Whether it’s right or wrong is up for debate. However, that still doesn’t make it Nazism. Can we move on? Interesting stuff over on Memory-Alpha. In the original script, Phlox developed a cure, Archer after some wrangling decided to forbid it and Phlox went over his head and delivered the cure anyway. Apparently UPN stepped in and said all crew members should be following Captain’s orders and it was changed to what we have. So the confused feeling that permeates the episode can be put down to executive meddling at least.