• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Let's talk "Spock's Brain"

Please don’t tell me this episode is unintentionally campy. It’s more enjoyable if I imagine the camp is intentional.
 
KIRK: She was on the Enterprise. She must have done it. How did you do it?
KARA: It was the old knowledge.
KIRK: How do you get the old knowledge?
KARA: I put upon my head the Teacher.

 
It's definitely not a great episode, and it does tax the suspension of disbelief, but I've always liked it from childhood onward. Some noteworthy elements for me:
  • I Iove how they milked that wonderful rear-projection viewscreen scene to give us a full portion plus seconds.
  • "The givers of pain and delight" has always amused me. (Go ahead and tell me I'm a neanderthal, it's okay.)
  • The mood evoked when Spock's brain finally starts communicating in voice-over still gives me that sense of child-like wonder. The sound design is great; Spock's fascination with his predicament and his absolute lack of panic, desperation, or apparently even concern are wonderful. Had the crew failed their recovery mission, he might have actually been reasonably content to run that planet.
  • I don't care what anybody says, "Brain and brain! What is Brain!?" always delights my wife and me. It's campy, yet also completely in character for Kara.
That said, there are also unnecessarily bad details that I wish had been left on the cutting room floor. One of the worst for me is Shatner hamming it up with the "off switch" in the last seconds of the episode. It's basically an outtake that was left in the final cut.

Another big problem is, of course, the lack of an explanation for Spock not being instantly dead. It seems like a couple lines of dialog could maybe have helped the credibility gap. Like, what if in addition to backup eyelids, Vulcans also had a backup mini-brain that could handle the most basic functions for a short time? (There was apparently a famous chicken who lived on for some time with a severed head because a small portion of the brain stem was still connected.) Or, what if Spock uniquely had an extra partial brain stem as part of being a human/Vulcan hybrid; a rare quirk of crossed genetics? Or, more outlandishly, some kind of echo of someone he had mindmelded with in the past.

Perhaps a Vulcan auxiliary brain was even a necessary part of the whole katra system, to keep the body alive a little while to allow a possible fal-tor-pan. Of course those ideas had not been invented back in the '60s, but if they had been then maybe the script could have taken a somewhat different approach: Spock could have still possessed his physical brain and had just his spirit or intellect abducted by the Eymorgs to run their systems.

Whatever the explanation, my point is that there could – well, should – have at least been an explanation for the absence of the Curse of Fatal Death, even if it was something McCoy has just now discovered as part of his examination. I'm not sure how any of this would have played, but it does seem like there would have been some possibilities beyond just "it's scifi and it's our last season and, just trust us, bro."

So I don't begrudge anyone who skips this episode, but I will always gladly watch it and find it a vastly more enjoyable installment than, say, The Alternative Factor.
 
That said, there are also unnecessarily bad details that I wish had been left on the cutting room floor. One of the worst for me is Shatner hamming it up with the "off switch" in the last seconds of the episode. It's basically an outtake that was left in the final cut.

I feel like that's exactly what it was. But I don't have the script.
Another big problem is, of course, the lack of an explanation for Spock not being instantly dead. It seems like a couple lines of dialog could maybe have helped the credibility gap. Like, what if in addition to backup eyelids, Vulcans also had a backup mini-brain that could handle the most basic functions for a short time? (There was apparently a famous chicken who lived on for some time with a severed head because a small portion of the brain stem was still connected.) Or, what if Spock uniquely had an extra partial brain stem as part of being a human/Vulcan hybrid; a rare quirk of crossed genetics? Or, more outlandishly, some kind of echo of someone he had mindmelded with in the past.


Whatever the explanation, my point is that there could – well, should – have at least been an explanation for the absence of the Curse of Fatal Death, even if it was something McCoy has just now discovered as part of his examination.

MCCOY: No. That incredible Vulcan physique hung on until the life-support cycle took over.

That's all I ever needed.
 
I think Kirk had a green fetish. Or green women like him.
Number of references over the years to Kirk as a horndog for green women: too many.
Number of green women in TOS: two?
Number of them Kirk interacted with romantically/sexually: zero.

MCCOY: No. That incredible Vulcan physique hung on until the life-support cycle took over.

That's all I ever needed.
Yeah, I guess I kinda forgot about that line. It's a little threadbare, but okay point taken.
 
If they had not taken him to the planet with them when they did, he would have died.
So, you keep him on life support (as indicated by dialogue previously cited) and beam him down at the last minute or something. Don't treat him like a puppet.
 
If they had not taken him to the planet with them when they did, he would have died.
Unless the plot had been a little different.

I think we can infer that fireproof78's argument is not "this was a good story but Spock should have died" so much as "this story needed more work so that it wasn't 'necessary' to parade Spock around like a zombie."

There are things about this episode I quite like, and I don't consider it bottom of the barrel, but I have to admit that even as a child I thought having Scotty and Kirk drive Spock around like a robot, using just a 10-button calculator, was batcrap idiotic. And completely implausible! How, for example, did they know in advance to program one of the red buttons to mean "grab wrist of person before you without breaking it" and then another button to be "move index finger of right hand 2 cm to left and press whatever button is there"? Even 300 years in the future, there's no way a device that looks like that could have controlled Spock in such specific ways, and definitely no time for Kirk to learn how to use it even if such nonsense could exist.

Would have been much better to have put a corresponding wireless headset on Kirk and let Shatner knock himself out making faces of extreme concentration.
 
Last edited:
think we can infer that fireproof78's argument is not "this was a good story but Spock should have died" so much as "this story needed more work so that it wasn't 'necessary' to parade Spock around like a zombie."

There are things about this episode I quite like, and I don't consider it bottom of the barrel, but I have to admit that even as a child I thought having Scotty and Kirk drive Spock around like a robot, using just an 8-button calculator, was batcrap idiotic.
That is my argument. You can rework it were Spock is sabotaging systems from within, giving hints or clues to his location, trying not to tip his hand or outsmarting the safeguards built in.

But the robo Spock is sadly playing poorly because of the random jokes about him being a computer throughout the show's run.
 
But Spock isn't being led around like a puppet against his will. His empty body is being electronically manipulated, yes. But Spock himself is cheerfully inhabiting the "Controller" space, accessing knowledge and interacting with is crewmates. There's not a hint of this causing Spock undue stress or hardship. Even if they changed Nimoy's dialog to have him "giving hints or clues to his location, trying not to tip his hand or outsmarting the safeguards built in," it's the same result.

The crew couldn't directly contact the Enterprise. They needed Spock's body along to restore the brain because time was of the essence and the people who did it were there. By extension, so was all of the proper equipment. So instead of using a remote control, they'd have had the body in a gurney (not good for an action show or moving around on the landscape) or in a wheelchair (same). And yes, they spent most of their time indoors, but they didn't know what they'd find down there.

Sure a gurney could have fixed it, but I can't see them wheeling him around corridors, making him fit into the elevators, trying not to crash into the bed during fights, etc.

And, realistically, you don't take your most popular character and keep him in a bed off screen for a full episode with his name on it when you're struggling to keep your show alive.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top