• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Spoilers Star Trek: Strange New Worlds 1x05 - "Spock Amok"

Hit it!


  • Total voters
    232
Nah, I don't like your explanation. I don't think you solved it at all.
Jokes aside, what I posted is an actual issue with spaceships, and the larger the ship, the bigger the problem. Sci-fi usually just ignores the problem entirely but a ship like the Enterprise-D would overheat and kill everyone onboard.
 
W19IHxj


Nah, I don't like your explanation. I don't think you solved it at all. I like this one:

Bah foiled by the image posting once again.

A wizard did it.
W19IHxj

W19IHxj
The struggle is real.
 
I like it too. Other than the leather on the shoulders and arms, looks very similar to the wool knit used on the original wraps. My only notes: loose the black undershirt... show some sexy captain's skin and give it more of a point in the front like the originals.

But the wrap is my favorite uniform and I want to add this one to my uniform collection.

Oh, and I loved this episode. I like a little light-hearted adventure.

Same! Sign me up once a version of this wraparound is available!
 
Loved it, nice fun episode.
Noticed Chapels scars.. Then ignored them nobodys body is perfect.. ( Kate Upton comes close though..:adore:)
Maybe Pikes jacket was to green? The green leather upper was.. Off I think. Just stick to fabric.

Oh.. Why is the enterprise still... Well... On? As in the warp nacelles are still lite up, running lights on.. Just.. Show her at rest like the refit in dock.
 
Jokes aside, what I posted is an actual issue with spaceships, and the larger the ship, the bigger the problem. Sci-fi usually just ignores the problem entirely but a ship like the Enterprise-D would overheat and kill everyone onboard.

Oh for sure. I'm aware of the issue of heat conductivity. That just reverses the "problem" though, they had to cool down the hull enough to walk on, instead of heating it. I just think it's all a non issue because whatever they did, they made the outside of the ship livable, and everything they did is impossible, so why pick out one specific impossibility? They did it, they used force fields somehow, matter closed. I'm glad they skipped the technobabble.
 
Did anyone else notice that the Enterprise Bingo PADD played an 8-bit version of the opening bar of the Jerry Goldsmith Trek theme when they ticked off an item? Can be heard around about 31 mins in after they reflavour the chewing gum.

It's not the first time the song has appeared in-universe, it was once played by a string quartet in Ten-Forward on the Enterprise-D. But very cool theme tune cameo nonetheless!
 
Oh for sure. I'm aware of the issue of heat conductivity. That just reverses the "problem" though, they had to cool down the hull enough to walk on, instead of heating it. I just think it's all a non issue because whatever they did, they made the outside of the ship livable, and everything they did is impossible, so why pick out one specific impossibility?
What can I say? People like it when things make sense to them.
 
Except they did, because we watched them walk around in regular uniforms and touch the hull. They did it at the same time they did everything else that we didn't see. Everything's equally impossible, seems weird to be worried about one impossible part of an impossible scene featuring 12 other equal impossibilities:shrug:
Just curious did anyone bring this up when ST:TMP did it at the near end of the film? In all the discussions I've ever seen about that film, (which I too saw first run in 1979); nobody had a problem with them walking on the hall to get to Vger after that space probe did effectively the same thing. ;)
 
10/10. Instant classic. I loved the humor. The body swap was fun. And Chapel steals every scene she is in, I adore her so much. Pike's speech at the end to the aliens was great. I can't believe how much I love this show.
 
So, and I ask this out of ignorance rather than criticism, wouldn't the surface of the hull be at an uncomfortably extreme temperature to where you couldn't just walk up and touch it with your bare hand?
Managing heat even on something like the ISS is quite a feat! Imagine that the external temperatures range from +250F to - 250F from the sun to dark side. Additionally, all the electronics and body heat inside the ISS have a naturally hard time of leaving. In space, there is no conductive loss of heat, which is the main method here on Earth. Instead, it's all through thermal radiation (EM waves). Yet, we manage with the ISS and I'm sure Star Fleet manages with its ships!

Here's some interesting info on the subject regarding the ISS: Staying Cool on the ISS
https://science.nasa.gov/science-news/science-at-nasa/2001/ast21mar_1
 
So when some aliens from an area sandwiched between the Klingon and Romulan Empire come to Starbase 1 for 'talks', they didn't come in a vessel using nothing but a light sail. Maybe the ship was like the equivalent of the first steamships, which had masts, sails, AND steam engines. But that was never mentioned.
I assumed it was a ceremonial craft.
I could be wrong, but it DID seem like she was crushing on Ortegas in the last scene. Seemed like there was more she wanted to say to her, but dropped it.
I think she was crushing on Spock. Which makes me wonder if Korby was some sort of Spock substitute?
 
Managing heat even on something like the ISS is quite a feat! Imagine that the external temperatures range from +250F to - 250F from the sun to dark side. Additionally, all the electronics and body heat inside the ISS have a naturally hard time of leaving. In space, there is no conductive loss of heat, which is the main method here on Earth. Instead, it's all through thermal radiation (EM waves). Yet, we manage with the ISS and I'm sure Star Fleet manages with its ships!

Here's some interesting info on the subject regarding the ISS: Staying Cool on the ISS
https://science.nasa.gov/science-news/science-at-nasa/2001/ast21mar_1
Interesting read. Thank you for the link.

I would hope that Starfleet had worked out a way to utilize waste heat in a more efficient manner.
 
Someone earlier asked why does it have to come down to sexuality. Because some people dislike depictions of things they are uncomfortable with, and on the other hand, we LGBTQ+ like to be acknowledged as existing.

Someone also said they thought heterosexual was a term being shied away from. I can't recall that ever being commonly used, and even straight is mostly just mentioned when being not gay. In fact, I would say it's always been the least mentioned identity because it is assumed to be default. Straight characters are not in danger of disappearing. What is hopefully disappearing is the idea that people need to define themselves into slots and then justify any divergence from that slot. For example, I found it annoying when Stamets identified as gay on Discovery because it's needlessly limiting of his identity. It doesn't make sense to me in the confines of the world he lives in. However, I know that it really matters to some that he does identify as something, and to say gay in Star Trek is a step forward.
 
What is hopefully disappearing is the idea that people need to define themselves into slots and then justify any divergence from that slot.
Which is why I really don't like it when it comes back to sexuality. Just let people to be people.

I would say I don't care, except I do because it comes up and it's annoying.
 
Someone earlier asked why does it have to come down to sexuality. Because some people dislike depictions of things they are uncomfortable with, and on the other hand, we LGBTQ+ like to be acknowledged as existing.

Someone also said they thought heterosexual was a term being shied away from. I can't recall that ever being commonly used, and even straight is mostly just mentioned when being not gay. In fact, I would say it's always been the least mentioned identity because it is assumed to be default. Straight characters are not in danger of disappearing. What is hopefully disappearing is the idea that people need to define themselves into slots and then justify any divergence from that slot. For example, I found it annoying when Stamets identified as gay on Discovery because it's needlessly limiting of his identity. It doesn't make sense to me in the confines of the world he lives in. However, I know that it really matters to some that he does identify as something, and to say gay in Star Trek is a step forward.

One of the interesting things is that Gene Roddenberry wanted to acknowledge the slash fans in a positive and accepting manner in TMP novelization. So he made the entire opening where Kirk is amused rather than offended at the idea of he and Spock being lovers, letting it be known that he's straight and certainly would never be involved with a subordinate but has no issue with it and the Federation celebrates all love.

The reaction to the book from the slash Trek community was visceral and full of words like "Betrayal."
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top