• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

What are your controversial Star Trek opinions?

Pulaski was more interesting period. Beverly was fine, but once you knew she was Picard's one-time love interest and the mom of Wesley and widow of Picard's late best friend there wasn't much left the producers did with her.

I mean, ghost fucking. I guess.

But she put on plays! TNG crew new how to have fun. Go listen to classical music. Watch a play Dr Crusher play put on. Play poker despite nobody having money to bet on. Have sex with Riker. So many options.
 
And the third time, the separation was done off screen.

As it should be. I see no reason why it had to be "expensive". You build up the library shots just like you did for the whole ship. Editing and story telling should have easily carried the day here.

The ship separating wasn't any more inherently dramatic than standard orbit. The ship being in danger was the drama.

Who cast those two together anyway? And how did DS9 do a better job there?

No offense to McFadden, but she wasn't Patrick Stewart or Avery Brooks. And Stewart and Wheaton did a pretty good job together.

I always liked Bev in TNG, but she was often the Chekov of that series. Usually there, usually having lines but not much to do.

There's got to be a better comparison than Chekov. McFadden would have given a leg to have as much screen time and character as Chekov.

Pulaski was more interesting period. Beverly was fine, but once you knew she was Picard's one-time love interest and the mom of Wesley and widow of Picard's late best friend there wasn't much left the producers did with her.

I mean, ghost fucking. I guess.

I mean, Liam Shaw was more interesting. He sucked and I hated him, but that's interest.

Yes, I'm entirely hung up on Data. If she really had been as indifferent to him as a piece of machinery that might have been something. But she was MAD about it.

Pulaski got better development in 1 season than Crusher got in 6.

She was a bold and vivid character. Not one I wished to spend time with.
 
I liked Disco Klingons, but they should have been post TNG, after a cataclysm changed them body and soul. Iratus bug maybe. Events similar to the end of "Spock Must Die" and the recent godwar comics
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top