Rate the episodes across all Trek series, as Discovery progresses

[BlueStuff]

An ongoing thread to compare our ratings/thoughts on each episode in Discovery when compared to the other Trek series at the same point in time. Leave your rating, plus a brief comment if you wish.

Since this is the first post in the thread, I'll include episodes 1x01-1x04. Each week after a new Discovery episode, I'll make a new post including the next relevant episodes.

1x01

TOS: The Man Trap
TNG: Encounter at Farpoint I
DS9: Emissary I
VOY: Caretaker I
ENT: Broken Bow I
DIS: The Vulcan Hello

1x02

TOS: Charlie X
TNG: Encounter at Farpoint II
DS9: Emissary II
VOY: Caretaker II
ENT: Broken Bow II
DIS: Battle at the Binary Stars

1x03

TOS: Where No Man Has Gone Before
TNG: The Naked Now
DS9: Past Prologue
VOY: Parallax
ENT: Fight or Flight
DIS: Context Is for Kings

1x04

TOS: The Naked Time
TNG: Code of Honor
DS9: A Man Alone
VOY: Time and Again
ENT: Strange New World
DIS: The Butcher's Knife Cares Not for the Lamb's Cry

 

[BlueStuff]

Mine:

1x01

TOS: The Man Trap - 7
TNG: Encounter at Farpoint I - 7
DS9: Emissary I - 9
VOY: Caretaker I - 7
ENT: Broken Bow I - 7
DIS: The Vulcan Hello - 7

1x02

TOS: Charlie X - 6
TNG: Encounter at Farpoint II - 6
DS9: Emissary II - 8
VOY: Caretaker II - 8
ENT: Broken Bow II - 7
DIS: Battle at the Binary Stars - 7

1x03

TOS: Where No Man Has Gone Before - 8
TNG: The Naked Now - 4
DS9: Past Prologue - 6
VOY: Parallax - 5
ENT: Fight or Flight - 6
DIS: Context Is for Kings - 6

1x04

TOS: The Naked Time - 8
TNG: Code of Honor - 3
DS9: A Man Alone - 6
VOY: Time and Again - 6
ENT: Strange New World - 4
DIS: The Butcher's Knife Cares Not for the Lamb's Cry - 6

 

[CorporalClegg]

Could be fun.


1x01
TOS: The Man Trap B+
TNG: Encounter at Farpoint C+
DS9: Emissary A-
VOY: Caretaker B-
ENT: Broken Bow B+
DIS: The Vulcan Hello C
ORV: Old Wounds B

1x02
TOS: Charlie X B-
DIS: Battle at the Binary Stars C+
ORV: Command Performance B

1x03
TOS: Where No Man Has Gone Before A-
TNG: The Naked Now C
DS9: Past Prologue C+
VOY: Parallax B-
ENT: Fight or Flight C-
DIS: Context Is for Kings C+
ORV: About a Girl B

1x04
TOS: The Naked Time A-
TNG: Code of Honor F
DS9: A Man Alone C
VOY: Time and Again C
ENT: Strange New World B-
DIS: The Butcher's Knife Cares Not for the Lamb's Cry C+
ORV: If the Stars Should Appear A-

EDIT: I added an extra kink!

 

[BlueStuff]

Sorry, have corrected an error on my part. Voyager 1x04 was "Time and Again", not "Phage".

 

[CorporalClegg]

Knew that didn't seem right.

 

[BlueStuff]

Haven't seen 1x05 yet but I thought I'd bump the thread anyway. Will update after I've watched it.

1x05
TOS: The Enemy Within - 7
TNG: The Last Outpost - 2
DS9: Babel - 5
VOY: Phage - 7
ENT: Unexpected - 6
DIS: Choose Your Pain - 8

 

[BlueStuff]

Looks like this thread isn't gonna take off, but I'll keep bumping it weekly until it just gets too sad.

1X06
TOS: Mudd's Women - 3
TNG: Where No One Has Gone Before - 8
DS9: Captive Pursuit - 8
VOY: The Cloud - 6
ENT: Terra Nova - 4
DIS: Lethe -