How would other captains handle "In the Pale Moonlight"?

[intrinsical]

Kirk would have decided its necessary for the Federation's survival and gone ahead without Garak's help. He would get Spock to keep Vreenak busy while he personally planted the bomb on Vreenak's ship.

Picard would have lectured Garak. He would then bring the Enterprise into a loosing battle with the Jem'Hadar right at the Romulan-Federation border. While fighting off the Jem'Hadar, he would appeal to the Romulans on the strategic and morale impact the loss of the Enterprise would have on the Federation and the war, and appeal for the Romulans intervene.

Janeway would have lectured Garak too. She would then take Voyager to the Romulan-Federation border and stay there for however long it takes to get the Romulans to see things her way.

I'm not sure what Archer would do. I suspect he would decide that getting the Romulans' aid is not worth the effort and concentrated on winning the war without them.

 

[Trevacious]

Archer -- No clue. I haven't seen anywhere near enough ENT.

I saw just enough to be sure that, whatever he did, it would involve a great deal of woodenness.

 

[darthvincor]

-Kirk: (never seen TOS, not sure what he'd do)
-Picard: He'd probably lecture Vreenak, then lecture Garak, then lecture Garak again when Vreenak dies, and finally get a cup of hot earl grey and stare out a viewport, with a look of foreboding on his face.
-Janeway: She'd probably say how she doesn't like Vreenak, and doesn't like Romulus, and also doesn't like the Dominion, and Garak least of all. When Garak has Vreenak killed, she gets Garak thrown in the brig. She then gets a cup of coffee and discusses it with Tuvok, about how things got this far.
-Archer: (haven't seen enough of ENT)