Three stars, I really like Matt Smith and Arthur Darvill is very good but I never liked Amy and I'm sick of River Song, her story really doesn't work, she was great in series four but everytime she reappeared she became more annoying.
I like some of the episodes, I don't like others, that hasn't changed since the RTD era, what I really don't enjoy in the Moffat era are the season long story arcs, the arc in season 5 was a little bit boring but the Doctor's death arc in season six was almost offensively stupid and pointless.
The show has potential but so far Moffat really hasn't delivered anything special, I still rewatch episodes from the RTD era, I didn't even bother getting the Moffat era on DVD, it's enjoyable enough to watch when it airs but that's it. Something's missing, even from the episodes I like, I'm not exactly sure what it is but Moffats episodes had it, even the not so great ones.