• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Star Trek Enterprise

I think Enterprise suffered because we were on ST overdose at the time we just came off the

TNG
DS9
VOY

juggernaut we had so much trek on it was diluted in our minds and it having followed the others it was so easy to pick at and because it wasn't like the others and was a new take on Trek we were less willing to give it a chance at the time.

When i look back at ENT now i like the show and enjoy watching it. I feel that if you released ENT today it would do better than it did back in the 2000's. Given some space from it's predecessors it would have more room to grow.

Now Im guilty of dropping out on ENT on it's original run yeah i had some stuff going on in my life but overall I just drifted away into other interests during season 4 so I did my small part towards it's ultimate demise.
 
Oh wait i want to add to that ent also was on upn not one of the big networks. remember TNG on it's first run was completely setup to fail it was on saturday and sunday ( where i was) nights it had low productuction values in the beginning but the fans really took to it because they wanted trek by the time best of both worlds part 2 hit it was in prime time with the network pushing it and the popularity and production value skyrocketed.

now if you compare the first 2 seasons of TNG to the first 2 season's of ENT which was the better show? I really think what killed ENT was we had so much that was still fresh from the preceding shows and be cause we had so much we were finicky about it and nit-picked the little things we didn't like. release that show this fall with a 11 year trek gap and it would go the full 7 season run with good ratings.
 
When it was on the air, I stuck up for Enterprise from the first episode to the last (except that last episode was a really raw deal). I was really disgusted with the hate some "fans" heaped on it and I pretty much liked it because it ticked off the captain kirk crowd. I watched it more regularly than I did any other Trek show.
I've only rewatched a few episodes since it's been available streaming on Netflix. I've actually found Voyager to be better than I remembered so far.
Enterprise is at least a more modern feeling show than TNG and TOS. I knew the show would get more love from intelligent fans a few years down the line.
-------
Bottom line: The idea of doing a show without any prime directive, contentious Vulcans, and a xenophobic earth population was a very cool idea.
 
Last edited:
I wasn't able to catch it when it first aired. but when I caught the pilot online....it bored me...just wasn't interested.

but after a couple years I gave it a shot again with windows media player...and ended up really liking the show.

one of my favorites...I can understand a lot of gripes about continuity..but it's not as bad as those that hate make it out to be...and if they didn't do some things "new" the show would have been even worse.

It is/was a good show if it's given a chance...approach it with the closed-minded "grrrr continuity grrr" then yah you're going to hate it..but that's true about anything.

that's what's funny about Trek being "dead" and the cause of the NuTrek coming to be...

the fans are what killed it. Yah some episodes/stories weren't very good but that's the case for ALL Trek series that have EVER aired.

but those fans point the finger elsewhere...of course.
 
I still watch it on DVD. An episode a week if I can find the time. Just today... it was "Minefield" and "Dead Stop" back to back. I love the fact more often than not, there was continuity between the stories. Here the serious damage inflicted on the ship by a Romulan mine, and Reed's injury are still part of the plot next time.

Quite hard to describe why I rate ENT highly. I latched onto it the first time I saw on Sky1 back in 2002 and loved everything about the show. I remember getting satellite TV just to see the new Star Trek earlier than terrestrial channels. There are only a handful of episodes I actively dislike.

A lot would be done different for Star Trek on TV now. Each season would be half as long, allowing pure continuous plot and less episodic filler which resets at the end. Producers would take nothing for granted, have a plan, a story arc and a goal each season. A series finale already half figured out, tallying up all the numerous questions we need answers to, should it get cancelled early... which it probably would be.

So yeah, I'm grateful for four years we got and especially for that last year. I wish they'd hurry up and get it out on Blu ray. Heck, I'd like them to show it where I live in true High Def and at a reasonable hour. That way it would really pick up a few new unsuspecting fans - already watching the preceeding show or tuned in early, waiting for the next one to start. Everything these days is geared to downloading and you have to be a fan of Star Trek to begin with really - to go looking for it. That's a solitary experience too, with no active need to all sit down and watch it together at a set time. Hard to remember that downloading back in 2004/05 was Limewire and completely illegal - but those uncounted numbers and TIVO weren't even measured.

If I were a TV scheduler, it would repeated in a channel line-up closer to prime time. Just before CSI, NCIS or whatever. Maybe try out a completely different theme tune... Maybe a different score... I don't know. Just as an experiment to see how many people would really tune in for Star Trek week after week. How long it would take to fail. I do wonder how much those fan gripes really did affect the show. Not simply nobodys like you and me, but high profile folks who mention it like Simon Pegg - who apparently could never get past the opening titles, before switching off.

"Faith of the Heart" never bothered me that much. I found it very inspiring alongside all those human achievements in exploration. Although I did dislike the way it was tweeked from Season 3 onwards. It somehow became overpowering chipper and grating in a year that was dark, gritty and bleak. Earth has just been destroyed > cut to the song. T'Pol has become a screaming psychotic > cut to the song. Two Reptillians wolf down white mice > cut to the song. I'd have liked Producers to have kept the audience guessing and change the title sequence every year. It seemed to have worked for "In A Mirror, Darkly" and thinking back to the 90's, Babylon 5 didn't have a uniform set of titles. It changed and evolved to meet the tone of the show.
 
Last edited:
I'm watching through it on Netflix streaming right now. The last episode I watched was "Detained." Aside from a few clunkers (I'm looking at you, "Unexpected"!), Season One is pretty solid, but not spectacular. The show's biggest problem in these first two seasons was that it was never very ambitious, they tended to stick with the same old TNG/VOY formula they'd been using for years when TV had matured into something different by then.
 
The episodes in season 1 and 2 seemed like what we'd been seeing for the past 14 years in TNG, DS9, and VOY. Plus, it seemed much more like a prequel to the TNG universe than the TOS universe. So, really, what reason was there for a non-fan to watch it?

Even though I wasn't crazy about the "Temporal Cold War" I would've like more episodes about it since it was at least something different and it seemed to bring out the best in the writers. I kinda liked the Suliban too. I really didn't like such a direct metaphor for 9/11 in season 3.

Season 4 was much more like what ENT should've been all along. Still, it would've been better for Trek on TV to have taken a hiatus and come back with new producers and done in more modern, arc-like manner.
 
After watching the Original Series and then switching over to the 24th Century, I found the TNG episodes to not be well thought-out. They just ended with a lot of questions. Anyway, I enjoyed DS9, but I didn't want all my Trek that dark. I was in the middle of watching Star Trek: Nemesis and started saying "What happened to the explorers?" It's in that thirst that I started watching Enterprise for the first time since it aired. I'm only about halfway through the first season but so far I have been enjoying myself.

What I don't like about the show is the overtly-sexual material. Watching T'Pol get rubbed down in Broken Bow and Archer falling into her breasts in Shadows of P'Jem. Some of the characters are overly non-Star Trek archetypes. They are almost charactures of themselves. Why to explore do the characters have to act like they do in the 21st Century? Starfleet should still have rules and regulations. Instead, they are still cowboys.

But there are some enjoyable episodes. I really have enjoyed Fight or Flight because of the journey of Hoshi. Archer's speech before he turns the ship around is great. I think it sets off a determination that the crew needs. Dear Doctor really drove home how easy it is to rely on rules to not have to make moral or difficult decisions. I don't agree with Archer's decision in this one.

Archer is a much better character than I remember him. They've done a lot of family shows in Berman's heading of Trek and it grates on my nerves. He is warm just because of the nature of who he is. I think there's some great acting going on by Backula.

Anyway, I am giving it a better chance than I ever gave it in its first run.
 
I was just plain burned out on Trek after TNG-DS9-VOY and the last two TNG movies. I might've watched two or three episodes of ENT while it was airing, never really got into it.

Now I've seen the whole series and it's my favorite Trek series, especially the last two seasons. I really think in Season 3 and 4 it was the best-written sci-fi show on TV, and contained some of the best episodes of any Trek show ever.

Also the Mirror Universe two-parter was the greatest piece of fan service I have ever seen. Mirror Universe! The Tholian Web! Gorn! Midriffs! Soval with a goatee! All is forgiven, Rick!

The finale, however, has gotta be up (down) there with Spock's Brain for Absolute Worst Episode Ever Filmed. Wish the Riker concept had been used in the 2nd season as a stand-alone episode -- might've worked really well there.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top