What are your controversial Star Trek opinions?

[CmdrJoe]

Starfleet Marines exist, and they are the military successors of the MACO's.
Change my mind. Nvm. You won't.

 

[cooleddie74]

In my head canon the ground infantry strike team we see on Nimbus III in Star Trek V is the late 23rd century equivalent of the MACOs.

 

[Bad Thoughts]

I would absolute watch a serious spy show about Starfleet Intelligence officers hunting down and arresting Section 31 operatives before they can carry out one of their plans.

Star Trek: Garak

Well-dressed, flamboyant, witty, and cruel to the bone.

 

[Kamen Rider Blade]

I've said it before, but I would absolute watch a serious spy show about Starfleet Intelligence officers hunting down and arresting Section 31 operatives before they can carry out one of their plans. You could have actual spy work, gun fights, spaceship chases, a mole in the team they have to flush out, proper moral ambiguity. Make it the closest thing to Star Trek: Andor (except the folks in the intelligence organisation are the good guys and the other guys doing assassinations are the bad guys).

I dunno, maybe it's the wrong time for that kind of series.

I'd rather see a proper "Section 31" TV show be a inverted version of the ALIAS TV show.

So 'Section 31' would take the role of 'SD-6', but all their actions are for the benefit / safety of the UFP.

But all actions are done in secret by clandestine civilians who live as regular citizens in the UFP who have cover jobs and their real jobs are to be secret agents.

 

[CoveTom]

Bad Writing or Not, it affects all of us since it's now part of "Established Canon" that Section 31 was a legal lawful Government Entity underneath StarFleet Intelligence.

The fact that it is "established canon" seems to mean a lot more to you than it does to me.

 

[Farscape One]

True. But neither is Sisko. (I guess a command officer should know a general outline of history, though.)

Sisko did say studying about the 21st century was a hobby of his when he and Bashir were being walked into the Sanctuary District, so it makes sense Sisko would know about the Bell Riots.

Starfleet Marines exist, and they are the military successors of the MACO's.
Change my mind. Nvm. You won't.

In my head canon the ground infantry strike team we see on Nimbus III in Star Trek V is the late 23rd century equivalent of the MACOs.

Plus DS9's "NOR THE BATTLE TO THE STRONG, season 5. They are definitely a different uniform than other Starfleet officers we see.

 

[XCV330]

To view this content we will need your consent to set third party cookies.
For more detailed information, see our cookies page.

Accept third party cookies

Established Canon comes in spicy ranch and contains Ed’s DNA

 

[kkt]

Star Trek: Garak

Well-dressed, flamboyant, witty, and cruel to the bone.

If only Andrew Robinson were still working as an actor!

 

[Kamen Rider Blade]

The fact that it is "established canon" seems to mean a lot more to you than it does to me.

I don't ignore what Paramount deems as "Trek Canon", if it's inconvenient to me.

That includes controversial topics like:
- Section 31
- Discovery
- Spore Drive & Mycelial Network.
- JJ-Verse
- etc.

I just make it work within the larger context of the Trek Universe.