Since we seem to be having the “TOS-R: Threat or Menace?” discussion again, here’s my take on it:
Back in the day, I tried to get my life partner into Trek by watching “The Menagerie”. She didn’t get very far, literally laughing at the old effects (which I thought were perfectly fine).
Years later, the Remaster came along, and we tried that version of “The Menagerie”. She never noticed the effects at all, but Part 2 ended and she turned to me and said, with surprise, “That was terrific!”
And that’s why I’ll never damn the Remaster, or complain that the CGI isn’t good enough—because that’s not the point. The point is that it enabled a modern viewer to get past their own visual prejudices and see the story. For that, TOS-R was a job well done, even if I disagree with some of its choices.
Back in the day, I tried to get my life partner into Trek by watching “The Menagerie”. She didn’t get very far, literally laughing at the old effects (which I thought were perfectly fine).
Years later, the Remaster came along, and we tried that version of “The Menagerie”. She never noticed the effects at all, but Part 2 ended and she turned to me and said, with surprise, “That was terrific!”
And that’s why I’ll never damn the Remaster, or complain that the CGI isn’t good enough—because that’s not the point. The point is that it enabled a modern viewer to get past their own visual prejudices and see the story. For that, TOS-R was a job well done, even if I disagree with some of its choices.