Spoilers Star Trek: Discovery 2x08 - "If Memory Serves"
- Thread starter Commander Richard
- Start date
Talos IV and I would get along.
Yes, only the final episode was written as a Holoprogram. CBS canon says they happened.
Watched The Cage for the first time in all its entirety yesterday - in prep for Discovery visiting Talos IV:
Quick thoughts:
I quite enjoyed it: overall it’s strangely surreal (almost like watching a Trek dream in the hazy edges of ones sleep...). I’m glad Shatner replaced Hunter, and that the series changed accordingly - but is interesting to watch as a ‘what-might-have-been’ episode.
I liked the away team blue jackets the crew wore (over the mustard uniform).
Sound effects are great (The blue humming flowers are awesome) - and the painted backdrops are reasonably good, considering budgets / made for TV effects during the 1960s.
Will be interesting to see how Discovery handles the Talosians...
Quick thoughts:
I quite enjoyed it: overall it’s strangely surreal (almost like watching a Trek dream in the hazy edges of ones sleep...). I’m glad Shatner replaced Hunter, and that the series changed accordingly - but is interesting to watch as a ‘what-might-have-been’ episode.
I liked the away team blue jackets the crew wore (over the mustard uniform).
Sound effects are great (The blue humming flowers are awesome) - and the painted backdrops are reasonably good, considering budgets / made for TV effects during the 1960s.
Will be interesting to see how Discovery handles the Talosians...
And said "Historical Holoprogram" was probably about as truly histrically accurate as say, Hamilton.
FTFY - ST: D ain't in the 24th century.
I admit to having strong Yeoman Colt drives.
I would seriously like to see a Pike series with all the roles from The Cage cast into the new crew.
Surely the Talosians power of illusion is why the planet is banned in the Federation. They could very easily make a ship crew press the wrong buttons start some kind of conflict or such while thinking they were doing something else. That kind of power I'm thinking is why going there warrants a death sentence.
What else would make the Federation enact such a draconian edict?
What else would make the Federation enact such a draconian edict?
I have a feeling the Death Penalty was a policy that was forced onto the Federation by the Talosians. They had to have felt themselves backed into a corner to do something as drastic as that.
One way or another, I think we're getting into something that won't be too pretty.
One way or another, I think we're getting into something that won't be too pretty.
The Melkotians seem as problematic a bunch and no edict about them at all.
Needs of the plot.
For some reason, Spock losing his Starfleet career and doing time in the stockade weren't big enough stakes.
Nope, had to be DEAAATH.
It was the Sixties. Every week the show had to have high stakes.For some reason, Spock losing his Starfleet career and doing time in the stockade weren't big enough stakes.
Nope, had to be DEAAATH.
What a way to open!
Okay. That was... different!
It's up. First stop for me tonight is Talos 4, later tonight Hala!
Ahhhhhhhhhh!
Previously on Star Trek!
Previously on Star Trek!
Nice TOS flashback!
Similar threads
- Poll
