• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

The High Republic: A more civilized age...

I get that. Lucas just never elaborated what that meant until years later. He could have been called Dark Lord of the Pies for all it mattered.
 
I get that. Lucas just never elaborated what that meant until years later. He could have been called Dark Lord of the Pies for all it mattered.
Well there's no point setting anything in stone until it's relevant to a given story. As I said even he changed his mind about certain things over the years and adjusted accordingly. Doing otherwise would just risk getting painted into a corner.

But still, as I said the idea that the Sith were a rival order of knights was there pretty much from the jump. Indeed the opening scene of the rough draft IIRC was a Sith Knight hunting the protagonist (Annikin Starkiller in that version I think?) while they were hiding out in the desert by their ship, and killing his younger brother. A scene that was kinda-sorta repurposed for TPM...and maybe one of the Ewok movies too.

When he was developing ESB & RotJ the idea was that Yoda being a Jedi Master meant he was a separate thing than a Jedi Knight. Like the Masters were primarily spiritual gurus that the Knights went to to train, and they they themselves have a whole different path and are not just senior Knights in their own right--hence no lightsaber. Sort of the priests of the order, while the Knights were the martial arm. Which by extension meant that the Emperor was Yoda's opposite number and the same in that sense; he wasn't a Sith Lord but a Sith Master--also hence no lightsaber. Clearly by TPM he'd changed his mind about that as he'd have to think about the organisation of the Jedi and Sith in more detail than before, but the general idea of what a Sith is never really changed.

I always found it odd that LF let KJA & Veitch define the "Sith" as a species since Zahn wanted to do the same thing just a few years earlier and it was nixed, so he called them Noghri instead. One assumes the design of the red skinned "Sith Species" from the EU will show up in canon at some point, just under a different name; maybe just "Massassi", or something like "Korribani", "Morabandian", or perhaps just repurpose "Sith'ari" to mean "slaves of the Sith", as in they were a total mix breed species that were enslaved for so many generations that any sense of an original culture or name was wiped out and forgotten.
 
Last edited:
Finished The Rising Storm a few days ago, absolutely fantastic. As good as if not better than Light of the Jedi. It's refreshing to have something set in a new era where anything can happen.

The whole High Republic initiative seems to be really well thought out. It's great that they have the whole storyline mapped out (that's not a dig at the sequels, I love them, 7 and 8 especially).
 
Read the second YA. It was alright. Wasn’t as enjoyable as the other books. One major thing happens at the end which I thought would have been a bigger deal but it didn’t feel like it.
The Reath/Nan story is the most interesting thing currently
 
My issue has always been that Zahn did that thing where writers conflate high intelligence with omniscience. It's one of my biggest pet peeves.
 
Will it make a difference in following the stories if I read the first volume of the Marvel High Republic comic before or after Light of the Jedi? I have both and I had originally planned on reading Light first, but I'm finding myself in a comic and Star Wars mood, so I was thinking about reading There is No Fear, the first volume of the comic, now.
 
Read the novel first. The comic is set after that.
The first YA novel should be read before the comic as well but it isn’t required.
 
Will it make a difference in following the stories if I read the first volume of the Marvel High Republic comic before or after Light of the Jedi? I have both and I had originally planned on reading Light first, but I'm finding myself in a comic and Star Wars mood, so I was thinking about reading There is No Fear, the first volume of the comic, now.
Honestly it won't make a huge difference. Even though it shares some character, and the events carry right on from the first two books, the actual plot of the comic is basically self contained in that any background information is summarised for you.
 
Last edited:
OK, that was kind of what I thought would be the case. I'll probably ahead and start the comic then, it might even help to at least have a little bit of a visual reference for the stuff it shares with the novels.
 
After my post I started There is No Fear, but I decided to stop when I hit what appeared to be a reference to the events of The Light of the Jedi. I know I probably could have kept going without being too lost, but I decided since I already have The Light of the Jedi, I'll just wait and read that first. I decided to switch over to the 6th volume of the Marvel no subtitle series for my Star Wars comics fix instead.
 
Lucasfilm has revealed some of the first information about Phase II of The High Republic in a new anniversary special of The High Republic Show.
I didn't watch the show, but they did post an article recapping some of the information revealed.
  • Phase II will begin in October of this year.
  • It will take place 150 years in the past.
  • George Mann, Zoraida Cordova, Tess Gratton, and Lydia Kang will be joining the author line up.
  • Cavan Scott will write the Marvel comic
  • Charles Soule will be writting a Marvel comic that explores Porter Engle's backstory.
  • Daniel Jose Older will be writing an all ages The High Republic Adventures graphic novel for Dark Horse,
  • Justina Ireland & new author Tessa Gratton will write the first YA novel for Phase II.
  • Claudia Gray will be doing something for Phase II, but she won't say what.
 
We are already jumping ahead? We are only on the third book. Wasn’t aware they were treating it like the movies with them being trilogies
 
Jumping back not forward, and it's not starting until October. There is still quite a bit of stuff coming out before then, we still have at least 3 issues of the monthly comic, the Trail of Shadows comic miniseries, the Eye of the Storm comic minseries, 3 issue of THR Adventures, the YA novel Midnight Horizon, and the kids book The Battle for Starlight.
 
I know but I see the novels as the main arc of the story. The rest are just tie ins. From what I’ve read of the series so far, the novels and the YA ones are all you need. The comics have been forgettable. They’re just good to put some images onto things.
Haven’t tried the audio play yet. From reading The Fallen Star, that could be a interesting one.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top