• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Spoilers Star Trek: Discovery 3x13 - "That Hope Is You, Part 2"

Rate the episode...


  • Total voters
    265
I hope Starfleet is still pursuing alternative propulsion systems. Even the new gold mine of dilithium will exhaust one day.
 
I'm just glad we are finally gonna be done with the Chain goons in their gimp outfits. Sad to see Osyrra go, I thought they had some real potential with her in the previous episode, guess they didn't dare add a strong female character to counter Burnham with.

I think she died too fast. It's amazing how she was able to fool that guy she helped, into thinking she was even a normal person (for all his life!), given how quick she was to turn on people and torturing them, but it's obvious that her character was completely unredeemable.
 
There's a reason why Fed presidents never got much screentime in over 50 years of Trek--they're inherently boring characters.

I would not say that they are inherently boring characters. Trek has not really tried to make them interesting. They don't have to be boring with good writing. The fact is that we've gotten good "Federation politics" episodes in Trek. DS9's "Homefront" and "Paradise Lost" is a good example that is considered one of the best. TNG's "Unification" and "The Defector" are also good examples of episodes that deal with Federation geopolitics. The novels have managed to make Federation President's interesting. I am thinking of Pres. Bacco for example from "Articles of the Federation". So it is doable to have Trek that deals with geopolitics and features the Federation President in an interesting way. It's just all comes down to the writing and the characterization.
 
It just occurred to me that Kovich's character could have been played by Scott Bakula or literally any past Trek actor and that character's appearance handwaved as a leftover from the chaos of the Temporal Wars.

Burnham: President Archer? How are you here? How are you still alive?
Archer: I got here in the chaos of the Temporal Wars, been here ever since due to the time travel ban.

They could bring in Shatner that way as Kirk with the same explanation, with the added bonus that the Discovery crew wouldn't know who he is! :guffaw: But I don't think Shatner would waste his time on a gimmick cameo.
 
It just occurred to me that Kovich's character could have been played by Scott Bakula or literally any past Trek actor and that character's appearance handwaved as a leftover from the chaos of the Temporal Wars.

Burnham: President Archer? How are you here? How are you still alive?
Archer: I got here in the chaos of the Temporal Wars, been here ever since due to the time travel ban.

They could bring in Shatner that way as Kirk with the same explanation, with the added bonus that the Discovery crew wouldn't know who he is! :guffaw: But I don't think Shatner would waste his time on a gimmick cameo.


Unless it's a commercial...
 
I'm just glad we are finally gonna be done with the Chain goons in their gimp outfits. Sad to see Osyrra go, I thought they had some real potential with her in the previous episode, guess they didn't dare add a strong female character to counter Burnham with.

There was a real Power Rangers vibe to the Chain at times, between the costumes, the vocal effect and the way the goons stood with their feet a mile apart. (Osyraa's plasticky prosthetics didn't help.)
 
I have one question: Where did Burnham beam the invading force after she took over the ship's functions?

Outer space? A la mirror universe?
 
She says to the computer to beam off all the regulators but that science guy was still on the ship. How did the computer know that he turned good and could stay onboard
 
She says to the computer to beam off all the regulators but that science guy was still on the ship. How did the computer know that he turned good and could stay onboard
He wasn't officially a regulator. It seems Discovery's computer takes a literal "exact words" approach to orders.
 
She says to the computer to beam off all the regulators but that science guy was still on the ship. How did the computer know that he turned good and could stay onboard
I think the Regulators had a very specific kind of badge that helped identify them. Science Guy must not have had one.
PS- So, who WERE the Regulators anyway? Borg? Breen? New guys?
 
It seemed pretty clear to me she beamed the Regulators back onto Osyraa's ship. Which of course means she later blew them up, but she didn't know that at the time.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top