• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

New Picard SDCC Trailer

Discovery and Picard (and Lower Decks) are all part of the prime universe. This isn’t a question.

Yes they are in the Prime Universe, but the Prime Universe is not the original continuity

Think about it, ST: 2009 was made under the Alternative Licence, yes?
But we saw the flashback scenes of Spock Prime in that movie didn't we?

So by definition the so called 'Prime Universe' is an aspect of the alternative licence or they wouldn't have been able to show those scenes

They had no rights to the original continuity. It's a clever slight of hand.

DISCO & Picard take place in the same Prime Universe as the Spock Prime flashback scenes in ST: 2009

Both the Prime Universe and the Kelvin Timeline are features of the alternative licence. Prime is simply closer to the original continuity than the Kelvin timeline

Does it matter? That's up to you
 
I thought the "Blue Lighting" was evidence that Romulan or Federation technology was used on that captured Borg Cube.

Ergo the Lighting change.
To me, it looks like huge chunks of that cube are missing, with only some internal framework visible behind those blue-lit parts. I think they are probably force fields installed by the Romulan-Fed crew to keep a breathable atmosphere inside.
 
In the ST:TNG episode "Parallels", it proved that Parallel Universe of very subtle differences do exist.

So what's to say that every spin-off, incarnation, extended universe content isn't "Canon" to some degree.

Even fan stuff can be "Canon" because it's part of the greater "Star Trek" Multiverse where any and all things that could've happened in a specific circumstances due to possible choices, will have happened.

Ergo everything co-exists.
 
Alison Pill can't help it being likable. She'll be a great science officer.
They should avoid writing her too mopey. She easily cries anyway.
 
They had no rights to the original continuity. It's a clever slight of hand.

DISCO & Picard take place in the same Prime Universe as the Spock Prime flashback scenes in ST: 2009

Both the Prime Universe and the Kelvin Timeline are features of the alternative licence. Prime is simply closer to the original continuity than the Kelvin timeline

Does it matter? That's up to you

I see this bandied about this board all the time. Is there any kind of documentation for this? It seems like some posters have accepted this as conventional wisdom but I can’t find anything about it.

All signs point to the prime universe and original continuity being the same. A lot of what you’re saying here is a distinction without a difference.
 
To me, it looks like huge chunks of that cube are missing, with only some internal framework visible behind those blue-lit parts. I think they are probably force fields installed by the Romulan-Fed crew to keep a breathable atmosphere inside.
Yeah, a huge chunk was missing, I think they were using the field for repairing the cube or transforming sections of the cube into a more Non-Borg / Normal BiPedaloid friendly environment.
 
I see this bandied about this board all the time. Is there any kind of documentation for this? It seems like some posters have accepted this as conventional wisdom but I can’t find anything about it.

All signs point to the prime universe and original continuity being the same. A lot of what you’re saying here is a distinction without a difference.

It comes from some conspiracy theorists on YouTube and is completely inaccurate. The look of something has nothing to do with what timeline it’s in. If it did, TOS and TAS would be in their own separate timeline
 
You know what else I'd love to see? Flashbacks showing Picard trying to help Nero convince the Romulan government that Romulus was in danger of being destroyed (as we saw in the Countdown comic book series that was a prequel to Star Trek 2009). Maybe they could even get Eric Bana to reprise his role as Nero for these flashbacks.

The reason? I heard this show is going to deal with the fallout of Romulus being destroyed.
 
Have to disagree. The stories are arguably enjoyable, but the style is nothing if not dated. It’s a choice, and there’s nothing inherently wrong with it, but it is certainly aping something decades past.

And plus, this isn't The Orville -- which you'll now have to pay to watch, by the way.
 
Is this a prison on a Borg cube?

V8D2rW1.jpg


D_8eLskVUAAfCQJ.jpg:large


Those look like alcoves in the back there and I *think* that is Romulan text to the right of the English.
The Romulans are now part of the federation ??? if all the old space romulan and all the military forces romulan now belong to the federation that would make them the greatest power in the whole galaxy?
 
I actually don't think there will be any additional Nemesis ties...unless the assassination of the senate also plays some small role with the involvement of the Romulans.

You'd assume if anyone survived Romulus, the Senate and other senior leaders may well have been on the first ship out (given Romulan deference to power). However having your planet blown up likely changed the geopolitical reality more than a few Reman rebels trying to seize power ever did. My guess is that we'll see Romulan survivors living on a bunch of Federation worlds in addition to their own surviving colonies. Perhaps there'll be tension between these two groups.
 
I am wondering if living Data is actually only in a dream? Given the line "I dont want the game to end"?

Also interesting sign "…has gone 5843 days without an assimilation…"

I wondered if it was a homage to the poker holodeck game with Hawking, Einstein etc so that scene with data was all from a holodeck
 
DISCO & this Picard show are not in the Kelvin timeline, but they are made under the same alternative licence that the Kelvin series of movies were made under

The so called 'Prime Universe' is not the original Star Trek continuity - it's an universe where things mostly match the events of the original continuity

Whilst this timeline might have the same rough chain of events there have to be differences - a minimum 15% difference I believe - so Seven's implants being different - the Borg cube having blue rather than green light, the DISCO Enterprise being larger than TOS all these things are different for contractual reasons

Discovery & Picard are made for CBS, yes, but they are made by Secret Hideout under the same alternative licence as Bad Robot made the Kelvin movies
None of what you said here is true, at all, in any possible way.

Also the Borg Cube does have green lights on the outside of it. The blue stuff s probably force-fields, installed by the Romulans.
mYHnJJt.png

A7KTKyl.png


Yes they are in the Prime Universe, but the Prime Universe is not the original continuity
Nope, you're wrong.

The Romulans are now part of the federation ??? if all the old space romulan and all the military forces romulan now belong to the federation that would make them the greatest power in the whole galaxy?
There's no evidence of this.

Romulans scavenging Borg tech originated from the ST09 prequel Countdown comic which Kurtzman had a hand in.
 
Last edited:
And there was me thinking this new trailer would put to bed this stuff. The Borg cube having blue lighting, and Seven’s implant looking different proves some sort of “alternate licence”, really?

Does all this really just come from that comment that John Eaves made, and no other reliable source?

V8D2rW1.jpg


Actually, if you look up the sides on the right, on the bottom, and lower left, there's plenty of green lighting on the cube.
 
And there's also the woman telling him, "You have forgotten who you are. We have not," and then later the hippie Vulcan saying, "Be the captain they remember." Maybe it's not just one character, but an entire Enterprise Alumni Association that Picard recruits his crew from.
vulcan? Was not he a Romulan? I thought that he had crest
To view this content we will need your consent to set third party cookies.
For more detailed information, see our cookies page.
min 1:16
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top