Spoilers Star Trek: Strange New Worlds 3x06 - "The Sehlat Who Ate Its Tail"

[Candleicious Ghost]

I'm going to sound like everyone else here. This was one of the few episodes this season so far that I really did enjoy. I also liked the holodeck one, and Through The Lens Of Time but that one with its wonly ending really, transporters can do that, hold a non corporeal in the buffer? I nearly screamed Bullshit at the screen but let it slide. This is Star Trek after all. /s

7/10 and around 11 minutes you see the TARDIS

 

[Nerys Myk]

I'm going to sound like everyone else here. This was one of the few episodes this season so far that I really did enjoy. I also liked the holodeck one, and Through The Lens Of Time but that one with its wonly ending really, transporters can do that, hold a non corporeal in the buffer? I nearly screamed Bullshit at the screen but let it slide. This is Star Trek after all. /s

7/10 and around 11 minutes you see the TARDIS

Is there a reason to believe it can't? Isn't anyone using a transporter rendered "non-corporeal" for a few seconds?

 

[Candleicious Ghost]

Is there a reason to believe it can't? Isn't anyone using a transporter rendered "non-corporeal" for a few seconds?

No, isn't any person held in the transporter a stream of matter particles?

I just didn't like that weird spirit entity could be held in the same manner.

 

[Nerys Myk]

No, isn't any person held in the transporter a stream of matter particles?

I just didn't like that weird spirit entity could be held in the same manner.

I always thought you're converted into energy, transported and then reconstituted into matter. A "spirit entity" is already half way there.

 

[fireproof78]

I always thought you're converted into energy, transported and then reconstituted into matter. A "spirit entity" is already half way there.

That's how they drove the noncopoeral prisoners from Data, Troi and O'Brien.

 

[Farscape One]

That's how they drove the noncopoeral prisoners from Data, Troi and O'Brien.

No, they left on their own because their fellow prisoners were trapped in that field Beverly thought up. (They almost got them in Ten Forward with the plasma shock to induce pain, but possessed Data stepped out of the way at the last second.)

Then once those 3 went with the others, they were beamed down.

 

[fireproof78]

No, they left on their own because their fellow prisoners were trapped in that field Beverly thought up. (They almost got them in Ten Forward with the plasma shock to induce pain, but possessed Data stepped out of the way at the last second.)

Then once those 3 went with the others, they were beamed down.

Thank you

 

[Candleicious Ghost]

Damn shame I can't change my vote I want this to be an 8 now after seeing the ones after this one.

 

[Mudd]

I always thought you're converted into energy, transported and then reconstituted into matter. A "spirit entity" is already half way there.

It works however they say it works this week.

 

[Candleicious Ghost]

I'm going to rewatch this because it was one of the few good episodes this season. But it reminded me of an actual Dr Who episode. Wasn't the TARDIS in that show captured by scavengers, I think the episode was "journey to the centre of the TARDIS" with the 11th Doctor.

Shame that can't be these scavengers and we saw it from the Dr and companions point of view.

 

[Reanok]

This show was very fast paced and intense the space pirates were ruthless . they certainly ahd a hard time of the Farragut and on the Enterprise to defeat a ruthless enemy and the suprizingg twist who the enemy was certainly not what I expected. Bravo!

 

[Ovation]

Just rewatched this (first rewatch since it originally aired). Definitely a high point of the season. Made me want “Year One” even more (yes I know it’s not happening).

 

[hbquikcomjamesl]

High stakes, without gratuitous servings of eye-scream. I gave it a 9.

that ending was ominous.

I wouldn't call the ending "ominous." More "humbling." The ending of the previous episode, with the screens glitching, was ominous.

 

[Paul755]

rewatched this one this morning. Very good episode for a backdoor pilot. Really liked the angle they took with Kirk actually needing to step it up. The last convo he had with Pike was really great.

Something has been nagging at me since the holodeck episode though. Scotty is terribly mid-cast. It’s not really the actor, it’s that they cast him too young. In TOS Scotty always came off as the older hand… “Mr. Scott you old space dog…” the guy that had more experience is space than everyone but Bones and maybe Spock but didnt pursue promotion or command because he just loved being an engineer. Here he’s just a kid no different that Uhura.

 

[Nerys Myk]

rewatched this one this morning. Very good episode for a backdoor pilot. Really liked the angle they took with Kirk actually needing to step it up. The last convo he had with Pike was really great.

Something has been nagging at me since the holodeck episode though. Scotty is terribly mid-cast. It’s not really the actor, it’s that they cast him too young. In TOS Scotty always came off as the older hand… “Mr. Scott you old space dog…” the guy that had more experience is space than everyone but Bones and maybe Spock but didnt pursue promotion or command because he just loved being an engineer. Here he’s just a kid no different that Uhura.

Space pup.

I'm liking the actor though. A true Scotsman!

 

[Yistaan]

rewatched this one this morning. Very good episode for a backdoor pilot. Really liked the angle they took with Kirk actually needing to step it up. The last convo he had with Pike was really great.

Something has been nagging at me since the holodeck episode though. Scotty is terribly mid-cast. It’s not really the actor, it’s that they cast him too young. In TOS Scotty always came off as the older hand… “Mr. Scott you old space dog…” the guy that had more experience is space than everyone but Bones and maybe Spock but didnt pursue promotion or command because he just loved being an engineer. Here he’s just a kid no different that Uhura.

Someone on SNW messed up on Scotty's timeline (which is odd since it was just a memory alpha click away for SNW writers). He's said in SNW to be a lieutenant junior grade at 38. Canonically even Harry Kim was definitely at a higher rank at that age. Keep in mind Scotty's Kelvin counterpart was already a lieutenant commander at this time.

 

[fireproof78]

Someone on SNW messed up on Scotty's timeline (which is odd since it was just a memory alpha click away for SNW writers). He's said in SNW to be a lieutenant junior grade at 38. Canonically even Harry Kim was definitely at a higher rank at that age. Keep in mind Scotty's Kelvin counterpart was already a lieutenant commander at this time.

What does age have to do with it?

 

[Nerys Myk]

Someone on SNW messed up on Scotty's timeline (which is odd since it was just a memory alpha click away for SNW writers). He's said in SNW to be a lieutenant junior grade at 38. Canonically even Harry Kim was definitely at a higher rank at that age. Keep in mind Scotty's Kelvin counterpart was already a lieutenant commander at this time.

Maybe Scotty joined Starfleet when he was older. After kicking around on various civilian ships for awhile.

 

[cooleddie74]

Although he said he was a Starfleet Cadet at 18 in "Relics(TNG)."

 

[Firebird]

Could be that Scotty wasn't much interested in upward movement in Starfleet, preferring to stick with the work.