• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Hate for the new Trek and the Future of Trek

But emotions merely are electrical impulses!

@PhaserLightShow


Well, art is still tangible. And so is the reason art is enjoyed (just electrical impulses).

@PhaserLightShow

PLS, I do not know you from Adam, but it makes me very sad to think that you actually might believe that things like Love and Art are merely electrical impulses we "feel". For my part, I am going to hope and assume that You do not truly feel that way, and that you are conducting a Posting experiment, taking an extreme opposite position, to see if others can explain/put feelings into words.
 
Seems like we're pretty far off topic now. Let's see if we can redirect, mkay?

Thanks
 
PLS, I do not know you from Adam, but it makes me very sad to think that you actually might believe that things like Love and Art are merely electrical impulses we "feel". For my part, I am going to hope and assume that You do not truly feel that way, and that you are conducting a Posting experiment, taking an extreme opposite position, to see if others can explain/put feelings into words.
Who is Adam? I do believe what I say. And what do you believe - concerning emotions.

@PhaserLightShow
 
Seems like we're pretty far off topic now. Let's see if we can redirect, mkay?

Thanks
Off topic, pretty far. This only originated from one thing a poster said. And it made a whole conversation. And it is okay, not "mkay". Thanks!
I see what you are saying - what I said about emotions was originally relevant but it is now a "shouting contest". Well actually, a contest of logic. But off topic (let the good times roll!).

@PhaserLightShow
 
Last edited:
What I believe is that if one truly believes in reducing feelings and emotions to a series of electrical impulses, then there is no life or experience or "being". No point to existence. No reason for much of anything. And that makes the electrical impulses firing right now that simulate "sadness" in my system, to make me "feel" sad.

You can google the expression, "I don't know you from Adam", if you want.
 
So idioms are out too?
(nods)

So, this is something that I don't understand is why to people "hate" Abrams Trek so much? I mean, for all the garbage that all the Trek series get from TOS onward, I rarely see them labeled as "not Trek" like Abrams does. I mean, even I, at the height of my frustration with the prequel trilogy did not hate them or even pretend they didn't exist. It simply was, warts and all, regardless of my irritation.

Is it just me? I'm sure it's just me.
 
So idioms are out too?
Again, who is Adam?

What I believe is that if one truly believes in reducing feelings and emotions to a series of electrical impulses, then there is no life or experience or "being". No point to existence. No reason for much of anything. And that makes the electrical impulses firing right now that simulate "sadness" in my system, to make me "feel" sad.

You can google the expression, "I don't know you from Adam", if you want.
This is what I believe. I also believe that life has no single point. The only point of life is what we do with it.

@PhaserLightShow
 
Seems like we're pretty far off topic now. Let's see if we can redirect, mkay?

Thanks
You are correct. Myself and those I am debating with are covering issues best left to saints and philosophers- yet we still cover them. But you're right - this belongs in a separate thread. Perhaps I should create one in a "non-trek" area of the BBS.

@PhaserLightShow
 
one thong a poster said
How can a poster say an undergarment?
It was a misfired synapse.

I've said this before: STAR TREK INTO DARKNESS is the best film of 2013 and THE FORCE AWAKENS was the best film of 1977. It not only leans, it checklists.

The Force Awakens? In 1977. It came out this year!
It refers to the thought that Star Wars: The Force Awakens copies the plot points of Star Wars: A New Hope so closely that it could be considered a remake. Let's try to get those creative, associative, metaphorical, and humor-interpretive thinking synapses firing on all thrusters.
 
Hey, I prefer fast pace over slow pace, for sure. But damn, the Abrams movies are really fast. Trek XI really put the petal to the metal. We, get like a minute of an establishing of the Kelvin and a bridge scene, than Nero's ship shows up and it's just explosions right away
You wanted a VO about "cataloging gaseous anomalies", while the captain drinks out of a Starfleet regulation teacup?

;)

What I believe is that if one truly believes in reducing feelings and emotions to a series of electrical impulses, then there is no life or experience or "being". No point to existence.
I think that's a weird point of view. Like saying that if there's no God then we might as well kill ourselves. Life without the supernatural is still rich and worth living.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top