• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

The Outcast and the limits of metaphors

Probably just demonstrating that while humans typically aren't polyamorous, other cultures might be.
Like when in a not-scifi tv series they shows someone from Pakistan with multiple wives. It's not like the authors are taking a stance to legalize polygamy in the Western World.
 
I think it was "The Emperor's New Cloak" when Ezri and Kira embrace.
Seems like the mirror universe lesbian kissing was not meant to be taken seriously, but I'd still say that Jadzia kissing her former wife Lenara in "Rejoined" was actually a step forward in openness about homosexuality on Trek. It was all about tenderness, understanding and a committed relationship.
If woman-woman sexuality was just indulging the male gaze, they'd have found a way to get it on TOS - !

ALBERT: I've got an idea. Why not make them, you know, a dream?
BENNY: What's that?
ALBERT: Just make the ending of your first story, Deep Space Nine, a dream.
BENNY: Would that make a difference?
PABST: That depends.
KAY: On what?
PABST: On who's doing the dreaming.
KAY: Well, obviously someone, er, someone without a lot of hope. A shoeshine boy, a convict, someone dreaming of a better future.
PABST: A Negro.
DARLENE: Yeah well, I suppose he'd have to be if he was dreaming about a Negro captain.
HERBERT: Hold on. Making it a dream guts the story.
PABST: Shut up, Herb.
JULIUS: I think it makes it more poignant.
HERBERT: What about the other Sisko stories? You can't make them all dreams.
KAY: Let him get this one published first, then he can worry about the others.
JULIUS: What do you think, Benny?
BENNY: I think it's better than chalk on the sidewalk.

There are no lesbians in the "real' world, so it's safe to let your children watch this children's show.

It's a very god children's show, and it's made for adults, but mostly, in the beginning, either children watched it, or adults watched it who watched Kirk as a child.

All these other earlier programs with the representation in them were made for adults.
 
I'd still say that Jadzia kissing her former wife Lenara in "Rejoined" was actually a step forward in openness about homosexuality on Trek.
What I thought was most meaningful in that episode was that Jadzia actually made the choice to go with Lenara, despite the penalties. We see Jadzia waiting for her former spouse; it's Lenara who turns away. I suppose it's ultimately meaningless, since Lenara's choice made Jadzia's moot, but still....I had really thought that they would find a way to keep her from having to make the choice at all.

But again, making the affected characters Trill does change the look of the message somewhat. (And I don't mean by covering it in spots. ;))
Like when in a not-scifi tv series they shows someone from Pakistan with multiple wives. It's not like the authors are taking a stance to legalize polygamy in the Western World.
Or, a bit more harshly....
There are no lesbians in the "real' world, so it's safe to let your children watch this children's show.
 
Star Trek was usually as subtle as a sledgehammer with its messages

And often slammed for that.

Soren said she identified as a female since childhood therefore was attracted to those who identify as males. It's like saying that every guy man wants to be a woman and every lesbian woman wants to be a man (or viceversa).

Yes that was a flaw.

They certainly are hiding behind their gimmicks to tell this story, & it's fair imho to criticize them for it some

Sure but a lot of Trek does too, most comes to mind the Kirk/Uhura kiss in "Plato's Stepchildren" being compelled.
 
Remember also that this was going to feature actual kissing... the first same-sex kiss on TV didn't occur until 1991. So this would have been a seriously groundbreaking event. Maybe TPTB weren't quite bold enough for that.

Yes the there had already been gay characters in All in the Family and MASH in the '70s point doesn't mean "The Outcast" being bolder and more direct wouldn't have still been more groundbreaking than most television in its time.
 
But again, making the affected characters Trill does change the look of the message somewhat. ....

Fair enough.
Back to TNG – another erotic woman/woman scene was Deanna and Beverly exercising together while talking about sex, in “The Price.”

It surprised me that Trek was considered a children’s show in the UK….so was it aired alongside Saturday morning cartoons? I read that 4 episodes of TOS were banned for years --Miri, Plato's Stepchildren, The Empath, and Whom Gods Destroy. Interesting that they banned TNG “High Ground,” also “Conspiracy” but had no problem with “The Outcast.” Admirable actually, IMHO.
 
Last edited:
Mirror Bashir was presumably never genetically modified, but we don't see him as having any issues. No mental ones anyway... any human living in that universe would have other kinds of issues!
 
Didn't PrimeBashir even suggest that he might have turned out reasonably fine without augmentation in the end?

As someone with likely a mild case of Asperger's, I likely manifested such much more noticeably when I was younger, but as I grew older (and became aware of my situation), I developed adaptations.

My point being that we don't really know what an Unaugmented version of PrimeBashir might have looked like, but it might have looked somewhat more like MU Bashir.
 
Didn't PrimeBashir even suggest that he might have turned out reasonably fine without augmentation in the end?

As someone with likely a mild case of Asperger's, I likely manifested such much more noticeably when I was younger, but as I grew older (and became aware of my situation), I developed adaptations.

My point being that we don't really know what an Unaugmented version of PrimeBashir might have looked like, but it might have looked somewhat more like MU Bashir.

Bashir was saying to his dad that he already figured Julian was a failure at 5 years old, and didn't give him a real chance. He may be right. Mirror Universe Bashir might be the only gauge we have, though I'm hesitant to call him a decent barometer of any kind for comparison.
 
As someone with likely a mild case of Asperger's, I likely manifested such much more noticeably when I was younger, but as I grew older (and became aware of my situation), I developed adaptations.

As someone with a mild to moderate case of same, and a former special educator and current special ed bus driver; I can tell you that Bashir's issues, as described, were more likely either being a slow learner (a person with an IQ between 75 and 90) or having a learning disability.

Mirror Universe Bashir might be the only gauge we have, though I'm hesitant to call him a decent barometer of any kind for comparison.

He was pissed off, he was scruffy looking, and he was otherwise completely forgettable.
 
Difference between "The Outcast" and "Half a Life" is that what was done to Soren was never presented as anything but the hateful and disgusting violation that it was. Half a Life actually seemed to condone the guy's (forgot his name) death at the end. That's why I hate that episode so passionately. Contrastingly, I don't enjoy watching the ending of "The Outcast", but I recognize that it was necessary to make its point.



Remember also that this was going to feature actual kissing... the first same-sex kiss on TV didn't occur until 1991. So this would have been a seriously groundbreaking event. Maybe TPTB weren't quite bold enough for that.



Urghhh... pretty sure lore says they breed in the underground pools, which suggests three possibilities:
1. They have a specific sex of their own, but consider it irrelevant: they go with whatever the host is.
2. They reproduce sexually, but they're hermaphroditic.
3. They reproduce asexually, via binary fission or something similar.

You are incorrect. The first same-sex kiss occurred on tv in 1979. (Dan Aykroyd and Garrett Morris in "The Pepsi Syndrome" as part of an SNL skit. This would also make it the first interracial same-sex kiss.)
 
You are incorrect. The first same-sex kiss occurred on tv in 1979. (Dan Aykroyd and Garrett Morris in "The Pepsi Syndrome" as part of an SNL skit. This would also make it the first interracial same-sex kiss.)

To view this content we will need your consent to set third party cookies.
For more detailed information, see our cookies page.

1972.

Doesn't count because it was a cheek rape?
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top