• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

New Phaser and Rifle Revealed

Well, they could ease their minds and relieve their consternation by just attributing it to be:
"The TNG art directors and make up people felt like making Romulans look different because they could."

That is the problem when doing a continuing story. People expect things to visually remain relatively static unless there's a story reason for the change.

True. Unless Romulans separated from Vulcans hundreds of thousands of years ago to allow time to evolve forehead ridges, then they should look like Vulcans. However, I was under the impression (maybe mistakenly?) that the separation was more recent than that.

I think it was two-thousand years.
 
...
I think it was two-thousand years.

That's the way I recall it, too. Or ... at least that's how long since Surak's teachings took hold on Vulcan. I've always interpreted this as the event that caused non-Surak Vulcanians to flee the planet and seed other worlds, but is there wiggle room in canon for the Romulans and Mentokans to have split off much earlier? Say tens of thousands of years earlier?
 
That's the way I recall it, too. Or ... at least that's how long since Surak's teachings took hold on Vulcan. I've always interpreted this as the event that caused non-Surak Vulcanians to flee the planet and seed other worlds, but is there wiggle room in canon for the Romulans and Mentokans to have split off much earlier? Say tens of thousands of years earlier?

Enterprise has it as those "who flew under the raptor's wings" (or something similar) left after Vulcan has its nuclear war two thousand years prior.
 
I wish they had just given Vulcans ridges too. Spock could have remained as he is, as he is half human.

I am actually a tad disappointed that with all these changes in Discovery, they did not take the opportunity to make Vulcans look slightly more alien.
 
The most likely explanation is that most of the dissenters that eventually became Romulans were of a ethnic group on Vulcan that had ridges. There were a few smooth foreheads in the mix as well, and we just happened to encounter those in TOS, and Romulans with the ridges hidden under helmets. There were so few ridged heads left on Vulcan that we have never encountered one.
 
The Romulan makeup in ST09 also included a forehead appliance, but way less prominent than the ridges we first saw in TNG.

Kor
 
....Perhaps the less well endowed feel the need to boost their foreheads with tattooing?

Timo Saloniemi
 
The Romulan makeup in ST09 also included a forehead appliance, but way less prominent than the ridges we first saw in TNG.

Kor

I think were make up tests with a more TNG style ridge. I think you can see them on the DVD/Blu-Ray.

But the final version doesn't have the V shape at all, just a bulkier forehead and nose.
 
Last edited:
They didn't? But .... what's this then?!

latest

Well, it looks a lot like a laser... :whistle:
 
I assumed the real life, production reason for the Romulan forehead appliances was to avoid having to shave a guest actor's eyebrows to make way for the upswept follicles. The rubber, instead, merely covered the real eyebrows so the performer would not look "odd" for several weeks or months afterwards waiting for his or her real brows to regrow.

Reflecting upon forehead appliances, I find it a bit ironic that Michael Westmore appears on SyFy's "Face/Off" as a guest advisor, critiquing the contestants' efforts. Arguably unjust, some fans tend to mock him for simply slapping a piece of foam on an actor's brow to make the "alien of the week". I'm sure some of that was mandated by higher-ups for expediency, but most people are only aware of the final results on camera. And that does tend to shape one's perceptions. So I can imagine some of the artists thinking, "Uh, do I really want to heed the advice of this guy?!"
 
A bit of makeup can obscure the real eyebrows so that only the prosthetic eyebrows are visible. No need to shave at all.
Close ups of Nimoy in costume bear this out.

When you have a limited costume budget for guest actors, sometimes all you have available is a piece of foam and two bits of rubber. TNG did a fairly decent job of "aliens of the week makeup" all things considered,

B5 planned out the number of alien guest appearances for each season in advance, so that they'd be able to budget say 20 Minbari extras and 15 Centauri's and amortize the cost over the whole season.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top