• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Multiple mirror episodes this season!

The MU on DS9 just turned into an excuse for the cast to show its acting range. DS9, VOY, and to a lesser extent ENT all did this - have the characters "possessed" or undergoing some sort of mental trauma to showcase that even though they were written very narrowly, they actually had incredible acting ranges man!

Oh, and TNG did this too with Brent Spiner, between giving him the Lore character, Dr. Soong, and all the "weird" episodes like Masks. I don't remember them really doing it for anyone else on the cast however.

I agree. Hopefully, since this is the first season the writers aren't yet bored writing for these characters and will have something to say in the episode.

Interestingly Voyager got better when Seven of Nine was added, because in addition to Jeri Ryan being a great actor, the writers were like "Ooh, a new character! I don't have to not-write for Chakotay anymore!"
 
No disrespect to anyone who wants to do a mirror universe episode, but screw that. Make me interested in THIS universe, in these characters, before showing me a MIRROR universe. What the hell is an alternate <plug in character name> without knowing who and what they are in this universe? Throwing a mirror episode in before establishing the characters better than they are now, say next season or further, seems to me to be just fan wank.
 
Last edited:
One thing I liked about the Enterprise MU is not everyone had the same roles on the ship.

Mayweather and Reed were MACOs for example.

Though I don't like how they changed the MACO logo to a skull.
Was a Shark not badass enough for the MU?
 
So is Mirror Discovery all puppies and rainbows and everyone is proverbial Tom Hanks?


But, Bill, they're both Asian!

No, Mirror Discovery is just as evil as any other mirror-ship, they're just chaffed under the leadership of peacenik Captain Lorca.
 
So is Mirror Discovery all puppies and rainbows and everyone is proverbial Tom Hanks?


But, Bill, they're both Asian!

In the Mirror Universe, Tom Hanks plays Kirk and commands the enterprise. There will be an episode where the new Kirk is reduced in age, forced to find a way back to his adult self, and an episode where Kirk is stranded on a deserted planet with a soccer ball.
 
It was explained in the novel, Mirror Mirror happened the same, Mirror Spock was killed before he could do anything.

Are you referring to Dark Mirror? In that continuity, Spock wasn't killed, he just decided not to reform the Empire.

In the current novelverse, Spock did institute democratic reforms, and that led to the fall of the Empire and its conquering and enslavement by the Klingon/Cardassian Alliance.

The snag is, Spock did that on purpose. He knew exactly what would happen. He planned the fall of the Empire so humans would know what it's like to be enslaved, and thus the Empire would never rise again.
 
^ No, Spock survived there too. The only MU continuity (that I'm aware of) where he dies, is Dark Passions.
 
Last edited:
Why would the Mirror universe have a starship named Discovery?

Why, despite a point of departure starting way back in the 20th century, are there "evil" versions of characters from the 24th century running around? The average man has 100 million sperm per ejaculate, so even the slightest alteration to history (like a woman sleeping on her right versus left side) would lead to another individual being born.

The Mirror universe has absolutely no logic to it, but it was never supposed to - any more than the "Roman planet," "Nazi planet," or "Gangster planet." It's just that DS9 took a one-off goofy (but well-executed) episode and drove it into the ground.

My headcannon is it's really some sort of weird simulation being run by advanced energy beings, but YMMV.
 
Why, despite a point of departure starting way back in the 20th century, are there "evil" versions of characters from the 24th century running around?

Yeah, but the name just doesn't seem to fit something commissioned by an evil empire.
 
Why, despite a point of departure starting way back in the 20th century, are there "evil" versions of characters from the 24th century running around? The average man has 100 million sperm per ejaculate, so even the slightest alteration to history (like a woman sleeping on her right versus left side) would lead to another individual being born.

In an infinite multiverse, the chance that the mirror universe turns out the way it does, is no more or less likely than any other.

Why would the Mirror universe have a starship named Discovery?

Because you have to discover new worlds before conquering them. :evil:
 
Last edited:
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top