• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Why is First Contact actually so beloved by the fandom?

That's still a kinder fate than being cut open and getting the implants, while being (possibly) fully awake, considering that the same things also happen during the surgery.
You're fully awake and aware of the nanoprobes too, slowly turning your body against you. That's not kinder. Just happens to involve less surgery. Which, sure, surgery is bad, and all that. But feeling completely powerless to stop this is awful.
 
You're fully awake and aware of the nanoprobes too, slowly turning your body against you. That's not kinder. Just happens to involve less surgery. Which, sure, surgery is bad, and all that. But feeling completely powerless to stop this is awful.
Yes, but nanoprobes work really fast. So there is a shorter amount of time to feel the pain and the trauma before being one with the Borg.
 
Another thing which makes assimilation by nanoprobes preferable is that you still have a (although extremely) short amount of time to either kill yourself or get killed by your colleagues (the second even after the assimilation), while this is very unlikely to happen if you are captured by them and already in an assimilation chamber...
 
The BQ is quite dysfunctional note how she's constantly chatting, commenting on everything she does when there's no one around to listen. She seems a bit unbalanced.
 
I noticed recently while watching TNG-R bonus stuff that they replaced the matte painting in Q Who that showed the massive Borg cube interior with a digital recreation that used FC/VOY designs for the alcoves. It's kinda odd now, cause only that small live set piece has the TNG design, and the rest of the cube is updated. But it retcons the newer design into the 2360s ;)
 
To make my point clearer, compare being captured by the Borg to be put under a brutal surgery while possibly still being conscious at that time with being ambushed by a drone, getting injected with nano probes and then when already being part of the collective going through the procedure.

I was never able to make it work, because that kind of body horror has never played to my strengths as a writer, but in the era when Pocket Books was publishing the Strange New Worlds anthologies I took a couple of whacks at a story about a character who gets injected with Borg nanoprobes and, while the assimilation of the body works and the Borg are able to hijack the nervous system, the assimilation of the brain fails, resulting in a character who is fully aware of what's happened to their body and completely unable to do anything about it. It would be a lot like sleep paralysis -- which I've experienced a handful of times in my life and it was absolutely terrifying -- but far, far worse, because at least with sleep paralysis a person will escape from it, while Borg assimilation is something that will never be escaped from.
 
My impression is that that's actually what happens on screen as well - they witness everything, remember it all, but can't do anything about it
 
For all the issues with introducing the Borg Queen, First Contact is still head and shoulders and torso and waist above Insurrection and Nemesis, so it likely benefits from comparison.
 
For all the issues with introducing the Borg Queen, First Contact is still head and shoulders and torso and waist above Insurrection and Nemesis, so it likely benefits from comparison.

About that. It's funny but the head, shoulders, and a little bit of the torso are all that's left of the Queen's original body, yet after the dissolution, we see that even that part is mostly metal!! That's some drastic assimilation!
 
About that. It's funny but the head, shoulders, and a little bit of the torso are all that's left of the Queen's original body, yet after the dissolution, we see that even that part is mostly metal!! That's some drastic assimilation!
and you expect assimilation to be less drastic...?
 
I was never able to make it work, because that kind of body horror has never played to my strengths as a writer, but in the era when Pocket Books was publishing the Strange New Worlds anthologies I took a couple of whacks at a story about a character who gets injected with Borg nanoprobes and, while the assimilation of the body works and the Borg are able to hijack the nervous system, the assimilation of the brain fails, resulting in a character who is fully aware of what's happened to their body and completely unable to do anything about it. It would be a lot like sleep paralysis -- which I've experienced a handful of times in my life and it was absolutely terrifying -- but far, far worse, because at least with sleep paralysis a person will escape from it, while Borg assimilation is something that will never be escaped from.

My impression is that that's actually what happens on screen as well - they witness everything, remember it all, but can't do anything about it

That's how Jean Luc described his experiences as Locutus in "Family", but from what we've seen and heard since then, especially in Voyager, this aspect was also retconned into something easier to accept and for some people like the xbs in "Unity" and Seven (at the beginning of her arc) even to prefer, compared to existence as an individual.
 
I noticed recently while watching TNG-R bonus stuff that they replaced the matte painting in Q Who that showed the massive Borg cube interior with a digital recreation that used FC/VOY designs for the alcoves. It's kinda odd now, cause only that small live set piece has the TNG design, and the rest of the cube is updated. But it retcons the newer design into the 2360s ;)

I'm looking at screencaps, and wow, yeah. Though they seem to still be the same colour scheme as the TNG ones.

gh2AlhF.png
 
Last edited:
And they're bigger and look like the plasma lightning plates from FC/VOY, instead of the almost static noodle plates from TNG
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top