• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Spoilers Star Trek: Discovery 3x04 - "Forget Me Not"

Rate the episode...


  • Total voters
    229
No I meant that the closest we got to Indian or Arabic were Bashir who is a British Indian character played by an Arabic actor and Clem Fandango/Vok who is a British/Asian/secret klingon played by a British Asian actor.

Also Reed was an English character as well as actor
Crusher was from fantasy Scotland planet and La Sirenas holograms covered all the bases
The real Tyler was an American.
Crusher was born on Luna.
 
My 13 year old questioning son is all over the Adira/Grey storyline. That's what he's most engaged in and excited about (he also picked up on the Calypso hints and loves the idea of a sentient ship - for him it's something new since he's not familiar with Andromeda or Farscape yet).

I think that the choice to make Adira a teen and not an older more accomplished person pre-joining was actually a good one. Representation matters, and I do think it's helpful to show characters in varying stages of their inner development, working through their own personal issues. He also quite likes Wesley in TNG, even though I find the character annoying to watch most of the time.

I found Adira's earnestness and uncertainty endearing and nicely nuanced. So far she hasn't been presented as some kind of Wunderkind who instantly knows better than other crew members. In fact, I like her wondering what she contributes vs the other host's memories and skills. Note: I am using 'she' for now, since that is how the character is portrayed on the show and will adjust accordingly.
 
Some preliminary thoughts before I delve into the comments:
  • Great acting, top to bottom.
  • I'm still not happy with making Adira a teenager, but it seems like that is a characteristic that will wear off, perhaps. The scenes early in the episode seem to work hard to infantillze Adira, when it seemed like the actor would have been better playing as an adult.
  • Del Barrio was generally quite good throughout the episode, especially during the "Trill" sequence (although Ian Alexander stole his scenes).
  • An origin story for Calypso? I guess I should have expected it at some point, but it was nice
  • I think Detmer's trauma should have been approached with more subtlety.
  • The music was LOUD!
  • Culber's failed haiku was a gas! I am so going to remember that line.
  • SMG was pretty good in the support role. It was nice to see more subtle physical acting from her.
  • No Dax? Come in, it was gimme for fan service!
  • When does Linus finally get it on with the Empress?

I am convinced that it is a blooper that they decided to keep.
 
And yet us Asians rarely ever get Main Billing or are the Star of our own TV shows in the US.

Heck, Blacks, Latinos, LGBTQAI+ all get front billing over us Asian Americans.

Heck, we haven't even had a Asian American Captain as the head of a Trek TV show.

Michelle Yeoh was the closest we got, but they turned her into the Terran Empreror instead.

And don't forget Hollywood and the lack German Representation or many parts of Europe to be portrayed in StarFleet as lead characters.

We've had more Americans & Canadians on the show, but no Australians or New Zealanders.

Heck, what about Arabic Characters? Indian Characters, Mongolians?

There are entire Ethnicities on Earth that aren't represented what so ever in Trek or on TV.
You do realize that they are giving Michelle Yeoh her own Star Trek series to headline right? It's one I'm certainly looking forward to.
 
That's literally 1 show out of how many shows are being currently produced in Hollywood?
Nora From Queens stars Awkwafina (Nora Lum)
Fresh of the Boat just finished a six year run.
Mindy Kaling's The Mindy Project ran for six seasons on FOX and HULU.
One Kaling's current projects is Four Weddings and a Funeral starring Nikesh Patel.
The CW is reviving Kung Fu with Olivia Liang as the lead
Agents of SHIELD starred Ming Na-Wen and Chloe Bennett (Born Chloe Wang)
 
Nora From Queens stars Awkwafina (Nora Lum)
Fresh of the Boat just finished a six year run.
Mindy Kaling's The Mindy Project ran for six seasons on FOX and HULU.
One Kaling's current projects is Four Weddings and a Funeral starring Nikesh Patel.
The CW is reviving Kung Fu with Olivia Liang as the lead
Agents of SHIELD starred Ming Na-Wen and Chloe Bennett (Born Chloe Wang)
That's literally 5 different people or groups of people.

Hollywood alone produces 532 Scripted TV shows in 2019
https://www.statista.com/statistics/444870/scripted-primetime-tv-series-number-usa/

5/532 ~= 0.94% of Hollywood TV has Asians in some form of Lead Capacity.

https://www.census.gov/quickfacts/fact/table/US/PST045219
Yet approximately 5.9% of the US is Asian.

This isn't even counting movies or other media.
 
That's literally 5 different people or groups of people.

Hollywood alone produces 532 Scripted TV shows in 2019
https://www.statista.com/statistics/444870/scripted-primetime-tv-series-number-usa/

5/532 ~= 0.94% of Hollywood TV has Asians in some form of Lead Capacity.

https://www.census.gov/quickfacts/fact/table/US/PST045219
Yet approximately 5.9% of the US is Asian.

This isn't even counting movies or other media.
I'm sure there are more that I'm unaware of.
Are Asians under represented? Yes. But the census will never be what Hollywood goes to when figuring out what shows to produce.
 
And yet us Asians rarely ever get Main Billing or are the Star of our own TV shows in the US.

Michelle Yeoh is a Series Regular on DSC (despite not appearing in every episode) and receives 'top dollar' billing whenever she appears (actors who have their names listed after an 'and', 'with' or 'Special Guest' tag are considered to be among the most important members of a television cast).

She's also getting a spinoff as previously noted.
 
I'm sure there are more that I'm unaware of.
  • Melissa O'Neil plays one of the lead characters in ABC's The Rookie. O'Neil has a Chinese (Hong Kong) Mother and a Irish father. Her TV character is Chinese-American with a Chinese last name (Lucy Chen).
  • David Lim plays Chinese-American cop Victor Tan as one of the main ensemble roles in CBS's S.W.A.T.
  • Kenneth Choi is in another ensemble main cast in FOX's 911
  • Yet another show with a main cast of ensemble actors is Chicago Med with Brian Tee, who is a Korean-Japanese-American born on Okinawa.
  • Tim Kang is of Korean descent, but he plays Gordon Katsumoto on Magnum P.I., which sounds like a Japanese name.
  • The Blacklist had a new agent in the main cast last season named Alina Park played by Laura Sohn.
  • Elementary ended two seasons ago, but it starred Lucy Lui.
Granted, none of those (except Lucy Lui, whose show is not longer on) are top billing, but all are in the main cast.
 
Last edited:
I kinda lost the thread here but naming shows featuring people of Asian descent, I recommend Kim's Convenience. It's a Canadian sitcom about a first/second gen Korean immigrant family. I don't watch many sitcoms but it's really endearing. Also, "Appa" was in The Mandalorian a couple weeks ago.
 
My only issue with Grey is that it looks like he refused to wear whatever they made for him and he just acted in the jeans and jacket he walked in wearing:lol:

The piercings are very 2020 too, couldn't they have gone with something a bit more alien, like the stuff the Romulans in Picard had?
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top