• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Spoilers Star Trek: Picard 3x06 - "The Bounty"

Engage!


  • Total voters
    260
6kNpF1R.gif
 
Yeah, inclusions an important part of Star Trek. If this is an effort by Matalas to erase some of that, I’ll be annoyed. I’ll admit it felt like there were some awkward unresolved things there so I’m hoping it’s just a fight. We shall see.
 
While Seven and Raffi breaking up wouldn't make them cease being LGBTQ+ people, the way it was handled still left me with a bad taste in the mouth. It was treated so nonchalantly and rapidly, not to mention with Worf doing most of the talking, that I couldn't help but sense an overarching vibe of "Seven & Raffi was a mistake and this is a course correction." Which I found very hard not to interpret as an attempt to reset Seven's character as if "making her gay" was an ill-advised and unnecessary move.

And as a side note, the amount of people complaining that she couldn't possibly be gay because of a brief relationship she had with a piece of plywood in a uniform 25 years ago is as frightening as it is completely unsurprising. Nothing but good old bi- and pansexual erasure.
I don’t particularly like Raffi and I didn’t like them together. Seven is one of my favorite characters. Given that Seven was more than likely involved with Bjayzul as well, it’s been made pretty clear that she’s bisexual, but I’d actually be a lot more interested in seeing her have a relationship with Liam Shaw than I am in seeing her with another woman. There’s chemistry there and the back story and conflict would make a relationship pretty interesting.
 
Genesis II. So it clearly got rebuilt by someone else.

Genesis II also implies it could be an improved version of the device.
If that's the case, then it would imply the technology was continued to be researched at Daystrom and improved upon... just not actually used.
But any subsequent breakthroughs which are derived from it could and would find their way into other starship technology (for example).
 
Genesis II also implies it could be an improved version of the device.
If that's the case, then it would imply the technology was continued to be researched at Daystrom and improved upon... just not actually used.
But any subsequent breakthroughs which are derived from it could and would find their way into other starship technology (for example).
I wonder if they managed to work out the problems with the protomatter. Also does the device still work on taking existing matter and altering its matrix? The same moral implications as the first device would still arise.
 
10. My first of the season. The ride is just about over. Why couldn't the first two seasons have been like this? It's amazing how the quality improves when people are put in charge that have some knowledge of the IP and audience they are producing for.

So much fun in this one. The TNG crew back together finally. The Lore fake out (so much more than Lore!). Another nonchalant Vadic "Hi." The classic, non-networked presumably, hero ships just itching for one more shot at saving the galaxy. If they had AI's I can see the Enterprises, Defiant, and Voyager begging to be let loose to have some fun once again. I can also see an Admiral Janeway smirk at her Changeling captors as Voyager comes swooping in, along with the rest of the hero fleet on Frontier Day, with Captain Seven in command. How's that for some fan-wanky shit? :lol:

If I'm to criticize anything, but not enough to knock it down a point for me, it would be Geordi. He felt slightly off. Even with his explanations for wanting to protect his daughters. His daughters both joined Starfleet because of him, his adventures, and his fondness for his old crew. Somewhat hypocritical for him to berate Sydney as she rightly pointed out. Also the lack of security at Daystrom Station.
 
I don’t particularly like Raffi and I didn’t like them together. Seven is one of my favorite characters. Given that Seven was more than likely involved with Bjayzul as well, it’s been made pretty clear that she’s bisexual, but I’d actually be a lot more interested in seeing her have a relationship with Liam Shaw than I am in seeing her with another woman. There’s chemistry there and the back story and conflict would make a relationship pretty interesting.

See, you phrased that rather strange though.
You'd prefer seeing her in a relationship with Shaw than in a relationship with another woman?
I agree Raffi wasn't necessarily the best example, and not exactly what I would think Seven might go for, but a different woman might be better overall fit for Seven.
Shaw has a grating personality and thus far I don't think Seven would or should consider a relationship with him. One ample reason being that he's her comanding officer.. and in fairness, I don't think they really perceive each other like that.

So, have Seven be with another (albeit different) woman than Raffi

I wonder if they managed to work out the problems with the protomatter. Also does the device still work on taking existing matter and altering its matrix? The same moral implications as the first device would still arise.

Its the fundamental principle of a baseline replicator. There's nothing morally ambiguous in that.
24th century replicators can convert energy into matter and back again. They can also rearrange pre-existing matter into something else.
The main issue with the genesis device was that it could be used as a weapon if deployed on an already living planet. The original idea was to use it on an uninhabitated/virtually dead planet - and the original Genesis device was deployed inside the Mutara nebula.

It's possible any inherent instabilities were the result of the environment in which the device was deployed and what it created.
It wasn't even used the way it was intended... so we don't know if the issues which arose on Genesis planet were the result of using Proto matter, or it was a result of using nebula matter (which wouldn't necessarily be enough to create a fully stable planet).

Proto matter usage wasn't so much a problem, as it was the fact it was unpredictable if I'm not mistaken and difficult to control.
That could have also contributed to the Genesis planet being unstable, but lets face it, the issues could have arose due to something different entirely that wasn't mentioned in the movie.
 
Sure she could but it would be interesting storytelling.
Maybe, but I don't see it.
Its the fundamental principle of a baseline replicator. There's nothing morally ambiguous in that.
24th century replicators can convert energy into matter and back again. They can also rearrange pre-existing matter into something else.
The main issue with the genesis device was that it could be used as a weapon if deployed on an already living planet. The original idea was to use it on an uninhabitated/virtually dead planet - and the original Genesis device was deployed inside the Mutara nebula.

It's possible any inherent instabilities were the result of the environment in which the device was deployed and what it created.
It wasn't even used the way it was intended... so we don't know if the issues which arose on Genesis planet were the result of using Proto matter, or it was a result of using nebula matter (which wouldn't necessarily be enough to create a fully stable planet).

Proto matter usage wasn't so much a problem, as it was the fact it was unpredictable if I'm not mistaken and difficult to control.
That could have also contributed to the Genesis planet being unstable, but lets face it, the issues could have arose due to something different entirely that wasn't mentioned in the movie.

I mean McCoy's whole point was that if this fell into the wrong hands, it could be used to alter all life on an already inhabited planet. The chance for the technology to be misused would always be there.

As for the proto-matter, David seemed pretty adamant that it was the proto-matter at fault for the instability of Genesis. I would think he factored in the circumstances of the planet's creation into his assessment. But as you say, Genesis was not deployed in the manner intended.
 
And one thing this shows is that the Federation government is well aware of Section 31 and its activities, but said government definitely refuses to acknowledge its existence.

Of course they did. Starfleet Intelligence, Starlfeet itself etc all knew about it and would just keep the lower officers fairly ignorant of it. It's why various records were missing, obfuscated etc.

It's a bit like most Western Militaries do not state where they have special forces or intelligence assets deployed. It'd be stupid to do so, and no matter how much screaming from frontiersman goes about you quietly ignore them on the basis their work does more harm than good.

In theory.
 
Fair game? Sure.
Is this the route, they’re probably going to go? Yup.
Relevant to JLP? Not so much.

But they are relevant to Bajor, which is relevant to Picard. Not as much as Sisko but there is a connection. However slender.
 
If I'm to criticize anything, but not enough to knock it down a point for me, it would be Geordi. He felt slightly off. Even with his explanations for wanting to protect his daughters. His daughters both joined Starfleet because of him, his adventures, and his fondness for his old crew. Somewhat hypocritical for him to berate Sydney as she rightly pointed out.
My children do this all the time with me. Having kids makes you blind.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top