Ramin Djawadi has explained why they decided to reuse the
Game of Thrones theme for this show:
“We decided to stick with that theme because
Game Of Thrones had been off air for three years, and it was decided that we really wanted to tie the shows together. Because even though it’s all-new characters and it’s set hundreds of years before, we felt like it needed that stamp to say ‘This is
Game Of Thrones—it’s in a different time, but it’s
Game Of Thrones,’” composer Ramin Djawadi explains in an
interview with
The A.V. Club’s own Hattie Lindert. “We felt like the opening really ties it all together. Even in the first episode, I wrote new pieces, but thematically, you hear the King’s Landing theme, you hear the dragon theme, so it’s very much calling back to the known themes to set the tone again. But then we depart, and as we get to know all the characters, there are new themes. I wrote so much music for the season.”
Honestly, I think that's weak reasoning. Oh, well.
Considering the astonishing talent and creativity Djawadi has demonstrated over the years, creating musical masterpieces even when the stories they featured in were somewhat lacking (e.g., "The Night King")... I find myself strongly suspecting that this was not actually his decision and that he is repeating talking points given to him by higher-ups. Because just re-using the same theme song is
so unoriginal that I just can't quite believe it was his choice.
It's obviously just a bit of PR speak for "We know the theme is iconic and didn't want to risk alienating people by doing something different."
Still, they could have kept the theme but just rearranged it slightly.
God, even a new arrangement would have been better than just flat-out re-creating the GoT theme.
It doesn't even make
sense to use as a composition because the internal logic of the theme is now lacking. That composition was designed both to establish some of the emotional themes that would be at play in the show -- a complex combination of a sense of longing and sadness, a sense of tension, a sense of hope and optimism, and a sense of dread -- but also to use those emotions to guide us through the map that would familiarize the audience with the complex geography and cultures of Planetos. There is a
reason the bridge occurs as we see the Wall, for instance.
But with this show... there's no real connection to the visuals. The ebb and flow of the composition is lost because the visuals we're seeing aren't connected to different themes or emotions. The visual we're seeing is a literal river of blood; this is the kind of visual that should be accompanied by a composition that evokes primarily feelings of dread and horror and disgust. The HotD theme ought to be
darker than the the GoT theme song. Which is appropriate, since this show is about a single family violently splintering in a way that even
Game of Thrones was never really about.
Reusing the GoT theme is just such an act of artistic cowardice, and it does such a disservice to the show. It takes away from
House of the Dragon developing its own distinct artistic identity.