Or i wonder if during the battle with the Injustice Society got sent to Earth Prime, and Joan was able to figure out a way to get to him (but not come back). They settled in at Keystone City, using their names... they may not have been famous enough for people to notice?This definitely raises a lot questions. Some time after Crisis aired I believe the Flash show runner said Jay and Joan Garrick would now be living on Earth Prime. Which raised questions about being doppelgängers of Henry and Nora who are dead. That may have been a smokescreen to hide this. The whole shutdown John vaguely said he was told there are future plans for Jay. Was this it? Or is he playing two different characters on both shows?
If he is dead on Earth 2 but alive on Earth Prime it would be nice to see the reaction of his friends on Earth 2?