I meant the feature film script. Prelude was a 20 minute trailer for the movie.
Spoilers Star Trek: Discovery 1x14 - "The War Without, The War Within"
- Thread starter Commander Richard
- Start date
I meant the feature film script. Prelude was a 20 minute trailer for the movie.
Maybe I need to specify: Solely the portrayal of the klingon-Federation war. Otherwise DIS is of course obviously better - being a professional product and everything.
But honestly? I never had any interest in revisiting that war. It's just boring, everyone knows how it ends, and that it doesn't matter in the grand scheme of things anyway, no matter what they try to tell us.
I like the characters of DIS just fine. And I want to see some real Trek with them. Just WHY oh why did the creators feel the need to to the exact same plot as a fuckin' fanfic?
And then do it somehow worse?
...That was literally just a bunch of talking heads.
Yes.
That.
Ugh. Don't remind me of it. It's almost as painful to watch as DIS' war arc. DIS had better acting and writing. Axanar at least a few colors and more finished CGI.
Unless they blow it up (as the trailer seems to show) and then decide to reset the timeline.
No
I suppose that materializing in hard vacuum (or close enough to it) is more plausible than into an atmosphere. I mean, where does the air go where Discovery is now located? Is it trapped inside the walls? Does air pressure suddenly double on the ship?
...who at least weren't talking about shroom-jumping inside the klingon homeworld under their Mirror Universe Captain on a Starfleet-sanctioned genozide-mission after managing to loose with a multi-species alliance against a few scattered marodeur-clans!
Really, Axanar is no measurement for quality... The only redeeming quality of it is the wonky stuff it didn't do with the material...
That's the only thing I could think of too.
I'm pretty sure that anything involving Tony Todd and J.G. Hertzler has some redeeming qualities.
- Shields only block Transporters is the story needs it and it's been that way for EVERY series be it TOS, TNG, DS9, VOY; etc.
Same with:
- "No transporters at Warp" too
- "You can't turn at Warp..."
- "No activation/use of Warp Drive while inside a Star System..."
^^^
All of which have been said during a Trek episode over the years.
^^^
Nope Saru ordered shields up as soon as they saw the other ship had shields up and weapons targeting them and that was all before the Admiral and Co. started to beam over.
To be fair the very idea of spore jumping an entire starship into a cavern under the surface of Qo'noS is really comic book-y and fanfic-y.
Star Trek has always been a bit comic booky. Not sure about fanficy as I've never read any. But it's definitely Star Treky.
My impression is that the writers have approached this show like a modern Hollywood blockbuster: Define the set pieces and devise cool moments and then write some connective tissue to get from point A to point B.
Well, remember the line in STVI:TUC: "The Klingon Empire has 50 years of life left to it..." and "The Klingon Homeworld will be uninhabitable in that time..," <-- That's 80 years PRIOR to TNG where we (again) see Q'nos habitable; with ancient building/halls on the surface and Klingons living in various districts.
To be fair, so was detonating a giant Christmas light in a nebula, instantly creating a planet on which all space roaches can thrive.
Yep. That is exactly right.
This means that TyVoq will also know that this Georgiou is an imposter. Voq, L'Rell, etc. ate the remains of PGeorgiou.
Can’t you beam through shields if you know the modulation? Given that DSC is a Federation ship, wouldn’t the Admiral or her team know what that was?
Similar threads
- Poll
- Poll
- Poll
