The MOST Disliked Episode of TNG - Final Part...

[Orac]

I'm giving my point to Transfigurations again. Same reason.

Angel One - 1
Up The Long Ladder - 0
The Outrageous Okona - 0
Transfigurations - 2
Galaxy's Child - 0
New Ground - 1
Violations - 0
Homeward - 1

 

[BigDaveX]

I'll vote for Homeward again. Like I said previously, I wouldn't really have that much of a problem with it if it weren't for the Prime Directive stuff early on.

Angel One - 1
Up The Long Ladder - 0
The Outrageous Okona - 0
Transfigurations - 2
Galaxy's Child - 0
New Ground - 1
Violations - 0
Homeward - 2

 

[tomswift2002]

The Outrageous Okona for the same reasons as before.

Angel One - 1
Up The Long Ladder - 0
The Outrageous Okona - 1
Transfigurations - 2
Galaxy's Child - 0
New Ground - 1
Violations - 0
Homeward - 2

 

[BlueStuff]

I vote Transfigurations purely for "less talk. More synthehol."

Angel One - 1
Up The Long Ladder - 0
The Outrageous Okona - 1
Transfigurations - 3
Galaxy's Child - 0
New Ground - 1
Violations - 0
Homeward - 2

 

[JirinPanthosa]

Galaxy's Child again, due to just being the least flawed left. Homeward reminds you of TNG's silly prime directive interpretation, Transfigurations makes its character messianic, New Ground brought in a character that never brought anything good to the show, Violations had scenes that were a bit too uncomfortable for having such little payoff.

Angel One - 1
Up The Long Ladder - 0
The Outrageous Okona - 1
Transfigurations - 3
Galaxy's Child - 1
New Ground - 1
Violations - 0
Homeward - 2

 

[Orac]

Transfigurations has been eliminated from the list.

Angel One - 0
Up The Long Ladder - 0
The Outrageous Okona - 0
Galaxy's Child - 0
New Ground - 0
Violations - 0
Homeward - 0

 

[Horta]

I really like "New Ground." Overall, a good look at family life on the Enterprise. Good story. Also, I like Worf's parents (great casting!), and young Alexander does a great acting job. As a bonus, I love the scene where Riker staggers out of the burning school room with the caged children's creature.

Angel One - 0
Up The Long Ladder - 0
The Outrageous Okona - 0
Galaxy's Child - 0
New Ground - 1
Violations - 0
Homeward - 0

 

[Farscape One]

I will give a point to "Homeward" for the same reason I did last time.

Angel One - 0
Up The Long Ladder - 0
The Outrageous Okona - 0
Galaxy's Child - 0
New Ground - 1
Violations - 0
Homeward - 1

 

[Sakonna]

I'll repeat my vote for Angel One. In addition to previous reason, it gives us the most recycled planet matte painting in all of Star Trek!

http://www.ex-astris-scientia.org/inconsistencies/reused_planets_angelone.htm

Angel One - 1
Up The Long Ladder - 0
The Outrageous Okona - 0
Galaxy's Child - 0
New Ground - 1
Violations - 0
Homeward - 1

 

[tomswift2002]

The Outrageous Okona for the same reasons as before.

Angel One - 1
Up The Long Ladder - 0
The Outrageous Okona - 1
Galaxy's Child - 0
New Ground - 1
Violations - 0
Homeward - 1

 

[Garth Rockett]

New Ground for Worf accepting his parental responsibilities.

Angel One - 1
Up The Long Ladder - 0
The Outrageous Okona - 1
Galaxy's Child - 0
New Ground - 2
Violations - 0
Homeward - 1

 

[Brennyren]

Another vote for "New Ground." Because parental responsibility is a good thing.

Angel One - 1
Up The Long Ladder - 0
The Outrageous Okona - 1
Galaxy's Child - 0
New Ground - 3
Violations - 0
Homeward - 1

 

[JirinPanthosa]

One more for Galaxy's Child. Below average episode, but I think it's awesome to see Trek call BS on one of it's previous scripts.

Angel One - 1
Up The Long Ladder - 0
The Outrageous Okona - 1
Galaxy's Child - 1
New Ground - 3
Violations - 0
Homeward - 1

 

[BlueStuff]

I concur with the above reasoning about Galaxy's Child. I dig the continuity.

Angel One - 1
Up The Long Ladder - 0
The Outrageous Okona - 1
Galaxy's Child - 2
New Ground - 3
Violations - 0
Homeward - 1

 

[Orac]

I gave Galaxy's Child a point, because I dig space borne organisms.

Angel One - 1
Up The Long Ladder - 0
The Outrageous Okona - 1
Galaxy's Child - 3
New Ground - 3
Violations - 0
Homeward - 1

 

[Horta]

Just as an aside. I like a lot of these episodes. The only one I dislike on this list is "Violations." I would have included on the "dud" list, "Code of Honor," and "Sub Rosa".

 

[Takeru]

Galaxy's Child has been saved, I liked Leah and her callimg Geordie out for being a creep.

Angel One - 0
Up The Long Ladder - 0
The Outrageous Okona - 0
New Ground - 0
Violations - 0
Homeward - 0

 

[BlueStuff]

With no great enthusiasm, I'll vote New Ground, simply because I guess it's the least bad of those remaining.

Angel One - 0
Up The Long Ladder - 0
The Outrageous Okona - 0
New Ground - 1
Violations - 0
Homeward - 0

 

[Garth Rockett]

I'll repeat my prior vote for New Ground.

Angel One - 0
Up The Long Ladder - 0
The Outrageous Okona - 0
New Ground - 2
Violations - 0
Homeward - 0

 

[JirinPanthosa]

This has become a hard decision. Three of the series worst are there, not going to vote for 'OMG SO CLEVER REVERSAL OF GENDER NORMS but we're gonna write it like it's some weird abnormal thing for women to be strong and make all the men on the planet completely weak and cloying because yeah we totally missed the point', the dull condescending one or the abject comedy fail.

Between the three mediocre skippable episodes remaining, probably between New Ground and Homeward, since Violations doesn't offer much and is a bit uncomfortable to watch. Homeward has the bigger flaw in that it has that 'Prime directive says we have to allow apocalypse' crap, but it also has bigger upside. The whole holodeck journey is clever, whereas Alexander was only ever annoying. I will vote Homeward.

Angel One - 0
Up The Long Ladder - 0
The Outrageous Okona - 0
New Ground - 2
Violations - 0
Homeward - 1