• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Let's talk "Spock's Brain"

No, it cannot. It is borderline on offensive and not entertaining in the slightest.
I mean, like it or don't like it, that's fine. Silly? Sure maybe. Offensive? That seems like that's a little extreme. Not entertaining? You'll never get a consensus.

It seems to trade on a similar notion as Plato's Stepchildren that forcing the characters to act out of character is somehow fun and not eye rolling at best and makes me turn off the episode at worst.
Yet I, Mudd and A Piece of the Action seem to get a pass 'round these parts for doing just that for the sake of yuk yuks.
 
Offensive? That seems like that's a little extreme
Removal of autonomy is very much something I find offensive. Call it extreme if you like but I cannot stomach it.

I, Mudd and A Piece of the Action seem to get a pass 'round these parts for doing just that for the sake of yuk yuks.
Autonomy being the key difference for me.

They choose to act differently and play to their character strengths.
 
I don't see Spock being brought down to the planet as a loss of autonomy. They had to put his brain back immediately when they found it, so bringing him down was the quickest way to save him.

The one who took his autonomy away was the Eymorg who took Spock's brain to begin with.
 
I wonder if it is the same one where Harris appears with Leonard Nimoy and his children. Perhaps not, as the one with Shatner and Cartright looks more formal.
Harris' hair and tie are seemingly different in the two photos as well.
 
Removal of autonomy is very much something I find offensive. Call it extreme if you like but I cannot stomach it.


Autonomy being the key difference for me.

They choose to act differently and play to their character strengths.
Then a lot of popular fiction must be hard for you to enjoy. Loss of autonomy is a key ingredient in a many stories. The struggle to regain it being part of the goal. Any time someone is taken over, brainwashed or otherwise coerced. Star Trek has more than its share.

I get it. I can't watch people being buried alive because of my claustrophobia. An episode of Alias with Sydney trapped in a coffin was a one time watch for me. It's incredibly uncomfortable. I understand the feeling, I just didn't see the "offensive" part of it.
 
When I said that manipulating Spock's remote-controlled brainless body could not be taken seriously, I meant because it was ridiculous, both in terms of its in-universe implausibility and in terms of multiple silly choices made for its execution.

A gurney on anti-gravs to move the body around would have been far more plausible from an in-universe perspective.

The fact that Nimoy moving around under remote-control doesn't accomplish anything that his all but lifeless body on a gurney couldn't have pulled off more convincingly should have been an enormous clue that they needed to scrap the episode and find something better for the popular character to be doing that week.
 
It is borderline on offensive and not entertaining in the slightest. It seems to trade on a similar notion as Plato's Stepchildren that forcing the characters to act out of character is somehow fun and not eye rolling at best and makes me turn off the episode at worst.
It cannot be entertaining or fun to anyone except the torturing Platonians.* Thus, it cannot seem to.

(*Which is the warp-drive POINT.)
 
Last edited:
I don't watch a lot of fiction.


Because it crosses a core value of mine.
It's good to believe in something, provided it corresponds to reality, but when your core values must be enforced so pervasively that they keep you from enjoying Star Trek, you might want to come up for air.

"Spock's Brain" isn't so good as human drama, and it isn't so bad as morally corrosive television, that we should do battle over McCoy's RC unit. :bolian:
 
good to believe in something, provided it corresponds to reality, but when your core values must be enforced so pervasively that they keep you from enjoying Star Trek, you might want to come up for air
It's deeply uncomfortable to treat a person so poorly.

And if it entertains you great. :beer:
 
so bringing him down was the quickest way to save him.
(Apologies for the tandem post.)

With transporters making travel near-instantaneous? They needed Spock as an RC toy so he could save them from the pain belts. Meanwhile, the pain did not disrupt Kirk's fine motor control enough to prevent him from controlling Spock.

It's a nonsense episode. Some see it as dramatic. Others as a comedy. All I know is that it "missed" with me. I will review the episode on occasion, but I do not review it as frequently as with other episodes.
 
(Apologies for the tandem post.)

With transporters making travel near-instantaneous? They needed Spock as an RC toy so he could save them from the pain belts. Meanwhile, the pain did not disrupt Kirk's fine motor control enough to prevent him from controlling Spock.

It's a nonsense episode. Some see it as dramatic. Others as a comedy. All I know is that it "missed" with me. I will review the episode on occasion, but I do not review it as frequently as with other episodes.
Except they couldn't beam down underground to that facility. It was clearly shielded from sensors, so they couldn't just beam in.
 
(Apologies for the tandem post.)

With transporters making travel near-instantaneous?

They were too far underground to communicate with the Enterprise. Besides, there was no indication the removal was done with McCoy's equipment. Kara had her own ship. She could have taken Spock over, removed his brain and sent him back.

So it was a lucky thing they brought him along.
They needed Spock as an RC toy so he could save them from the pain belts. Meanwhile, the pain did not disrupt Kirk's fine motor control enough to prevent him from controlling Spock.
Well they needed Nimoy to be in the episode other than as a disembodied voice. Otherwise, Spock would be asleep in bed until they found the teacher. Nimoy getting his full salary for an hour in the recording booth and a day of shooting would have been a waste of salary.

Here's the thing....Spock wasn't suffering. His brain was hooked up to the Controller and judging by the onscreen evidence, was fascinated by what he was doing. He also had access to a wealth of knowledge. Nowhere was it indicated that he was desperately trying to get back to his body.

His body was an empty shell. The physical Spock being remote controlled around was just a body. It wasn't Spock. So it's not like Spock was being carted around like a puppet. Everything that makes Spock "Spock" was cheerfully reading and making air circulate. He may not have chosen to be there, but he didn't seem particularly put out by it.

Unlike, say, when Parmen made him laugh and cry. Okay, that was meant to be unsettling. But Spock's Brain was a B Movie...Star Trek Style. I enjoy it on that level.
 
It's worth noting that the removal of Spock's brain and consciousness made him the first male to enter the all-female enclave in some time.
Oh really? Then who be these guys?

spocks-brain-br-409.jpg
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top