lines of the NuEnterprise just don't look right, so he ditched them.
And, it's funny that you show those images of the ships as 'accurate'.. since the Columbia doesn't have spires like that anywhere.
http://www.jaynz.info/images/ADB/ADB_Hermes.png
That image I posted was the first one I could find on a Google image seacrh, and posted it only to point out the deflector dishes (not sure what you mean by 'spires'?) I also wasn't aware of you assisting him and nixing the idea of the dishes as you indicated.
I really like your scout image, especially the differences between it and the destroyer. I might just try to model that on my SFB minis.
In any case, no offense was intended.
J