Yes.What is the difference in a remote controlled Spock as depicted in this episode vs wheeling brainless Spock around on a gurney or in a wheel chair? Would you be opposed to that as well?
Yes.What is the difference in a remote controlled Spock as depicted in this episode vs wheeling brainless Spock around on a gurney or in a wheel chair? Would you be opposed to that as well?
www.livescience.com
That said, there are also unnecessarily bad details that I wish had been left on the cutting room floor. One of the worst for me is Shatner hamming it up with the "off switch" in the last seconds of the episode. It's basically an outtake that was left in the final cut.
Another big problem is, of course, the lack of an explanation for Spock not being instantly dead. It seems like a couple lines of dialog could maybe have helped the credibility gap. Like, what if in addition to backup eyelids, Vulcans also had a backup mini-brain that could handle the most basic functions for a short time? (There was apparently a famous chicken who lived on for some time with a severed head because a small portion of the brain stem was still connected.) Or, what if Spock uniquely had an extra partial brain stem as part of being a human/Vulcan hybrid; a rare quirk of crossed genetics? Or, more outlandishly, some kind of echo of someone he had mindmelded with in the past.
Whatever the explanation, my point is that there could – well, should – have at least been an explanation for the absence of the Curse of Fatal Death, even if it was something McCoy has just now discovered as part of his examination.
Number of references over the years to Kirk as a horndog for green women: too many.I think Kirk had a green fetish. Or green women like him.
Yeah, I guess I kinda forgot about that line. It's a little threadbare, but okay point taken.MCCOY: No. That incredible Vulcan physique hung on until the life-support cycle took over.
That's all I ever needed.
A lie is around the globe while truth is still living up their shoes.Number of references over the years to Kirk as a horndog for green women: too many.
You would prefer they let him die?Yes.
Nowhere did I imply that.You would prefer they let him die?

If they had not taken him to the planet with them when they did, he would have died.Nowhere did I imply that.![]()
So, you keep him on life support (as indicated by dialogue previously cited) and beam him down at the last minute or something. Don't treat him like a puppet.If they had not taken him to the planet with them when they did, he would have died.
Unless the plot had been a little different.If they had not taken him to the planet with them when they did, he would have died.
That is my argument. You can rework it were Spock is sabotaging systems from within, giving hints or clues to his location, trying not to tip his hand or outsmarting the safeguards built in.think we can infer that fireproof78's argument is not "this was a good story but Spock should have died" so much as "this story needed more work so that it wasn't 'necessary' to parade Spock around like a zombie."
There are things about this episode I quite like, and I don't consider it bottom of the barrel, but I have to admit that even as a child I thought having Scotty and Kirk drive Spock around like a robot, using just an 8-button calculator, was batcrap idiotic.
Some shoes are hard to live up to.A lie is around the globe while truth is still living up their shoes.

We use essential cookies to make this site work, and optional cookies to enhance your experience.