• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Decanonization Time!

Please do explain "how canon works" in a thread asking people what they would decanonize.
It's where some businesspeople you've never met, who currently possess the legal rights to a work of fiction, are able to tell you how you should regard it.

This might sound silly - "fiction is fiction," you might think, "it's all stories. I can reintepret, modify, and enjoy it however I like, as can anyone else." That sounds reasonable and is how people have approached fiction for millennia, but unfortunately, it is not the case - Paramount's secret police will be dispatched to deal with any subversives.

They got me the other week for simply thinking the thought "I don't like how Picard's written in 'Perfect Mate', I'll probably skip this on the next rewatch"; they came over and forced me into that Clockwork Orange eye-opening machine to make me watch it until I recanted and pledged to always keep every line of 'The Perfect Mate' in mind when watching any other work of Star Trek ever produced.
 
that is either the biggest lampshade I've ever seen on a badly aimed virtue signal, or I'm an idiot. Could be either, really.
How is not watching much media a virtue signal? I know I have a tendency to overthink media so I don't watch a lot. That's me trying to manage my shit not a commentary or judgement on anyone else.
 
How is not watching much media a virtue signal? I know I have a tendency to overthink media so I don't watch a lot. That's me trying to manage my shit not a commentary or judgement on anyone else.
giphy.gif
 
To be fair, nobody on this site enjoys Star Trek, as such.
I know you're likely joking, but I enjoy Trek as a whole very much.

Very carefully. How do you?
Very broadly. There are certain shows and episodes that don't appeal to me, but as a whole I love the franchise. But I am legitimately confused as to how someone could enjoy Trek if you can't ever watch and enjoy what a good villain brings to a story.
 
Very broadly. There are certain shows and episodes that don't appeal to me, but as a whole I love the franchise. But I am legitimately confused as to how someone could enjoy Trek if you can't ever watch and enjoy what a good villain brings to a story.
Because of the heroes.
 
That's fair, and I love the heroes in Trek, but they are only part of the story. There wouldn't be much going on in the episodes and films if it weren't for the villains.
True enough but I'm not watching for the villains, personally nor do I find them compelling by themselves. The heroes are compelling by themselves.
 
True enough but I'm not watching for the villains, personally nor do I find them compelling by themselves. The heroes are compelling by themselves.
I see what you're saying, and I respect that. I just don't think that's how most people watch movies or TV shows. Personally, I can hate what someone like Khan or Garak is doing, and yet still be compelled by their performances because Ricardo Montalban and Andrew Robinson just give brilliant performances and they are both so well written.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top