• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Spoilers Star Trek: Picard 2x09 - "Hide and Seek"

Rate the episode...


  • Total voters
    201
Tweet writers and production staff directly on Twitter and # or @ them if they have accounts, sometimes they reply or like posts. I don’t have an account myself but one of my friends tweeted Jeri Ryan (Seven of Nine) once and she liked his post. He screamed and it really did make his day. :bolian:
Exactly.

This is not the place to go "If the writers need a list of complaints here's mine. I hope they read it." This isn't the 60s, 80s, or 90s. You can literally go on websites and find direct contact information. The only reason to share these attitudes is not to change the writers mind but to insist that these errors be recognized as such by the larger community.

News flash-they probably won't be. :bolian:
 
Tweet writers and production staff directly on Twitter and # or @ them if they have accounts, sometimes they reply or like posts. I don’t have an account myself but one of my friends tweeted Jeri Ryan (Seven of Nine) once and she liked his post. He screamed and it really did make his day. :bolian:

I don't do twitter as the posts are limited to 155 letters
 
He'll probably be back in the finale once they return to the 25th Century.


Yes, but only if there's something in the air for the laser to hit, like dust, fog, smoke etc.

It must be really dusty foggy smokey in picards chateau.

Can you have beams which ionize the air and cause self emissions due to electron energy state shifting.
 
Write a book then. You could call it 'The Nitpicker's Guide to Star Trek: Picard' or something like that.
Probably could publish really easily too. Then mail a copy to the writers, with the author's autograph.

How are TreBBS people not working in Hollywood?
 
Write a book then. You could call it 'The Nitpicker's Guide to Star Trek: Picard' or something like that.

I read books. I don't write books.

It occurs to me someone could collect my writings and after judicious editing could ghost write a book for me and I would allow them a 25% commission. Publish on Amazon kindle as an ebook?
 
You wou
Exactly.

This is not the place to go "If the writers need a list of complaints here's mine. I hope they read it." This isn't the 60s, 80s, or 90s. You can literally go on websites and find direct contact information. The only reason to share these attitudes is not to change the writers mind but to insist that these errors be recognized as such by the larger community.

News flash-they probably won't be. :bolian:
You would need to engage with them as writers are very ego sensitive and cannot countenance any criticism of their 'plots'. Remember how Ellison caused a huge storm when his script was polished?
 
I read books. I don't write books.

It occurs to me someone could collect my writings and after judicious editing could ghost write a book for me and I would allow them a 25% commission. Publish on Amazon kindle as an ebook?

You could always self publish on Amazon Kindle. You might sell a half a dozen copies.
 
I need to summarize the issues which the writers need to account for and damages the brand.
The brand has literally never been in a better health, thank you.
My thoughts while watching the episode: What's the value of hiding the key inside the Elnor hologram vs. anywhere else? He's a program running in the ship's computer.
no, he’s running on the mobile emitter. If he was in the computer the queen would have control of him.

How would defeating him in hand-to-hand combat reveal the code?
Good question. But at least it would stop him to keep killing drones.
Why couldn't they use Not Laris' transporter to beam into the ship? Instead they're engaging in guerilla warefare with drones.
the queen controlled the ship, perhaps she turned on a transporter inibitor.

Why would the Borg queen fly away and wait for the Confederation to exist? She could just start assimilating Earth now, and then the rest of the alpha quadrant will fall.
She wants to take control of the 21st century borg and turn them into “good” borg.
Why doesn't Picard tell Soong about the future he comes from? Try to talk his way out of it...or make Soong realize what a terrible future comes from his legacy?
he tried, soong wasn’t interested. Did you even watch the show?!

Do modern firearms have laser sights that appear as beams in the air?
some do. And these are likely modified anyway.

I guess these borg soldiers can't assimilate others?
I guess they can’t.

Why didn't Picard think of the tunnels before sending Raffi & Seven to fight the Borg?
He is probably asking himself the same question. Why would a 100 year old guy forget something and then remember it later?
Interesting that Starfleet would reject Seven after everything she did to help Voyager get home (but still allow Icheb).
this has been addressed plenty of times above.

Tricorders can extract bullets?
I guess they can if they are also medical devices. It really isn’t beyond what established Trek technology can do.

Yvette doesn't have a French accent. Jean-Luc doesn't have a French accent. Why does he call her "mamman" instead of "mum" or "mommy"?
picard is a sucker for everything french.

Picard and Not Laris find the well, but there's no hole in the board from when his foot went through as a young man. I guess someone repaired it?
that hole is still a few centuries in the future. Picard’s past is the chateau’s future. I thought you had more attention to detail than this!

Why is holo-Elnor wearing a mobile emitter?
because otherwise the queen would control him.

How do they even have one? Voyager's Dr. got his from the 29th century.
jt’s 30 years later in a different timeline.

Why would any blows landed by the queen on Holo-Elnor hurt him?
they shouldn’t unless they hit the emitter.

Seven knows that Jurarti is "in there" and "can fight", but when the mercenaries are beamed into the field, Seven declares that they aren't people anymore, they're Borg and starts shooting them.
Humans can be inconsistent, especially when emotions are involved.
Why does Not Laris' computer speak in English instead of Romulan?
it probably has an universal translator built in.

Nobody got hurt by the exploding weapon?
Possibly. Maybe soong did, though.
What about all the mercenaries that Queen Jurarti borgified and that they killed? Any butterfly effects there?
as I mentioned, this timeline is pretty messed up by now, I guess they will address it next week.

So Jurarti is the new queen, and she's going to build a better Borg, and she's going to the be Borg queen we see in episode one of season two
maybe.

So the writers become aware and do hard work and polish.
you might want to polish your list before sending it to them: plenty of your points are hardly worth “fixing”.
 
Let's not forget that until FC the Borg in the TNG Era didn't have nanoprobe tubules with which to inject and assimilate victims. A drone had to render Picard unconscious and transport him back to the Borg cube in order to assimilate him and transform him into Locutus. Not all Borg drones throughout canon can assimilate on the spot.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top