• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Spoilers Star Trek: Prodigy 1x05 - "Terror Firma"

Rate the episode...

  • 10 - Excellent!

    Votes: 12 15.2%
  • 9

    Votes: 20 25.3%
  • 8

    Votes: 29 36.7%
  • 7

    Votes: 12 15.2%
  • 6

    Votes: 2 2.5%
  • 5

    Votes: 3 3.8%
  • 4

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • 3

    Votes: 1 1.3%
  • 2

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • 1 - Terrible.

    Votes: 0 0.0%

  • Total voters
    79
I thought this was a great episode. Probably the best one of the entire season thus far. It's actually a good place to take a break, ending not on a cliffhanger, but telling a complete character and plot arc for the show to date.

This episode was basically from the POV of Gwyn, and it worked in spades. Essentially there was this tension within Gwyn's character between loyalty to her father and her sense of right and wrong/affection for the other characters. She started the episode as a betrayer of the remainder of the kids, had a complete and total breakdown of her idolization of her dad, and made a reverse heel turn into a full comrade-in-arms with the escapees. Dal gets a bit of a character arc as well, but it's secondary to Gwyn's lead here - but important that he goes over the course of the episode from the character who trusts her least to the character willing to risk everything to save her life. Simultaneous to the completion of these character arcs, the kids discover the true nature of the ship, which is a nice metaphor for "leveling up" as a crew.

The episode gets dinged in my book for one reason alone - the idea of a ship powered by a "protostar" is dumb, even in the history of Treknobabble. Protostars are not small, they are actually much larger than regular stars due to being lower density. I simply cannot completely look past this, even though I enjoyed the episode considerably.

But that's only because you missed the mission where Captain Worf of the Enterprise E discovered the first ever small protostar while exploring a unknown part of space in the Beta Quadrant. His chief Engineer and Head Science Officer was lucky to find out they could be used to power starships when they found a broken down experimental Borg ship nearby that tried to replicate a protostar in their ship and use it. While the Borg had failed they did come close and thankfully Starfleet was able to finish what they had started.
 
I gave it a 10. It was a nice way to wrap up this part of the season, especially, with the end where the crew shot of into the unknown.

I was happy to see Gwyn move away from her father's thought processes, and be her own person. helping the crew.

The ship's means of propulsion was such a cool moment that I smiled until it hurt.
 
I suppose the labor colony had at least one Klingon at some point? That or Tellarites in their pre-warp history had encounters with Klingons and that information got disseminated among the Tellarite people?
There were Klingon words in E1

Was the energy source of Emperor Georgiou's flagship in the 23rd century Terran Empire a protostar?
That's right. It just looked like a tiny star. Thanks!
It was a star first, then changed
 
But that's only because you missed the mission where Captain Worf of the Enterprise E discovered the first ever small protostar while exploring a unknown part of space in the Beta Quadrant. His chief Engineer and Head Science Officer was lucky to find out they could be used to power starships when they found a broken down experimental Borg ship nearby that tried to replicate a protostar in their ship and use it. While the Borg had failed they did come close and thankfully Starfleet was able to finish what they had started.

They found a mini-universe (a protouniverse, even!) on DS9. Who's to say that very, very, very smaller stars haven't been formed somewhere crazy. Heck, maybe they just threw a protostar into a subspace compression anomaly (see One Little Ship) that they could use later.

Cue physics lesson here:
 
Looking forward to the second half of the season.

Uhm, actually, it seems there are 20 episodes in Season 1 (not 10).
So, we're technically only 1 quarter of the way through right now.

I don't know what the airing of Prodigy will be like, but its possible they will give us the next 5 episodes over 5 weeks just like now, and then have another 1 month long hiatus before we get the next 5 episodes, and another final month long hiatus until we get the final 5 episodes.

If it happens like that, it means that 20 episodes per season would air across 8 months in total (5 weeks of air time, followed by 1 month of waiting - and 4 months 'break' between seasons).
 
They found a mini-universe (a protouniverse, even!) on DS9. Who's to say that very, very, very smaller stars haven't been formed somewhere crazy. Heck, maybe they just threw a protostar into a subspace compression anomaly (see One Little Ship) that they could use later.

Cue physics lesson here:

"One Little Ship" was kind of a joke.
 
Still part of canon... and useful.
But not something you can replicate easily since it's a one-off anomalous event. caused by out-side forces.

Same with Riker's Transporter Clone.

They don't understand the entire circumstances that caused it to happen.

They just resolved the issues at hand.

In the Shrunk Run-About case, they figured a way to undo the shrinkage.

In Riker's case, they kept the clone.
 
9. Would have been a 10 if it wasn't for the damn warp tunnel.. Again.. I dispise that effect.. Ever since ST09.. And love the NON use of it in lower decks... I miss warp star streaks.. It's not hyperspace..
 
But not something you can replicate easily since it's a one-off anomalous event. caused by out-side forces.

Same with Riker's Transporter Clone.

They don't understand the entire circumstances that caused it to happen.

They just resolved the issues at hand.

In the Shrunk Run-About case, they figured a way to undo the shrinkage.

In Riker's case, they kept the clone.

Riker's Transporter Clone event happened at least twice (see: Lower Decks), and perhaps more, if you count the similar, but not equal, anomaly from The Enemy Within.

In One Little Ship, Starfleet was directly investigating this anomaly that they found out could "shrink" (subspatially compress?) objects, i.e. starships and people. And they used it without a hitch. And it was still there when the episode ended. In fact, here's a line from Worf in the episode:

The data collected here could provide Starfleet with the key to creating transwarp corridors through space.

Sounds familiar.
 
9. Would have been a 10 if it wasn't for the damn warp tunnel.. Again.. I dispise that effect.. Ever since ST09.. And love the NON use of it in lower decks... I miss warp star streaks.. It's not hyperspace..
I don’t like it either, but it’s not as if Trek ever was consistent with Warp effects.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top