• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

USS Enterprise (eventually) on Discovery?

The display on the left has the angled pylons, the disply in the center has straight pylons, the display on the right looks like it has straight pylons.

Still an absolute beauty of a bridge.

I think that's just a trick of the light, or something. They all look angled to me.
 
They did do a good job. I probably sound overly harsh but I was pointing out what I noticed while I was watching because they were jumping out to me. To most viewers, it probably wouldn't jump out as much, if at all. And I'm impressed that as much of TOS was retained as it was. I honestly expected the Enterprise to look more like something out of Star Trek VI and I'm glad they didn't do that.

Comparing the two updates of the Original Enterprise: Though I understand the Abrams Films had to do their own thing, I prefer Discovery's version.
I do like this take on the classic tos
 
From the inside, the windows seem to tilt downward. That's not such a good fit for deck 2 but there are matching windows on about deck 7.
I think most of the saucer windows on the model, including the ones on the bridge superstructure on deck 2 (deck 1, now?) were replaced by DSC-style rabbit-tooth windows. There are a few circular ones, but I'm not sure if there are any pairs that close to each other. I can't be sure if there's not a third window, though, in which case it might be the three at the very forward of the saucer, though the windows look a little small to be those.

Well, its not the first time the windows didn't match up with the sets, and it won't be the last.
 
Pretending it's the same when direct video evidence shows otherwise is fanon (no offense).

It’s all pretend. All make believe.

Producers are asking us to pretend this was the bridge that Kirk would/will inherit. And I think they've done a grand-enough job that I’m able to imagine that if we were to remake TOS today it would look like this (no offense).
 
Last edited:
It will in 2265, and I doubt any of the new shows will last that long. Even starting a Pike show now for a 7 year run brings us up to 2264. The chances of actually remaking TOS are extremely small because that show already exists. So nothing prevents a refit after the Pike show, or whatever.

Canon (visual evidence from the shows itself) shows that the bridge does change. How or why doesn't matter, just that it's done before 'Where no man has gone before'. Pretending it's the same when direct video evidence shows otherwise is fanon (no offense).
Yeah no. Them using footage from 'The Cage' tells us otherwise. This is a visual reboot.
 
How dull is your crew if you need that many red lights for them to know they're in a dangerous situation? :lol:

Lets see, aliens, different visual spectrums, people working at different areas of a large workspace that need something in everyones field of view at a given time...
 
If they can't see red, then more red isn't going to help them. :p

A consistent level around their work area will though. I've worked in offices that used LED systems around very large open plan spaces to create consistent levels during different parts of the day.

Typical human centrism though...
 
They need the extra room to hide the alcohol...
Nah, it'll be like that Black Mirror episode, where a panel swings around and there's a cabinet.
I have one tiny nitpick, but it's not about the bridge. I always assumed that the briefing room in WNMHGB was on deck 2 at the center of the saucer. Now it has two round portholes that suggest it's somewhere much lower in the saucer, and not centered. This seems odd to me for a circular room.
DSC-S2E13-64.jpg

It looks really nice though.
Is that a reimagined NX-01 painting? Or is it a weird angle on the 1701 which makes it look like it's just nacelles and a saucer?
 
Yeah no. Them using footage from 'The Cage' tells us otherwise. This is a visual reboot.
How was using footage from the Cage saying otherwise? There was a refit between Cage and Disc, and another one between Disc and TOS...

You don't have to like the idea, but to conclusively say something against visual video evidence just seems very odd.
 
I like the insides of the Enterprise a lot more than the uninspired outsides. But when they go to red alert, it turns into a nightclub, which is not entirely a bad thing.
Should have been Black Alert and they could all have played Pin the Tail on the Donkey in the dark. :biggrin:
 
How was using footage from the Cage saying otherwise? There was a refit between Cage and Disc, and another one between Disc and TOS...

You don't have to like the idea, but to conclusively say something against visual video evidence just seems very odd.
So they turned it back to the way it looked 10 years before? (the previously on used Season 1 footage for the exterior of the Enterprise, not 'The Cage') How does that make sense?
 
I think most of the saucer windows on the model, including the ones on the bridge superstructure on deck 2 (deck 1, now?) were replaced by DSC-style rabbit-tooth windows. There are a few circular ones, but I'm not sure if there are any pairs that close to each other. I can't be sure if there's not a third window, though, in which case it might be the three at the very forward of the saucer, though the windows look a little small to be those.

Well, its not the first time the windows didn't match up with the sets, and it won't be the last.
The saucer edge has the rabbit tooth windows, but I think there are some round windows just above the sensor dome that could be close enough together to be the briefing room.
Is that a reimagined NX-01 painting? Or is it a weird angle on the 1701 which makes it look like it's just nacelles and a saucer?
I'm pretty sure it's just a weird angle. An NX-01 painting would be great though.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top