• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

I officially began my journey through all Star Trek on October 9th...

....
Oh, absolutely not. I'll be watching from the very beginning, just like I have with the others (can't be as bad as the first two seasons of TNG, right? ;))....Am I screwed? Have I spoiled too much on myself? :(

I'm kind of annoyed with myself. I seem to always get big things spoiled on me anytime I get big into something.

Glad you're starting at the beginning with DS9. I'm afraid, however, that DS9 is just as uneven as TNG for the first two seasons—and maybe even worse. I'd say for the first two years there are c. 3 dud episodes for every good one. But the good ones are very good! And they show the greatness that's to come for DS9. Starting with the third year it becomes consistently strong, with something like 3 out of every 4 episodes being somewhere between good and great, and only a few weak episodes each season. And it has the best final year of all of the Star Trek shows.

It's slightly too bad you got those spoilers, but really not a big deal.

One slight bummer that you'll probably notice is that both TOS and TNG have been beautifully remastered for HD. That has not happened for DS9, and apparently won't happen, because it's so expensive. If you're watching on a smaller screen it won't be a big deal, but on a big screen you can really notice it.


Someone made a cool fan trailer for DS9's 20th anniversary a few years ago. Like most trailers it makes DS9 look much more action-packed than it really is. And I think it might be considered to have a few spoilers, and so I don't think I'll post it.

Oh, one last thing. Try not to believe the haters re: Voyager. It's a very good show imho! I like it just as much as TNG, DS9, and TOS. But for some reason, and I think maybe part of it is sexism because of Janeway, there's a lot of trashing of VOY. I think Janeway is a great captain.
 
Last edited:
About Janeway. I think the writers did not know how to find a happy medium with her. Like they didn't know how to write a woman in a position of authority without making her seem too much one way or another.
 
About Janeway. I think the writers did not know how to find a happy medium with her. Like they didn't know how to write a woman in a position of authority without making her seem too much one way or another.
Arguably, they had the same problems with Picard, Sisko, and Archer. Yes, striking the right tone for a woman captain posed more problems, and Jeri Taylor's vision didn't help to create an unassailable, consistent character. I think the other captains were equally underdeveloped in their first 2-3 seasons as Janeway, perhaps even less so. Picard and Sisko appeared to be intelletually aloof, and Archer appeared to be persistently annoyed. I think what saved Picard and Sisko is that the writers actually feared losing the respective actors, and began writing more to their interests as both actors and activists. Archer didn't change much, but that disappointment over not being an explorer that he felt was woven more organically into later stories. What happened with Janeway? I don't know. She became more clearly a central element of stories as the series focused more on Janeway, Seven of Nine, and the Doctor.
 
Jeri Taylor's vision of Janeway always reminds me of a certain South Park episode. Where the Christian record publisher is trying to explain to Cartmen the difference between "loving Jesus" and writing really creepy "Love songs to Jesus". Jeri seems to have a similar issue with Janeway. Most writers Love the characters they write. They delve into the nooks and crannies, finding interest and depth in their struggles and flaws. Taylor's writing of the character always struck me as someone who was more "in love" with the character. Enamored of Janeway and would never perceive or reflect on the characters flaws. The end result was Jeri's writing made Janeway seem oddly creepily psychotic. Especially as it tended to be interspersed with other writers more nuanced takes on the character. If anyone was reading DC comics in the early 00's you might remember Devin Greyson's oddly creepy run writing Nightwing. Where the reader felt more like they were reading a stalkers diary of fan fiction as she followed and chronicled the man she "loved". Jeri Taylor's Janeway always reminded me of that. (Granted Twilight proved there is a market for that sort of thing...)

Now most ST characters took a little while to dial in and shed some of their initial "character outline" baggage (Piccard's hatred of children anyone?) and evolve to their final forms. Often over the course of season 1 and sometimes 2. But Janeway and Worf stand out as the two main focus characters that they never really got dialed in solidly. Every writer had a subtly different spin on them that took away from the overall perception of the character by the viewer. Archer suffered a little bit of this as well. I suspect that some of it may also fall on the approach and technique taken by individual actors. The stronger character actors such as Picardo found and focused on their inner voices for the role in spite of the writers vagaries. Whereas the more "lead" actors were more at the mercy of the script and individual writers.
 
Cool fan trailer for Voyager:

To view this content we will need your consent to set third party cookies.
For more detailed information, see our cookies page.
 
I know Sisko is like some kind of god or something, I know they get their own starship in season three, I know Worf joins the show in season four, and I know Jadzia dies at some point :(

Am I screwed? Have I spoiled too much on myself? :(

You're not screwed because...
Sisko is not a god. For 7 seasons he is a human.
You don't know how or why a starship or Worf join the action.
Jadzia is a Trill, if that body were to die, she could live on in another body, I guess... But, we're all going to die someday.
 
As the new show gets ready to launch, Star Trek will start to draw new fans. Most of them, however, will be daunted by the idea of the 700 episodes that now exist of the various Trek shows. Fans of Hitchhiker's Guide to the Galaxy know that the answer to the question of life, the universe, and everything is 42:

To view this content we will need your consent to set third party cookies.
For more detailed information, see our cookies page.

What if you tried to boil down all of TV Trek to 42? Which episodes would you pick? And first off, how would you spread out your 42. I think I'd do 10 from TOS, 10 from TNG, 10 from DS9, 10 from VOY, and 2 from Ent. I'm going to say that two-parters count as one.

Which ten from the original series might you pick for a newbie to try the best of that now-ancient show? Here are mine (in production order):

Balance of Terror
What Are Little Girls Made Of?
The Menagerie, parts I & II
Space Seed
The City on the Edge of Forever
Amok Time
The Doomsday Machine
Mirror, Mirror
Journey to Babel
The Enterprise Incident
 
Unfortunately, from posting on here a lot, I've ran into a few (major?) spoilers to do with DS9.

I know Sisko is like some kind of god or something, I know they get their own starship in season three, I know Worf joins the show in season four, and I know Jadzia dies at some point :(

Am I screwed? Have I spoiled too much on myself? :(
Most of this isn't a problem:
Sisko isn't a god, but the Bajorans regard him as connected to the gods. Not really a spoiler as it emerges in the first episode. From your list, the only real sticking point is Jadzia, but if you find you dislike the character, your foreknowledge will be an upside. ;)
 
Shala....

Since you survived the very uneven last season of TOS, as well as the often weak first two seasons to TNG, I think you'll be able to make it through DS9's hit and miss first two years. But just in case you want a "cheat sheet," there's a fan who has made a list of the best and most essential episodes of DS9, getting the best of the show in c. 75 episodes. Here's the list:

1. Emissary part 1--pilot

2. Emissary part 2-- pilot

19. Duet--cardassian war criminal……..my fan choice #1

20. Hands of the Prophets--intro Kai Winn, season 1 ender

21. Homecoming--Bajoran coup trilogy 1,season 2 opener

22. Circle--part 2

23. Siege--part 3

39. Blood Oath--re-intro Kang, Kor and Koloth

40. Maquis part 1--intro of the maquis movement

41. Maquis part 2--

43. Crossover--first “mirror” episode

46. Jem’ Hadar--beginning of the Founders arc, season 2 ender

47. Search part 1--looking for the Jem’Hadar, season 3 opener

48. Search part 2--

51. Second Skin--Cardassian believes kira is his daughter…..my fan choice #2

55. Defiant--Riker returns……..my fan choice #3

60. Heart of Stone--founders trick Odo into professing love for Kira….my fan choice #4

65. Improbable Cause--major precursor to Founder war part 1

67. The Die is Cast--part 2

66. Thru the Looking Glass--part 2 of “mirror” arc (filmed in-between previous two-parter)

72. Adversary--season 3 ender, sets up Founder infiltration of federation.

73. Way of the Warrior part 1--start of Klingon civil war, Worf intro, season 4 opener

74. Way of the Warrior part 2

76. The Visitor--”old Jake” seeks his lost father……….my fan choice #5

79. Starship Down--iconic battle with Jem’ Hadar

80. Little Green Men--classic ferengi comedy episode…..my fan favorite #6

81. Sword of Kahless--part of “original klingons” arc

83. Homefront--founders infiltrate earth part 1

84. Paradise Lost--part 2

86. Return to Grace--key Dukat/Kira episode…..my fan favorite #7

87. Sons of Mogh--farwell to Kurn…..my fan favorite #8

92. Shattered Mirror--”mirror arc” part 3

94. For the Cause--key Maquis episode

96. To the Death--strong Jem’ Hadar episode

98. Broken Link--Odo becomes Human, season 4 ender

99. Apocalypse Rising--season 5 opener Klingon/Dominion

100. The Ship--Dominion face-off

102. Nor the Battle to the Strong--good rare Jake episode involving Klingons

104. Trials and Tribbleations--'Nuff said

111. For the Uniform--Maquis arc involving Eddington.

112. In Pugatory's Shadow--part 1 of classic Garak/DominionWorf prison story

113. By Inferno's Light--part 2 outstanding conclusion with Cardassia switching sides among many other themes.

119. Soldiers of the Empire--strong Worf/Martok Klingon episode

120. Children of Time--awesome Odo/alternate reality episode--my fan favorite choice******

121. Blaze of glory--Maquis/Eddington wrap up

122. Empok Nor--outstanding O'Brien/Garak episode--my fan favorite choice***********

124. Call to Arms--season 5 ender and official Dominion War start

125. Time to stand--season 6 opener DS9 under Dominion occupation & Sisko on secret mission

126. Rocks and Shoals-- conclusion to Sisko's mission, great microcosm of war story

128. Behind the Lines--the 'partisan' resistance on occupied DS9 begins in earnest

129. Favor the Bold--Sisko decides to retake DS9 as a symbolic victory in a war going badly

130. Sacrifice of Angels--part 2--Feds retake DS9 with much loss of life

131. You Are Cordially Invited--Worf/Dax wedding--My fan favorite choice

137. Far beyond the Stars--Fantastic period piece/alternate reality episode--my fan favorite******

138. One Little Ship--"Ant-Man" sized crew takes on Jem'Hadar

142. Inquisition--first "Section 31" episode

143. In the Pale Moonlight--Sisko makes morally questionable decision to save the federation, a great Garak episode (is there any other kind?)

146. Valiant--nice Jake/Nog episode with young crew fighting Dominion

150. Tears of the Prophets--farewell to Jadzia--season 6 ender

151. Image in the sand--season 7 opener parts--Sisko pursues his destiny

152. Shadows & Symbols--part 2 of sisko origin

157. Once More Into the Breach--wrap-up to the Kor "ancient warriors" arc featuring Dominion

158. Siege of AR-558--classic war is hell episode, very well done

162. Emperer's New Cloak--final "mirror" episode

166. Inter Arma Enim silent Leges--classic political treachery episode--my fan favorite*********

167-176 are the ten episode wrap to the war and the series and I don't think you can leave any out....
 
That's a tough question. I appreciate The Original Series much more now than I did when I first watched it. At the time, I was kind of "eh" about it, was wanting to just move on to the more modern shows, but now, I kind of miss it.

I think The Next Generation is the better show of the two, but as for characters, while Picard may be my favourite captain and Data and the ensemble cast is awesome, I don't think anything will be able to beat that character dynamic between Kirk, Spock and Bones. They caught lightning in a bottle there, not only with the characters, but with Shatner, Nimoy and Kelley, just perfect casting. I'd rather watch the films again then do a full watch through of TOS, sure, but I still love that series.

Anyway, to your question, after much thinking, these are probably the ten essential episodes I'd show to a newbie (in order of production):

Balance of Terror
The Menagerie, Parts I and II
Arena
Space Seed
The City on the Edge of Forever
Amok Time
The Doomsday Machine
Mirror, Mirror
The Trouble with Tribbles
Journey to Babel

There's a few others I'd love to put on there like The Corbomite Maneuver, The Devil in the Dark, Errand of Mercy, A Piece of the Action, The Enterprise Incident and All Our Yesterdays, but if I can only pick ten, then they're my ten.

A very good list. And one that lines up extremely well with most fans favorites.

While yes TNG never had that specific chemistry of the core characters, they made better use of the broader cast to create smaller chemistries amongst the crew while leaving the Captain a bit more regal and aloof. Lonely is the head that wears the crown if you will. It was an approach that worked well for Patrick Stewart's Picard.

DS9 is fascinating in that it does have a ton of TOS type chemistry. It's just not really focused on the main core cast. It may be telling that our "Everyman" POV character is an elevated TNG background supporting character. Because in DS9 the supporting cast steals the show in every way possible. Quark, Odo, OBrien and Bashir, Garrak etc. this is not to say the main uniform cast is bad. Avery Brooks is charmingly badass as The Sisco. (You will know maximum Sisco has been achieved when he stops shaving his chin and starts shaving his head.) But you don't come back week after week to see what's going on in Ops. You come back to see the denizens of the Promenade and how the interact. (And to watch Bald Bearded The Sisco use the Defiant to blow whatever he feels like straight to hell. "None of this mamby pamby exploration and diplomacy. It's point, shoot, accept surrender")

Voyager probably has the weakest cast chemistry. It has a lot of great characters and performances, but what chemistry there was generally seemed to be "Paris and..." Or "The Doctor and...". I guess there could be said to be a sort of chemistry between Janeway and Harry Kim, in a sort of "Fifty Shades of Janeway" breaking of will, kind of way. ("She only hurts me because she loves me!")

The cast chemistry for Enterprise is sadly underrated. They all for the most part meshed really well.
 
Archer was just plain boring. You can say a lot of things about Janeway, but she wasn't boring.
 
Here are my ratings for the whole first season of TOS....

Man Trap: B-
Charlie X: C+
Where No Man Has Gone Before: B+
The Naked Time: B
The Enemy Within: B
Mudd's Women: D
What Are Little Girls Made Of: B+
Miri: B-
Dagger of the Mind: B+
Corbomite Maneuver: A-
The Menagerie I & II: A
Conscience of the King: B+
Balance of Terror: A
Shore Leave: B
Galileo Seven: B
The Squire of Gothos: B
Arena: A-
Tomorrow is Yesterday: C+
Court Martial: B
Return of the Archons: B-
Space Seed: A-
A Taste of Armageddon: B+
This Side of Paradise: B-
The Devil in the Dark: B+
Errand of Mercy: C-
The Alternative Factor: D-
City on the Edge of Forever: A+
Operation: Annihilate!: B
 
Yes, "The Inner Light" is one of the finest episodes of the whole show. Thanks for sharing your reviews. Amazing that you're now almost at the end of the 5th season.

If I may ask, what are your top 20 or so episodes for TNG so far? A few years ago my teenage son and I did a top 40 list of our favorite Next Gen episodes. Here's the list, ranked from best to the merely good. We ranked Inner Light in the top 5, and those top five are all about equal in my mind. I have a feeling we've missed a lot of good ones....

All Good Things
Chain of Command
Darmok
The Measure of a Man
The Inner Light


The Offspring
Unification
Yesterday's Enterprise
Best of Both Worlds
Frame of Mind


The Defector
Time's Arrow
Preemptive Strike
Face of the Enenmy
Redemption


Cause and Effect
Arsenal of Freedom
Parallels
Time Squared
Coming of Age


Remember Me
Sins of the Father
Conspiracy
Family
A Matter of Honor


Reunion
Timescape
Disaster
I, Borg
Ensign Ro


Night Terrors
The Next Phase
Second Chances
The Game
A Fistful of Datas


The Battle
Ship in a Bottle
Conundrum
Evolution
Relics
 
If you count "The Cage," as well as count "The Menagerie" as two episodes, I think TOS has 80 episodes in total. My son and I also did an experiment of trying to boil down TNG to its best 80 episodes in broadcast order. Even though Encounter at Farpoint is a deeply flawed episode, we included it because it sets up a lot of things, including esp. the last episode, All Good Things. Anyway, more listmania....

1, 2 Encounter at Farpoint
3 Where No One Has Gone Before
4 The Battle
5 The Big Goodbye
6 Datalore
7 11001001
8 Coming of Age
9 Heart of Glory
10 Arsenal of Freedom
11 Conspiracy
12 Elementary, Dear Data
13 A Matter of Honor
14 The Measure of a Man
15 Contagion
16 Time Squared
17 Pen Pals
18 Q Who
19 Samaritan Snare
20 Peak Performance
21 Evolution
22 The Enemy
23 The Defector
24 The Hunted
25 Yesterday’s Enterprise
26 The Offspring
27 Sins of the Father
28 Sarek
29, 30 Best of Both Worlds
31 Family
32 Brothers
33 Remember Me
34 Reunion
35 Data’s Day
36 The Wounded
37 The Clues
38 First Contact
39 Night Terrors
40 The Nth Degree
41 The Drumhead
42 The Mind’s Eye
43, 44 Redemption
45 Darmok
46 Ensign Ro
47 Disaster
48 The Game
49, 50 Unification
51 Conundrum
52 Ethics
53 Cause and Effect
54 First Duty
55 I, Borg
56 The Next Phase
57 The Inner Light
58, 59 Time’s Arrow
60 A Fistful of Datas
61 The Quality of Life
62, 63 Chain of Command
64 Ship in a Bottle
65 Face of the Enemy
66 Tapestry
67, 68 Birthright
69 Starship Mine
70 Lessons
71 The Chase
72 Frame of Mind
73 Rightful Heir
74 Second Chances
75 Timescape
76, 77 Descent
78 Parallels
79 Preemptive Strike
80, 81 All Good Things
 
I love how Geordi seems to get along best with android-like characters such as Data and Hugh
No to mention holograms.... :shifty:

Looking back now, I think he might have been testing Hugh to see if he had fully transitioned from the ways of the Borg or if this was just a temporary thing.
If you mean the scene in which Hugh recognizes him as Locutus and Picard then slips into Locutus character, that's exactly what he was doing.

I'm still curious how Picard could even remember anyone on the Enterprise's names or even how to captain a starship after going through so much for so so long.
It's a subject that's been debated in these parts, but my impression is that while it seemed completely real-time and immersive to him while it was happening, in reality it was downloaded into his brain in 25 minutes, and once he awakened from the experience, he was able to access his real memories just as easily as if he'd been unconscious for 25 minutes.
 
Again its nice to see someone new appreciate what they are seeing as opposed to so many fans these days who take things for granted.

I, Borg. A controversial episode, but I LIKE that. The show needed episodes like this where people questioned moral decisionson a big scale. That alone makes it great.

Next Phase is an underrated little gem with some good pacing and good FX.

What can I say about Inner Light. It's pretty terrific. This BB is the only place I've ever seen anyone say the DON'T like it..as insane as that sounds.

Wow..... this is gonna be fun.


So I just got finished watching a run of three episodes, two of them being just great episodes and one an all-time classic. I feel slightly overwhelmed right now, but I'll give you my thoughts on each of them anyway. Enjoy...


I, Borg
I was super excited to watch this. It'd been nearly two seasons since we'd seen the Borg, and I was anxiously waiting to see the Borg cube come back, blow some shit up, and assimilate a few people here and there. Now while that didn't exactly happen, I got something just as good in a much more grounded and personal story with the Borg after Q Who and The Best of Both Worlds. First of all, the guest actor for Third of Five/Hugh, Jonathan Del Arco, did a great job, as well as the rest of the main cast as a whole.

I love how Geordi seems to get along best with android-like characters such as Data and Hugh, better than he has with any human character on the show. He taught Hugh how to be an individual, and for the first time ever, when Picard first met Hugh, I felt legitimately angry at the captain. Looking back now, I think he might have been testing Hugh to see if he had fully transitioned from the ways of the Borg or if this was just a temporary thing. Commendable, but at the time, I felt like shouting at him for trying to undo the work of everyone else on the ship. Hugh is innocent, dammit! Leave him alone! :lol:

Enjoyed this episode a lot. I hope this isn't the last Borg-centered episode of TNG, they're pretty fucking awesome :borg:

The Next Phase
This was quite an interesting episode. Written by Ronald D. Moore and directed by David Carson, I had a feeling going in it was going to be a good one. Carson's episodes I've noticed tend to stand out a lot, for good reasons. They have their own sort of visual flair that you don't see with the other episodes. I see now after looking him up that he's the director of Star Trek Generations, so maybe the producers had the same feeling as me. They look more... professional, I guess, I don't know.

Anyway, The Next Phase was an episode all about death. In the beginning, Geordi and Ensign Ro Laren transport over to the Enterprise from a Romulan ship and are lost in the transporter beam, presumed dead. Little does Picard and the rest of the crew not only know that Geordi and Ro are still alive and well, but they're actually still on the ship, but are cloaked and carry no substance. We get to learn more about Ro and Bajoran culture, we get to see more sneaky Romulans, and we get to see an interesting problem Geordi and Ro have to overcome.

Just a fun episode. We even got some action chases to rival J. J. Abrams's Star Trek ;)

The Inner Light
Aaaand, this is it. This is the reason I've gone through eight seasons and six films of Star Trek. Not because of cool starships, not because of wacky aliens or big explosions, but for inspiring and touching stories like this.

After watching The Inner Light, I have a new favourite episode. Episodes like The City on the Edge of Forever, The Trouble with Tribbles, The Measure of a Man, Yesterday's Enterprise, The Best of Both Worlds, Darmok... they are all surpassed by this, the best episode out of the franchise for me so far.

The performances, writing and music in this was phenomenal. Margot Rose plays Eline, the wife of "Kamin", and she manages to steal whatever scene she's in, holding her own perfectly well up against Patrick Stewart and his, as always, strong performance. This was a deeply personal story for Picard, in 25 minutes for everyone else on the Enterprise, he goes through multiples decades in a whole new life.

I don't ever cry or get too emotional watching movies or TV shows, but Eline's death scene was definitely enough to make tears well up in my eyes. That ending too, when Kamine is finally told how and why he's there, and his reaction is just too much, man :( Imagine waking up from that, I'm still curious how Picard could even remember anyone on the Enterprise's names or even how to captain a starship after going through so much for so so long. His family, his kids and grandchildren which he saw grow up from babies to adults, all gone forever, never to be seen again in just a split second. That is torturous, so much worse than any Borg assimilation.

Ugh, there's so much more I can say about this episode. How about the music!? That flute melody, while so simple, is yet so gorgeous. I've been listening to this while typing out this full post, and it sounds like something right out of The Lord of the Rings. Beautiful. I remember sitting still for about five minutes after that episode ended, staring at a blank screen. Him playing that flute one more time leading into the credits, such a perfect ending.

Anyway, that's that done. The season five finale, Time's Arrow, is up next, and I'll probably make a post on my impressions for that too later. Hopefully we can reach Chain of Command and get DS9 started by next weekend. We still have quite a lot more to go for now though, so let's keep going.
 
Wow..... this is gonna be fun.


So I just got finished watching a run of three episodes, two of them being just great episodes and one an all-time classic. I feel slightly overwhelmed right now, but I'll give you my thoughts on each of them anyway. Enjoy...


I, Borg
I was super excited to watch this. It'd been nearly two seasons since we'd seen the Borg, and I was anxiously waiting to see the Borg cube come back, blow some shit up, and assimilate a few people here and there. Now while that didn't exactly happen, I got something just as good in a much more grounded and personal story with the Borg after Q Who and The Best of Both Worlds. First of all, the guest actor for Third of Five/Hugh, Jonathan Del Arco, did a great job, as well as the rest of the main cast as a whole.

I love how Geordi seems to get along best with android-like characters such as Data and Hugh, better than he has with any human character on the show. He taught Hugh how to be an individual, and for the first time ever, when Picard first met Hugh, I felt legitimately angry at the captain. Looking back now, I think he might have been testing Hugh to see if he had fully transitioned from the ways of the Borg or if this was just a temporary thing. Commendable, but at the time, I felt like shouting at him for trying to undo the work of everyone else on the ship. Hugh is innocent, dammit! Leave him alone! :lol:

Enjoyed this episode a lot. I hope this isn't the last Borg-centered episode of TNG, they're pretty fucking awesome :borg:

The Next Phase
This was quite an interesting episode. Written by Ronald D. Moore and directed by David Carson, I had a feeling going in it was going to be a good one. Carson's episodes I've noticed tend to stand out a lot, for good reasons. They have their own sort of visual flair that you don't see with the other episodes. I see now after looking him up that he's the director of Star Trek Generations, so maybe the producers had the same feeling as me. They look more... professional, I guess, I don't know.

Anyway, The Next Phase was an episode all about death. In the beginning, Geordi and Ensign Ro Laren transport over to the Enterprise from a Romulan ship and are lost in the transporter beam, presumed dead. Little does Picard and the rest of the crew not only know that Geordi and Ro are still alive and well, but they're actually still on the ship, but are cloaked and carry no substance. We get to learn more about Ro and Bajoran culture, we get to see more sneaky Romulans, and we get to see an interesting problem Geordi and Ro have to overcome.

Just a fun episode. We even got some action chases to rival J. J. Abrams's Star Trek ;)

The Inner Light
Aaaand, this is it. This is the reason I've gone through eight seasons and six films of Star Trek. Not because of cool starships, not because of wacky aliens or big explosions, but for inspiring and touching stories like this.

After watching The Inner Light, I have a new favourite episode. Episodes like The City on the Edge of Forever, The Trouble with Tribbles, The Measure of a Man, Yesterday's Enterprise, The Best of Both Worlds, Darmok... they are all surpassed by this, the best episode out of the franchise for me so far.

The performances, writing and music in this was phenomenal. Margot Rose plays Eline, the wife of "Kamin", and she manages to steal whatever scene she's in, holding her own perfectly well up against Patrick Stewart and his, as always, strong performance. This was a deeply personal story for Picard, in 25 minutes for everyone else on the Enterprise, he goes through multiples decades in a whole new life.

I don't ever cry or get too emotional watching movies or TV shows, but Eline's death scene was definitely enough to make tears well up in my eyes. That ending too, when Kamine is finally told how and why he's there, and his reaction is just too much, man :( Imagine waking up from that, I'm still curious how Picard could even remember anyone on the Enterprise's names or even how to captain a starship after going through so much for so so long. His family, his kids and grandchildren which he saw grow up from babies to adults, all gone forever, never to be seen again in just a split second. That is torturous, so much worse than any Borg assimilation.

Ugh, there's so much more I can say about this episode. How about the music!? That flute melody, while so simple, is yet so gorgeous. I've been listening to this while typing out this full post, and it sounds like something right out of The Lord of the Rings. Beautiful. I remember sitting still for about five minutes after that episode ended, staring at a blank screen. Him playing that flute one more time leading into the credits, such a perfect ending.

Anyway, that's that done. The season five finale, Time's Arrow, is up next, and I'll probably make a post on my impressions for that too later. Hopefully we can reach Chain of Command and get DS9 started by next weekend. We still have quite a lot more to go for now though, so let's keep going.

I have to agree with you. I think The Inner Light is the finest crafted episode of TNG. Best of Both worlds and Yesterday's Enterprise will draw me back to greater or more frequent repeat viewings for their action and effects components, but the Inner Light is everything we ever could want in a thoughtful SciFi show. There are few other shows as thoughtful and as powerful that just leave you thinking. Off the top of my head TOS's "Balance of Terror" and "City on the Edge of Forever" Babylon 5's "Walking Through Gethsemane" and "The Coming of Shadows" spring to mind and DS9's "The Visitor" and "In the Pale Moonlight". And of those Inner Light is so wonderful in its compactness. It's a stage play. Limited cast. limited setting. Fully stand alone and self contained.

Also very astute to pick up on Geordi. You've discovered his darkest character secret. He's a closeted Robosexual. Star Trek providing diversity, generations ahead of its time! (does anyone else suspect that meeting 7of9 might have caused Geordi to simply drop dead on the spot?)
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top