• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

James Kirk in "Discovery"?

So that means if the Talosians show up on Disco, Michael and company will have to venture to Talos on the Enterprise. So maybe we will see the interior of the Big E, including the bridge, after all. ;)

It's been widely reported that the Enterprise bridge will be seen. Also, we've seen some of the interiors already (corridor and Spock's quarters).
 
Spock was one of the two officers that recommended no further contact with Talos IV. He signed off along with Pike on the report to Starfleet.

I7zjwEp.jpg


Screencap from Trekcore.com
It's really weird how they expressly pointed out that Spock was HALF-VULCAN. :wtf:
 
It's really weird how they expressly pointed out that Spock was HALF-VULCAN. :wtf:
Starfleet was still solely under United Earth which is a human based organization up to the mid-first season of TOS, when it was transferred to the Federation ([URL="https://www.trekbbs.com/threads/when-did-tos-take-place-23rd-century-or-22nd-century.297786/page-9#post-12789653"]when did TOS take place, 23rd century or 22nd century[/URL]). Aliens (and half-aliens) are rare, or should be rare, serving with humans in the CAGE, DSC and still rare in TOS. Long-term environmental (and language) concerns probably limit most alien postings to earth based starfleet and ships. Even Spock, who is half-human, finds the Enterprise uncomfortably cold as he finally confesses to McCoy in "The Deadly Years". Vulcans will find it too high in O2 or high pressure, and too cold (per "Amok Time"). Andorians will find it too hot (ENT retcon). Tellarites too...clean smelling or too high gravity judging by how weak and unstable the ambassador looked in "Journey to Babel". Short-term, you can tolerate it, but long-term can be, if not uncomfortable, hazardous to your health.
 
Assuming that DISC gets a third season, should the Discovery crew run into a young James Kirk? Why or why not? And at what point?

Dear God, I hope not. Having Pike and Spock on for Season 2 is bad enough. Perhaps I can tolerate a one episode appearance and nothing else.
 
Starfleet was still solely under United Earth which is a human based organization up to the mid-first season of TOS, when it was transferred to the Federation (when did TOS take place, 23rd century or 22nd century). Aliens (and half-aliens) are rare, or should be rare, serving with humans in the CAGE, DSC and still rare in TOS. Long-term environmental (and language) concerns probably limit most alien postings to earth based starfleet and ships. Even Spock, who is half-human, finds the Enterprise uncomfortably cold as he finally confesses to McCoy in "The Deadly Years". Vulcans will find it too high in O2 or high pressure, and too cold (per "Amok Time"). Andorians will find it too hot (ENT retcon). Tellarites too...clean smelling or too high gravity judging by how weak and unstable the ambassador looked in "Journey to Babel". Short-term, you can tolerate it, but long-term can be, if not uncomfortable, hazardous to your health.
Addition thoughts: I don't think the Enterprise has a dial-a-gravity in quarters. It seems to have gravity control in engineered areas, such as in small environmental chambers (in Med Bay, "Lights of Zetar") and maybe the flight deck (on/off?). The rest of the ship is all set at a gravity setting. Even when the turbolift fails, it goes into free fall implying the whole ship is at gravity.
 
My ideal version of the TOS bridge -- if they were to make it look like it would've been done in the '60s if they had the budget -- would've been to make it look 2001: A Space Odyssey inspired, with Disco-style computer displays.
Unfortunately for that idea, 2001 was released in 1968, years after the TOS bridge had been designed.

Principle photography on 2001 began almost a year after "The Cage" had been screened and months after principle photography on "Where No Man Has Gone Before" had wrapped.

The TOS bridge could never have been "inspired" by 2001.
 
Addition thoughts: I don't think the Enterprise has a dial-a-gravity in quarters. It seems to have gravity control in engineered areas, such as in small environmental chambers (in Med Bay, "Lights of Zetar") and maybe the flight deck (on/off?). The rest of the ship is all set at a gravity setting. Even when the turbolift fails, it goes into free fall implying the whole ship is at gravity.

Then again, the walla relating to exercises or damage includes the "Gravity at .8" bit. We don't observe this in practice, which is sort of the point - but as a corollary to that, we would never get good evidence against cabins having adjustable gravity, exactly because the adjusting would always have to be unobservable, for VFX/SFX expenses reasons.

ENT had localized gravity failures extending to things as private as cabin shower stalls, it seems. Sure, the ship might have been hardwired in a way that would make it difficult for T'Pol to maintain higher gravity in her quarters - but future ships would not be deliberately handicapped that way.

The Discovery has "piecemeal" written all over her hull, and could accommodate fairly exotic guests or crew members (and already has). And the VFX/SFX for showing significant gravity manipulation would finally be affordable, in moderation.

As for Spock's "half-Vulcan" status in official correspondence, that's sort of super-significant in a document discussing the quarantining of a world inhabited by powerful telepaths...

Timo Saloniemi
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top