• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Spoilers Starfleet Academy General Discussion Thread

I would assume so as well, but the Travelers are arguably more enigmatic than the Q. Honestly, it wouldn't shock me for Wesley of all people to go "Ok, now we're talking guys" and pop in. I sort of hope they don't go that route, unless the Travelers come back for a good reason. Considering they can travel time so easily, it seems possible to me that his comment could have been a sort of "push in the right direction" so to speak. Like a Q lesson. He did sort of give that Q feeling too in Picard.

I do hope it's someone else, that we genuinely haven't seen in a long time.
Yeah, I doubt it will be Wesley for that reason. We've seen him on three different shows in the modern era. I expect they're talking about someone not seen since BermaTrek.
 
I think more likely is that, by all accounts SMG is a humdinger of a human and when offered the chance to visit the set and meet the new cast, she jumped at it because she is just.... a really nice person.
That’s true, and I didn’t want to imply Martin-Green appearing on the show was a certainty, but there was also this TrekMovie article from a few weeks ago, which might make you see it as at least a little more likely … :)

 
I see the Burn as more of an attempt to “revert” the galaxy ala Fallout and the destruction of Shady Sands. Before the Burn, TNG and DS9 had made it seem that the Milky Way or at least Alpha Quadrant had become too known and civilized. The Burn returns it to the Wild West of the TOS era.

I agree that was the desire to do The Burn. To basically reset the Star Trek universe and move away from Roddenberry's utopia. KInd of funny though how you would think such a story would go is you would focus on characters who are more outlaws and cowboys. Academy and Discovery before it seems to be taking it in another direction. How the hippies tamed the west. :)
 
Can't find it now, but in an interview I saw on YT today, Yashere and Notaro talked about Thok and Reno being a couple in SFA. Initially I though they were tongue in cheek, but no - it's true, and we get to see them at home in domestic bliss.....

I am glad Reno then is going to have a big role in the show. She is one of the few things that worked in the first two episodes. I thought she might only be in a few of the episodes.
 
I agree that was the desire to do The Burn. To basically reset the Star Trek universe and move away from Roddenberry's utopia. KInd of funny though how you would think such a story would go is you would focus on characters who are more outlaws and cowboys. Academy and Discovery before it seems to be taking in another direction. How the hippies tamed the west. :)

I am here for Hippie Star Trek. I feel like it could be just as valid as a take on the Utopia concept as was envisioned in the 1980s. I do admit that I find the "reconstruction of the Federation" to be really cool and very Archer.
 
I am here for Hippie Star Trek. I feel like it could be just as valid as a take on the Utopia concept as was envisioned in the 1980s. I do admit that I find the "reconstruction of the Federation" to be really cool and very Archer.

I feel like if it's going to work they got to make the war college aspect of the show work to contrast it. If Starfleet Academy is going to be 1960's Berkeley then the War College has to be something like West Point or The Citadel.
 
Can't find it now, but in an interview I saw on YT today, Yashere and Notaro talked about Thok and Reno being a couple in SFA. Initially I though they were tongue in cheek, but no - it's true, and we get to see them at home in domestic bliss.....
If this is true it could turn out excellent, Thok's already got the potential to be one of the more entertaining characters in the series and this kind of thing could give her a sympathetic/softer edge which just makes the drill sargeant stuff land even better.
 
I feel like if it's going to work they got to make the war college aspect of the show work to contrast it. If Starfleet Academy is going to be 1960's Berkeley then the War College has to be something like West Point or The Citadel.

Agreed, they are positioning this to be an allegory, and they need to commit to it. Starfleet ends up "winning" and folding the War College into their structure, forming one united Star Fleet, much like the MACOs in Enterprise, however they get there is where the story lies. I feel like with Tamira in the War College, it's definitely going to have a lot of contrast. Caleb looked downright betrayed when he heard she went to the War College, I can't imagine they don't capitalize on that plot thread.
 
You know what I expect to maybe see in that episode that pays homage to DS9. I think we might see Sisko's house he wanted to build on Bajor. Something that has become something a holly site that Bajorans come and worship at and sort of go to to have a religious experience. Also I think we might see that Starfleet ship named after Captain Nog.
 
I found Lura Thok's drill Sergent act in her introduction more then a little distasteful, and since then I felt like she's been pretty two dimensional with how she continually feels the need to repeat Jem'Hadar/Klingon taglines.

Starfleet is a military organization, so I'm not sure why a drill sergeant would be distasteful?

Anyway, she was the absolute highlight of those first two episodes and I'm one who was very leery of her in the run-up to the debut. Also, she can only deliver the lines she is handed and she did a bang up job doing it.
 
Can't find it now, but in an interview I saw on YT today, Yashere and Notaro talked about Thok and Reno being a couple in SFA. Initially I though they were tongue in cheek, but no - it's true, and we get to see them at home in domestic bliss.....

I largely don't care about their home lives. With only ten episodes I wish they'd focus on working on plots that are interesting, this stuff ends up feeling like a crutch.

Felt the same way about Miles and Keiko, I just didn't care. Not what I generally watch Star Trek for.
 
I largely don't care about their home lives. With only ten episodes I wish they'd focus on working on plots that are interesting, this stuff ends up feeling like a crutch.

Felt the same way about Miles and Keiko, I just didn't care. Not what I generally watch Star Trek for.
This. Romance is the most boring element of the human adventure in media, Star Trek especially.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top