"Spectre of the Gun" might as well be a Chaplin classic by comparison. "TATV" fails on almost every level. "Gun" didn't, even if it was cheesy and just a lame sendoff of the countless TV westerns on the air at the time.
FYI: the overall poll with These Are The Voyages as ENT's representative is now up in General Trek, for those who don't visit that forum but would like to participate in the poll.
No shock here...whatsoever. "TATV" might also be in the running to win the worst overall from any series. It's that cheesy and disappointing.